Regretting my college choice

Buyers regret is not uncommon. D dealt with that probably up until orientation and room assignment - her choice was also based on money and she ended up in same town that she’s lived in all her life instead of some higher ranked LACs. She had an amazing experience, amazing new friends (you really don’t run into all your local HS friends the way you think you will) and solid academic foundation for led to Ivy grad school. Bonus - she had 0 debt.

I know it’s hard to let go, but start actively looking at class offerings, clubs, etc and focus forward. I’ll bet you’ll have a great time!

@scmom12 i’m glad to know that I’m not alone. All of my friends seem to have everything figured out. They all knew where they wanted to go, got in, and never looked back. I, the most indecisive one, had no clue, applied to 9 colleges (too many IMO), and worried right up until May 1st. But thank you for the advice! I have already started looking a little into clubs and classes and such!

I’ve been a CC member for a little over a year now. Y’all are so nice and kind, I wish I had reached out earlier in the year for advice and guidance. Perhaps I wouldn’t be in this situation if I had.

You are not alone. In fact, I’ll bet all your “together” friends may not be that way in private!. BTW, D committed to her school on April 30. Really, you are not the only one!

Close enough. I’d give the edge to UVA for sure, but it’s not a huge gap imho.

For me UVA, Carolina, and Michigan are in their own tier . . . but still wouldn’t pay OOS for them unless our son was considering an even more expensive private school.

I just can’t help but think that if I had started this thread a month ago and not have made this decision yet that y’all would be urging me to go to UVA… I mean who in their right mind turns down Virginia (and Michigan for that matter)?!

@jw1615 No, I think we would have still suggested OSU. If my DS were comparing our large strong state flag ship vs UVA with debt, strong in-state wins. UVA is good, it’s just not $20,000-$30,000 better than any of the strong state schools you mentioned.

My S17 had his heart set on Wisconsin-Madison. He liked Minnesota but loved Wisconsin. Minnesota came in with a nice scholarship. Wisconsin gave him nothing. He made the decision to go to Minnesota and has not looked back. I am sure that up until he starts school in the fall he will have thoughts about wanting to go to Wisconsin, but he just could not justify it for the debt he would have to take on to go there. Wisconsin is #44 in the 2017 US News vs. Minnesota which is #71. He will have excellent employment options for either one.

Come November 25th, he will be maroon and gold through and through as Minnesota hosts Wisconsin!

I really feel that you will be in the same boat. We visited OSU and it is a fantastic university in an absolutely great college city.

I think many of us would have been voting for OSU a month ago.

OP, I just plugged $32,000 into a loan repayment calculator and came up with 120 payments (so, monthly for 10 years) of Monthly Loan Payment: $371.98 that you WON’T be paying because you chose tOSU over UVA.

I agree with the other posters who have pointed out that in the grand scheme of things, tOSU and UVA are both excellent schools.

I think some buyer’s remorse is natural. Let yourself feel it for 24 hours and then move on to all of the wonderful opportunities that await you in the fall!

It’s clear from your first post that you thought this out thoroughly based on what was most important to you and made your decision accordingly. If you have played it safe your entire life and you HAD chosen UVA, I guarantee you that you’d be on here freaking out right now about paying that extra $32K (and possible more debt over and above that) to go to a school that might be “too southern, too Greek, too elitist,” and you’d be reading the negative UVA threads over and over getting yourself even more worked up. :wink:

You made the right choice. Now go buy some OSU stuff with all that money you are saving and start getting excited!

For many students, it makes sense to pick the less expensive undergrad choice and then save your debt capacity for graduate or professional school.

@jw1615 in my opinion you have a few misconceptions that are clouding your judgement.

As I said before the rankings are negligible in this case. I have been in the working world for thirty years. I am in a position to accept and review applications and hire. NOT ONCE did I look at or consider undergrad rankings in the hiring process. At this stage in my life my social circle is many higher level managers in various occupations and industries. I’ve talked to many of them about this site and what you kids are being told. NOT A SINGLE ONE takes ranking into consideration. If all things were equal they would call you both in for an interview to see how you carry yourself, what you can offer the company, will you fit in with other employees etc. The decision will be made based on the interview not ranking. If they see you graduated from a public flagship they are impressed. Most really won’t care that one is ranked slightly higher than the other.

Ohio State is one of the largest universities in the country. Why do you think you would be at a disadvantage if you want to change majors? My son changed majors and it was simple and they were very helpful. If you can’t find a major at tOSU you can’t find one anywhere.

