Rate of Admission Article

<p>Apparently there is another piece of legislation to increase the admit rate of instate students. The article provides a comparison of VA schools to other selective state universities. Take a look at the chart on the far right side of the page. No wonder it is so hard to get into UC schools. UCLA 89.6% instate and UCSD 93% instate. </p>

<p>It turns out being “best value” school(s) has helped the argument that our most selective state schools could increase the oos tuition rate and make up the delta in terms of lost revenues.</p>

<p>[Rate</a> of Admission](<a href=“http://beta.connectionnewspapers.com/article.asp?article=325186&paper=71&cat=104]Rate”>http://beta.connectionnewspapers.com/article.asp?article=325186&paper=71&cat=104)</p>

<p>The fundamental issue I think, is how progress in both elementary and higher public education in the US by that irritating issue of states’ “rights”. If education were a more national responsibility the OOS/IS distinction shouldn’t exist. It makes no sense why a Virginia student who lives just across a state border should have to pay so much to attend school across that border, especially given how much Nova people commute up north and are intricately linked economically to regions outside the state.</p>

<p>Education is a public good. The public benefits to society that come with education do not magically stop upon encountering state borders. After all, we have good reason to believe that the economies of Baltimore and DC benefit from a well-educated Nova population and vice versa, so it’s not like students attending school across state borders are being “free riders”.</p>

<p>UC schools are hard for several reasons. Most of them range from being quite good to very good. The instate applicant pool is also VERY high quality in California…very high income and very heavily asian. </p>

<p>The IS/OOS distinction exists because universities receive a huge portion of their funding from the states in which they reside. Shifting responsibility for those funds from states to the federal government wouldn’t necessarily accomplish anything.</p>

<p>The education system is too large to leave it up to the federal gov’t. There’s just too many differences amongst the states to give control over schools to the gov’t at a national level. Look at No Child Left Behind, it’s a miserable failure because it’s too broad, but can’t be specific because each state is too different. I think as long as kids’ parents are paying taxes to a state, and that money is going to schools, IS should have preference. I also think 2:1 is a healthy ratio. OOS students bring a lot to the University. However, since the state keeps slashing our budgets, and we’re relying more and more on our endowment, maybe it’s not right to limit OOS kids. I don’t think this is a good time for the state to be crossing out the huge cash flow from OOSers, or it needs to stop slashing the budget.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Only because the federal govt lacks the power to enforce a real national education system. It can only give financial incentives. It does not have direct power over the schools.</p>

<p>Our K-12 educational system is a “failure” because we educate everyone. If we kicked the bottom 50% of intellects to trade schools and the like we’d quickly “rise” compared to countries that “outperform” us like Hungary.</p>