Princeton, Williams, Georgetown’s application numbers down- Loosing charm?

@Nocreativity1 here I am replying to you even though I said I wouldn’t but that’s because you’re now saying it’s about entitlement. It’s not. When an alum is told if your kid doesn’t go ED were going to hold that against them, and then they do but get deferred or rejected despite being HIGHLY qualified, it does look like a scheme designed to shore up ranking. Of course, congratulations that Duke worked out for you! You’ve already told us this is proof they only take the best. Correction: The best of the best. If Duke celebrates circular reasoning, I can certainly see how you found your home there.

@milee30 , the eye roll purely was in response to the comment that we need an eye roll emoticon… to show that we have one!

Edit: oh, I see the comment it responded to has been edited out…

@theloniusmonk opinion- " their marketing of rankings is better, by a wide margin, than anybody else’s, "

my opinion is THE/WSJ is better if for no other reason than it includes liberal arts colleges (Amherst/Williams). For anyone except engineers the LACs provide whatever education students need. (FYI u. Chicago has no engineering either. And some of the Ivies are weak at engineering too.)) Amherst has 10 NSF funded undergrad biomedical/biological research summer slots which is about the same number as research universities with 20,000 undergrads. High school and admissions officers’ “opinions” worth 20% in USNWR is worthless. in WSJ/THE they solicit opinions of research “teaching scholars” for that component. NOTE: swarthmore is a LAC with strong engineering

Calling ED a “scheme” and “unethical” only works if you would still be calling it that following an acceptance, not just ranting about a denial. Everyone knows that all these colleges end up rejecting many qualified applicants and nothing is guaranteed… don’t they?

Incidentally re the UC mailings. We are instate and received exactly zero from the UCs, who are known to court
OOS students to help meet their budgets… so that may be the motivation more than just application numbers.

Also @Nocreativity1 I never said I was an alum of Duke or that they were promised anything. What a disgraceful allegation. ED is a scheme designed to increase rankings and is NOT in the students interests. I can have an opinion without it being my application or university.

@SJ2727 True. Personally I agree with the second thing you wrote: a lot of qualified kids get rejected but in my opinion the ED scheme just locks them in and doesn’t let them shop financial aid packages around, puts huge pressure on legacies, and ultimately “factors beyond their control” end up making the difference in who gets in and who gets deferred once the applicant has established themself as well qualified. Personally I think it would be better to just have Spring admissions like they used to.

@SJ2727 Applying ED isn’t possible for everyone, high EFC applicants can’t commit early. They have to wait for RD to see which schools are going to offer merit scholarships. Every objection isn’t due to sour grapes of denial. Many students can get accepted to most schools but can’t get family, college’s financial aid or loans to pay their COA.

LOl about this: “puts huge pressure on legacies”. Must keep people up at night worrying about how unfair ED is for a a student deciding to take advantage of things other than his or own achievements in order to be accepted to a school he/she does not really qualify for despite having every advantage in life. Tough breaks! The expectations for legacy should be much higher than they are for students who are not legacies.

@CupCakeMuffins that is really true. If you’re getting a full ride or you’re not needing aid then ED is sold as a great way to increase your odds. But then they email everyone to get more and more applications so they can break a new record, take fewer kids, increase their ranking. Meantime the student gets emotionally committed to a school in the Fall that in many cases rejects them for “factors beyond their control.” Then they have like two weeks to file new applications, study for finals, celebrate Christmas if they do that. I said it’s a scheme and I think it is.

Are we having fun yet?

Yes @lostaccount of course it must be that alllllll deferred legacies are unqualified saps who were just working the system to get into a school they don’t deserve to attend. None of them work hard. None of them overcome anything. None of them achieve great things just by hard work. They’re alllllll privileged! ?

@CupCakeMuffins , that wasn’t my point. I wasn’t defending ED per se. I was simply saying that one’s opinion on the merits of the scheme shouldn’t change depending on the outcome to you personally. (I got in - what a fantastic achievement! I was denied - what a terrible unethical practice!)

