Rural or city school- which is safer with Covid19?

My D is deciding between 4 colleges. 2 are in cities but have distinct campuses and 2 are in small towns/rural settings. Is anyone else looking at this as a criteria for college selection in the wake of the coronavirus? We feel like a smaller town might be safer right now. Both rural schools are within an hour of a major city so healthcare would be available if needed. Also seems like the rural schools might have a slightly better chance of not being on-line in the fall. Any thoughts?

Obviously we are also looking at many other factors to make our decision but was just wondering if anyone else was thinking about this.

This describes current conditions in the U.S.:

https://www.usnews.com/news/health-news/articles/2020-03-29/counties-without-coronavirus-are-mostly-rural-poor

I think it depends on where your rural area is. I’m in a rural area in NJ, but everyone commutes and socializes outside the immediate area, so we have cases. If you’re talking rural in ND, maybe it makes a difference. I think rural in the northeast or southeast still has a big exposure.

I don’t think it will impact our decisions because students are coming to those rural schools from all over, bringing their germs and visitors with them.

COVID19 is here to stay, just as seasonal flu is. There will be a vaccine in a year or so. The chances of something else killing a young, healthy person are probably higher. I wouldn’t make this a criteria of selecting a college at all.

Any more thoughts on this? I guess not so much as to which option would be “safer” but more so which one would be more likely to be open in the fall? We live outside of Boston and have not hit the peak here yet but it is coming in the next week or two. Not sure if I see Boston letting the thousands of college kids flood back into the city this fall. But I maybe see rural Indiana letting 2000 kids onto a residential campus.

On the flip side, better access to more advanced health care in an urban area if needed.

“students are coming to those rural schools from all over, bringing their germs and visitors with them”

Yup. I do not see how a rural college can open if covid-19 is still widespread in urban areas. One of the entire points of a college or university is that it brings in very smart students from all over the place, including all over the US and all around the world.

Many of us are concerned about whether we or our children will be on campus in the fall, and whether classes and/or labs will be open. However, I do not think that there is much that we can do about it right now. I am trying to make sure my family is safe and to get through this week without being infected by anything. Next week I will worry about next week.

For students who need to pick a university to put down their deposit they have to look past next week. I think that I would ignore the covid-19 issue, and decide where I wanted to be after this is over.

I’d choose based on whatever criteria you’d use without the virus.

I don’t think that at this point you can try to predict which schools might be more likely to be open in the fall. It seems as if the virus impact not only varies by population, but the timelines are different for different areas around the country. Some cities are projecting their “peak” coronavirus times, with some now (like NYC), and I read another city was in late June (ugh). So while a small town might have very low rates right now, it could just mean that the virus hasn’t really hit there yet, and they could be less likely to open in fall.

But also, the timing might not matter, period. Since colleges have kids coming in from all over, the infection rate of the college town may not matter at all. Then you also have variance in the state stay at home orders (some strict, some average, some states don’t even have them yet). For example, I’m in Ohio and we were an early shutdown state. Does this mean we will “reopen” late, because we were conservative? Or reopen early, because we flattened our curve? No one knows yet.

The uncertainty is very hard, but I don’t think there is any way to get answers yet. Until we have a city/area that is coming down from its virus curve, then starts to make some “reopening” plans and we see how that goes, we don’t have any answers as to how we start moving back to normal from this and how it will go for schools.

Rural locations are safer in general - from viruses as well as from crime. Densely populated areas see higher spread of viruses.

My son is still at his somewhat rural school because they have MUCH fewer cases locally than we do at home. Our town has virtually the same population as his college town. We have 154 more cases and ours continue to grow by 30+ per day.

We’re 15 miles from a major airport. We have both train and bus lines through our town. The population density is significantly higher in our town.

He’s 150 miles from a major airport. There is no train anywhere near him. The bus system was primarily used by students and they’re all gone. He’s surrounded by farms.

All that being said, I would wager that his fall semester will be online.

When you look at the maps of states, most cases are in the cities. We have rural counties that have no cases but they also have no colleges, no malls, no businesses except a gas station or a small store. If they have a ‘big’ store, it is likely a farm or feed store. Rural rural, not just low population.

We have low population areas like Vail, Aspen, and Telluride where there were lots of cases because people brought the virus in and then it spread.

Even colleges that only have 2000 students have a concentrated population. The county may only have 10,000 residents, but 3000 or so are in a small area with lots of contact every day. My daughter’s school was in a small city. She probably had contact with the same 100 people every day (roommates, teammates, classmates, profs, lunch counter workers). It would be the same at a rural colleges.

As reported in USA Today, nascent perceptions on this question may favor attendance at rural colleges:

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/education/2020/04/14/coronavirus-college-admissions-fafsa-financial-aid/2986961001/

I would think about avoiding a current huge hot spot, maybe, but I think the advice to choose where you would if the virus were not here is good.

[quote=“merc81, post:13, topic:2088518”]

As reported in USA Today, nascent perceptions on this question may favor attendance at rural colleges:

So interesting as Catholic and Fordham are two schools my D was accepted to and part of what I was referencing in the original post. She has now narrowed it down to Catholic and 3 more rural colleges. She’s having trouble deciding so the chances of being on campus in the fall is just another decision point for her.

An isolated college with little or no routine contact with the outside world (e.g. Deep Springs College) may be the safest from the virus, if the incoming student cohort and instructors and staff for the year are virus-free.

However, if anyone does bring the virus in, the isolation may be problematic due to difficulty getting to medical services.

Hard to know what the Fall is going to look like. Wondering if students will still be on remote learning in fall.

I think you are asking the wrong question. The bigger question I would ask, during this unprecedented pandemic, is will this college have the financial resources to survive for the next year or two? Financial solvency is a real concern.

I just read an article from the Duke Chronicle that they are very concerned about financial difficulties and are setting up short-term and long-term task forces to address budget shortfalls and the impact the coming/current recession will have on the university. If a university with $8.5 billion endowment is concerned, what does that say for the less well funded public and private colleges?

Massachusetts released Covid case data at the individual town level today. Williamstown has a higher per capita rate than Boston.

Given that testing remains very uneven across geographies, I would be careful in interpreting the data beyond the fact that the virus is more widely spread than the data indicates.