ED can benefit the student immensely at the most generous need-based schools, as ED increases the chance of admission to be able to get that rich finaid.
“Early in this thread someone said EA was more competitive at Georgetown than RA. I would be very grateful if someone could explain this to me.”
So Georgetown’s EA rate was 12% for class of 2022, their overall rate was 14.5%, and if you back out the numbers given in their press releases, that implies the RD rate was 15%. This is the opposite of schools that have ED and even SCEA. MIT and Cal Tech I think are the only other schools that have this kind of relationship between EA and RD.
@SJ2727 you hit on the scheme part, and it affects all applicants regardless of legacy. If the student is told they have greater odds by making the ED commitment then in some cases they’re buying a load of malarkey. Duke had what 882(?) ED accepted students but 52% were either students of color or international students or both. So regardless of whether an ED applicant falls into that category or the white US citizen category either way they’re going for one of 450 spots…less actually. Now of that ~450 spots they’ll probably give a certain percentage to different genders, so it’s probably more like one spot out of 300? 250? Less? In an applicant pool that was DRUMMED UP by mass emailings to almost 5000. So where exactly was the advantage to the ED applicants legacy or no? In my opinion there is none. It’s not in the student’s interest to buy into the scheme to help universities build rankings while crushing very well qualified kids in mid December.
On Georgetown- thanks @theloniusmonk for backing out the calcs. At their info session, Gtown said they only admit via EA the applicants that they absolutely know they’d admit regardless of what the rest of the applicant pool looks like, so it tends to be more selective.
Btw Gtown did a good job of disincentivizing my D to apply
no bumping applicant numbers there!
@ApplestoApples89 , see, the thing is, ED worked for my daughter. She did have a better chance ED, and it worked for her. And it’s worked for many other people too. But it doesn’t work for everyone. It is less competitive, but that doesn’t mean automatic. People should understand that. If you think it’s a “scheme”, then you think so regardless of outcome and shouldn’t apply using it in the first place.
Clearly though you have an almost gospel opinion on this that argument doesn’t impact, so I’m not engaging further on this topic here. It’s very simple though: it works for a lot of people, but obviously it can’t work for everyone.
“ED can benefit the student immensely at the most generous need-based schools, as ED increases the chance of admission to be able to get that rich finaid.”
Ok, but why couldn’t that student get that financial aid with EA? Are you implying that EA and SCEA admits get less FA than ED admits? That would be counter to economic theory, the ED student is locked in, you can charge whatever price you want, the EA kid is not locked in, you may have to compete by lowering prices (i.e. offering more financial aid) to get the student.
“But I’m going to bring it down to a really concrete level: they’re wronged by the ED PROCESS which in my opinion is a scheme that helps universities get rankings and does NOT benefit students. If a student is a legacy indirectly pressured to apply to ED when it really just adds to the application numbers, that’s wrong. That’s not ok. Not in the students interest.”
Look, ED is not in the student’s best interest, I agree there, but you almost seem to imply that 100% of legacies who apply ED with good stats should get in, and that seems a little I don’t know, unrealistic.
“Your emotions aside Duke does not admit on as you put it “an arbitrary” basis. They take the best of the best. The elements beyond the students control are the applications of others that stand out.”
You really think the basketball players are going to class? They sell out their school for the basketball program, I’d use a harsher word, but this is a family show.
@SJ2727 I don’t think it’s a matter of opinion at this point. The fact that you got good results doesn’t mean it’s not a scheme to boost rankings. And I am not an applicant, not the student, not my case. I know someone who was impacted by this scheme. You cannot look at Duke’s numbers and realistically state that ED applicants got an advantage over RD. Maybe by a percentage point or two once you divide the two halves and look at actual spots available per demographic in relation to the drummed up applicant pool. But what these students really did get was a lot of needless pressure when it would be fine and more competitive for everyone to find out in April and compare financial aid offers from multiple schools. Final point: if Duke’s RD pool is 28,000 and the RD admit rate is 6% but you’re vying for one of 250 spaces in an ED pool of 5000 how is it worth it? If chances are so slim regardless why go through the stress only to help universities get better rankings? The fact that some people get in doesn’t make it in the students’ interests to be part of this scheme.
“not an applicant, not the student, not my case”?
Really? You have two posts in the Duke application discussion and the rest of your posts are in this thread bashing Duke’s ED system.
@theloniusmonk I don’t in any way believe all legacies should get in. But in my truthful opinion if a legacy is well qualified (and by that I mean more than scores and GPA) and they come from a family that has supported the school over years, then there should be no “factors beyond their control” that prevent an offer. They should get in. In this case Duke COULD HAVE offered more spots over last year considering their successful ad campaign to get more applicants, (they had something like 20% more applicants this year) but they chose not to give more offers over last year because it comes across that it’s more important to them that they break a new record than think about the effects on their alumni and the student applicants.
Yes @SJ2727 I do feel for the student and I’ve seen what happened this year happen to other legacies the last three-four years so I decided to speak up.
@Jon234 , see posts 101 and 103 if you haven’t seen them yet. I look at it as Georgetown really just cherry picks in the EA round and is extremely selective for EA. It doesn’t mean that if you applied EA, you are at a disadvantage. If you got deferred (my son did), you just weren’t one of the tippy top, and you’re now in the RD round where you have a better chance.
I didn’t look at the data, but I wonder if GT is down because they are a little more work than many of their competitors. If you have students who are just applying to say the top 20s, and applying to a LOT of high level schools, it might be easy to just skip GT due to their non Common App, send all scores, 3 SAT subject test, application. ALso maybe word is out that EA GT doesn’t give you an advantage. So take some extra time to do the bit of extra work (administratively) that GT requires.