My only concern for you at this point is your attitude. If you go in with a negative attitude you will have a negative experience. Please embrace your decision. Celebrate that you made the right choice. Know that you are leaps and bounds ahead of so many who are taking on unmanageable student debt. You’re the winner here!!!

@jpc763 thank you!! I hope you’re right!!
@GnocchiB I’m flattered you would go to all that effort just to show me how much I’d have to pay back :slight_smile: thank you!! Even seeing the price differential I just can’t help but wonder anyways… as @1Dreamer said and I agree with, I would probably be freaking out no matter where I decided to go.
@1Dreamer I almost wish I hadn’t read those negative UVA threads. I of course stumbled across then on April 29th which is what complicated my decision :frowning: ignorance truly is bliss
@bhs1978 wow thank you for that insight! I understand that you’re most likely right and the difference is negligible but it’s just hard to let go of something that’s been a dream (leaving Ohio and going to a good school) for so long. It’s weird because I’ve spent the better part of the last 4 years dreaming about college and deciding where to go and what to do and now that my time is here it just feels a little anticlimactic. After all this time spent searching, writing esssys, going to interviews, studying, and getting good grades I end up at my state flagship…

Re: a few posts back.

You won’t be paying that ~$370 per month on the ~$32k in debt you avoided by choosing Ohio State.

That $32k could be a nice downpayment on a house, a Mercedes instead of a Dodge (nothing wrong with Dodge of course…), or a whole lot of stock (etc.).

Many of us usually tell kids to stay home at their flagship – unless the OOS public offers something the in-state does not – because no OOS flag is worth all the extra money.

You made the right choice. Most people on here would have suggested OSU. Now get yourself to the 'Shoe in September and forget you ever had doubts. :slight_smile:

I’d like to offer a comment that I have told all my children. School is about getting an education and growing. The most important decisions you will be making are what classes/professors you will taking, not which school is better. There are great professors at OSU and bad professors. The same is true of UVA. If you take the time to find the best professors, you will get a great education and grow. Spending time finding the better professors (not the ones that give easy A’s) and classes is much more important than UVA or OSU. As for getting that first job because of a school’s reputation, I do believe that there is some truth to it. However, for you life as a whole (including you as a person and all future jobs), getting the best education, via taking the best classes, is the most important thing.

@privateID Very well said. I think sometimes there is too much pressure to attend what is perceived as the “best” school, which does not exist, as everyone is different.

OP, after reading some of the posts about UVA on CC, I’m glad my daughter was not accepted there. It may be highly ranked, but IMO, it would not be a good fit for many students like my daughter. I think you made a good choice and will be happy.

Also “well I do want to live in Virginia or at least the DMV area”. I had to laugh when I read that. The DMV area is VERY expensive, traffic is horrible, and for my family - not worth it. My husband and I live in the DMV and we plan to relocate to a saner calmer place when our youngest goes off to college in two years - and we still might choose a big city (or the suburbs), but it will not have the stressful environment of the DMV. I don’t think Charlottesville is considered in the DMV and is probably a nice place, but the DC burbs are just crazy. You won’t be missing anything - just take the opportunity to visit DC when you get a chance - it is an interesting place, but it’s a place that most people would rather not and can’t afford to live. My husband was telling me about an intern in his organization who was living in a house with 12 other people and was sharing a room with a meth-head. That’s all she could find that she could afford.

Take your choice and be glad you made the right one! Good Luck!

Thank you all for the nice and reassuring comments! I just got an email about ordering football tickets for OSU so that’s definitely helping me to get psyched about being a Buckeye this fall! I think UVA will always be a “what if” kind of thing. Hopefully my first semester at THE Ohio State University erases any doubts I have. Also @privateID your comment was honestly really helpful/eye opening. As my english teacher told me, “hard work does all the talking, it doesn’t matter where you go.”

where you are now will not determine your future. My kids went to schools less challenging than where they got in but are a success in the fields they choose. Look forward and not back. Questioning yourself will only stifle your creativity. btw, my dad (now retired) was a very successful architect. Did not go to any top school. Would not spend the money for his kids to go to a top school… and to this day, will say the passion is what will make the difference and what will you make successful. So light that fire within…

on a another note…i know a gal who went to Ohio for undergrad architecture and then worked and now at Michigan for masters. She would have been instate for UVA but choose Ohio.