@lostaccount the reason I said it puts pressure on legacies is if they’re informed that not applying ED will be looked down upon, then yes that puts pressure on them to apply ED, get emotionally committed to the school, and then have to deal with the fallout if it doesn’t work out for “factors beyond their control.” I know it’s such a shock to think that bad things can happen even to legacies, that even legacies sometimes are actually highly qualified but get deferred/rejected. Hard to believe these privileged, entitled, saps could ever be qualified. Hard to believe unfair, dare I say it, ARBITRARY decisions sometimes get made in admissions but it happens. And when it does, it doesn’t feel great.

@sj2727 I agree. Often people who aren’t effected personally, they start defending unjust policies. ED qualifiers are one example and Asians qualifiers of Ivies are another.

@suzy100 ??? Thanks for making me laugh. I probably never would have written anything about this student but it really gets under my skin how many people go along with the ED scheme all to the benefit of the school. What exactly does the 17-18 year old high school kid get in return? If it works out, they know where they’re going to school in December instead of April. Why is that such a great deal for the student? We have really gotten to the point where we can’t wait three months? We have to know right away? I would never recommend ED to anyone who isn’t being recruited as an athlete because they just sign with total certainty that they’re in. Otherwise it’s not worth it. All you’re doing is helping schools like Duke issue bragging press releases about record number of applicants and record low percentage of acceptance. Then they get rewarded with better US News ranking but the disappointed applicants get crushed. Not a good deal.

@anon145 USnews ranks LACs, too, in a seperate category. It even ranks schools according to best undergraduate teaching if you think this is the most important indicator for you. As others commented, all ranking systems will have their pros and cons.

Apples- “When an alum is told if your kid doesn’t go ED were going to hold that against them, and then they do but get deferred or rejected despite being HIGHLY qualified, it does look like a scheme designed to shore up ranking”.

“I never said…,they were promised anything”.

Your first statement certainly does contradict your second by suggesting an expectation of acceptance or promise. If not why are you so upset? If your not implying a promise was made how were you wronged?
That is the definition of entitlement. A quid pro quo. I am alum, if child applies early they will get in. Child doesn’t get in, it’s a scheme because kid was entitled to admission.

I highly doubt Duke would tell alumni they will “hold it against” a legacy for not going ED. However they do say that you won’t get the full benefit of legacy if you don’t go ED. That doesn’t make it a scheme.

“HIGHLY qualified” as you write (even in all caps) is subjective and those with eyes across all applicants made the decision. You have no basis to dispute the validity having only seen one side of the decision.

Lastly my kid opted for another school although he loved Duke (and no he had no hooks, URM, legacy etc before you start another narrative). I am neither Duke lover or hater, just hate to see people try and portray kids that get disappointing news as victims as opposed to empowered to succeed beyond an admissions decision.

@Nocreativity1 I just refuse to believe this is so complicated for you. But I’m going to bring it down to a really concrete level: they’re wronged by the ED PROCESS which in my opinion is a scheme that helps universities get rankings and does NOT benefit students. If a student is a legacy indirectly pressured to apply to ED when it really just adds to the application numbers, that’s wrong. That’s not ok. Not in the students interest.

Now I’m gonna have to call BS on your entire narrative at this point because earlier, you said that Duke nominated your kid to be a Robertson scholar and you said that the student that I know if this student was so great would be a Robertson scholar semi finalist too. But you have also just let us know that your kid was not an early decision applicant which means you have no experience whatsoever with the arbitrariness of the ED process or the lack of connection between ED and becoming a Robertson Scholar. Zero. I think you glossed over that little detail.

Also, the idea that all these students are victims of the ED scheme does not mean they aren’t empowered. It’s not binary. The student I know has a few great options and it’s only January! My point is, was, and remains that Duke did a massive campaign to get applicants to Duke’s benefit but not to the benefit of the students who applied believing the decision to admit or deny wouldn’t hinge on “factors beyond their control.”

It’s not just athletes that benefit from ED, because clearly legacies do too. Just not all of them. ED can be a very strategic decision for some, and often those “some” are totally unhooked; and while I understand it’s not fair on those who need to compare financial aid packages, if the situation exists and people can strategically use it then they will. And obviously for ED, a vast majority of applicants (not just legacies) will be emotionally committed to the college. But anyone looking at the numbers for competitive colleges will know that not much is certain. And yes, at some point it’s subjective (which is not the same as arbitrary). Two legacies with equal stat and one place available, adcom just happens to like one essay more than the other, or something like that. There are no auto-admit criteria here.