@ApplestoApples89, assuming a student is going to apply anyway, ED only boosts application numbers if the school accepts a greater proportion of the class during the ED round. In other words an application submitted during the ED and RD rounds are counted the same.
If Duke were really just trying to reduce their acceptance rate they would be more likely to accept the student you write about.
Like @Nocreativity1 I have never heard a school say they would hold it against a leagcy if they didn’t apply ED. I have heard many schools that give preference to legacies say that if a legacy chose to apply RD they would not receive the legacy boost. That would just put them on even footing with everyone else. The advice I’ve seen given to students who are enthusiastic about their parent’s school but can’t apply ED for financial reasons is to write a note to the school explaining that it is their top or one of their top choices but that they need to compare FA offers.
ApplestoApples89 - Although schools might like ED because it boosts their yield and selectivity numbers, I think the thing that appeals to them most is that it gives them much more control and certainty than they used to have when building a class, which schools value greatly. Back in the day, most schools had no idea which admits would ultimately attend and just had to hope for the best in any given year. Now, half (or more) of the uncertainty is eliminated thanks to ED.
As far as benefits to students, besides knowing a few month earlier (and maybe saving the trouble of writing supplements and paying application fees), I think the main benefit is that in some circumstances, it gives an applicant who knows where they want to go a better chance of getting into that school. That’s what happened in the case of SJ2727’s daughter, and good for her. However, I agree with you that when you are talking about ultra competitive schools like Duke, the ED advantage is much less than meets the eye for an unhooked kid because so many of those slots go to recruited athletes, first generation, URM’s, connected kids etc … Also, even where the ED advantage is real, there are definite negatives for students. If you are a student who doesn’t know where you want to go, or where you can afford to go (and therefore can’t apply ED), it puts you at a disadvantage because so many slots are filled through ED that your chances of getting into any particular school RD are worse than what they otherwise would have been. That’s the flip side of the ED advantage coin. Also, when you go ED, you limit your options, particularly financial options, which is usually not a good thing.
My own opinion is that ED has gotten completely out of control and whatever positives it has for students, are outweighed by the negatives. That said, I wouldn’t go so far as to call it a scam or a scheme.
As far as the legacy thing goes, I don’t really have an opinion. That said, I will note that all of the high stat kids from my kid’s HS who applied ED as legacies (even a couple of double legacies) to Ivy-level schools were either rejected or deferred (although none of them applied to Duke).
Apple “Now I’m gonna have to call BS on your entire narrative at this point because earlier, you said that Duke nominated your kid to be a Robertson scholar and you said that the student that I know if this student was so great would be a Robertson scholar semi finalist too. But you have also just let us know that your kid was not an early decision applicant which means you have no experience whatsoever with the arbitrariness of the ED process or the lack of connection between ED and becoming a Robertson Scholar. Zero. I think you glossed over that little detail”
Hate to respond to personal attacks but as follows:
-
Never said if your candidate was great would have been nominated for Robertson. Did use the Robertson as an example to show that Duke AOs thoroughly review candidates and that it is not an arbitrary process.
-
Never said my kid was ED at Duke. Actually REA at another school. Not the result we wanted but no tears or complaints.
-
All of the above doesn’t change the reality that Duke AO does push some applicants to Robertson semi final round once applications are reviewed and strong candidates are identified in both RD and RD.
So no detail glossed over just not about an individual kids experience. But as long as I responded please answer the following…
If your student had been accepted would you so much as utter a word of protest about the injustices of ED or would you have thought it fair that he got in and moved on having your sense of entitlement fulfilled? Sorry you have indirectly answered that previously.
ED isn’t evil because one “highly” qualified legacy kid thought he was guaranteed admission and his advocate is upset because it didn’t work out. I only hope for the candidate that this amounts to his/hers “greatest” disappointment in life.
ED worked out for my D because the odds were better- her school doesn’t let athletes get quite as much of a bump as some other schools and my kid wanted/needed the bump in her chances because of borderline scores. I’m obviously happy it worked out for her, but would be just as happy if there were no such thing as ED and everyone entered the playing field at the same time.
@Sue22 that’s incorrect because they are engaged in advertising to get more applicants and it works. The number of applicants that were intending to apply ED or RD isn’t fixed. It grew with the emails and ads. If ads didn’t increase the pool they wouldn’t use them. And the reason more apply ED is based on the malarkey that they’re getting an advantage. I mean technically they are until you realize that it was never competition for one spot out of 882. It was always half that, < 450. And then somewhere around half of that 450 based on gender.
With ED heating up more than ever, it’ll be interesting if anything comes of DOJ’s requests to preserve records issued last spring to schools who may name-share ED applicants or may have done so in the past. It’s been a while since I looked at this, but back then it seemed to me that there’s likely an antitrust issue (Sherman Act).
NYU is notorious for bad FA, so why such a huge jump in ED applicants? It is not even that great a school other than a few specific programs. “Irrationally exuberannt” behaviors for name-brand seekers?
“ED advantage is much less than meets the eye for an unhooked kid because so many of those slots go to recruited athletes, first generation, URM’s, connected kids etc …”
Yeah but those slots go to legacies as well, they’re part of the group you described. Legacy may not a hook but it’s a distinct advantage, the race thread has analysis of what hooks including legacies Harvard gave the most advantage to (data10’s posts has some good work there). Usually legacy is a proxy for wealth so it’s possible the legacy kids getting rejected ED may not have the wealth the colleges look for.