Should kids with sub-2.0 GPAs be expelled?

<p>While I’m not in support of outright expelling students who have sub-2.0 GPA’s, I think the consequences of such a policy would be intriguing. If students at a certain school honestly believed they’d be expelled if they did poorly, wouldn’t the academic achievement at such a school skyrocket? Students would surely perform far better on all things education-related, which would increase their future successes.</p>

<p>Consider: If the United States instituted some sort of expulsion policy (or at least suspension) for all public schools, wouldn’t it be a step in the right direction? As in, wouldn’t the US start to catch up on the likes of South Korea and Finland? Of course, those with extenuating circumstances would be exempted, but it’s still an interesting idea.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Education is very much a state’s issue. So a federal law mandating some sort of expulsion policy for all public schools would be unprecedented, and therefore unlikely. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I doubt it. Some students simply have no desire to be at school. Expulsion would be a welcome relief to them. Of course, this is speculation, but that’s the vibe I get when I’m around underachieving students.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Only to the extent that if you remove the bottom of any distribution, its average would go up.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Of course not.</p>

<p>No. Students should be expelled if they violate school rules, and having a 2.0 GPA is not one of them. I kind of get your point that those with low GPAs tend to be the “troublemakers”, but still, why not just expel those who disobey the rules instead of wiping out an entire group of students? I’m pretty sure not EVERY 2.0 student disobeyed school rules.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>LOL :)! That’s very true, and I’m sure you weren’t intentionally being facetious there ;).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I know some school districts are actually taking the opposite of your proposed approach. Some school districts have “magnet” schools, in which underachieving students are integrated with high achieving students pulled from around the county. Apparently, hanging around high-achieving students helps underachievers be better students. Or more cynically, the school district officials are just trying to average out the underachieving portion by congregating all the smart students at one school :p.</p>

<p>I understand the point of expulsion being a welcome relief to some students. But those are the small minority. Anyway, an expulsion policy would probably not work. But somehow, we as a country need to emphasize the importance of academic success. Everyone hears about colleges liking to see high GPA’s, but many students do not think four years in the future. They tell themselves that their grades will improve eventually. How about a rewards system for those that excel and a penalization system for those that fail? Nothing drastic or particularly favoring naturally smart youths, but something that recognizes those that work hard. (By ‘not favoring naturally smart youths’, I mean a not a system in which the better you are, the more benefits you get. Instead, it would simply have two options: work hard and receive perks, or slack off and receive penalties.)</p>

<p>I don’t think it really makes sense to try to think about the education system isolated by itself. The way the world is changing and is going to change is what is going to shape the future of education, not the ideas of education reformers.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>What kind of incentives and penalties?</p>

<p>I think there already are incentives for the hard-working: a decent shot at a happy future (stable job, discretionary income, etc.). And there already are penalties for the slackers: a less stable or desirable job, or even no job. However, those are long-term incentives, so I take you as saying that there need to be short-term incentives …?</p>

<p>This thread epitomizes the elitism on this board. And I applaud PoliticalProtege for not giving up, and I would join the debate if I had more energy.</p>

<p>how about you get to yell out at your principle during assembly with impunity if you do well; and if don’t do well then you have to demurely hold doors open for everyone.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I didn’t take you for one of those thread sabotagers, who thought that it’d be hip to jump in and start opposing every one of my viewpoints or creep my post history and make personal attacks or make dumb comments ;).</p>

<p>What kind of incentives and penalties? I can’t be sure. These kinds of consequences are given naturally by some parents–especially those of Asian descent. There’s a reason some cultures are more successful in education than others, and I’d say it’s motivation. Some students simply don’t care. But if we can find meaningful perks for those that work hard (not only those that get good grades) and penalties for those that slack off, I think students would perform better as a whole. The perks could be as simple as priority in lunch lines and free football games. Alternatively, penalties could include having to attend long review sessions on Saturdays (which would serve a double function–punishment and the resulting better grades from the increased study).</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That would also be punishment for the teachers :o. I think that teachers are stressed enough with grading papers and cut incomes, not to mention additional Saturday courses. </p>

<p>Teacher salaries in my state have been slashed 3% this year, and bonuses are completely gone. Teachers no longer get a bonus for each student that passes the AP exam. Given the economic recession, this isn’t surprising.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I agree - culture plays a part in one’s education. Some cultures seem to stress education over other cultures, but I don’t have much more to say on that. As always, there are numerous exceptions to every stereotype. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I fundamentally oppose perks because I feel as if high school nowadays is a little too sheltered. Before, a decade or so ago, there was no grade recovery. Now, teachers have to jump through hoops to fail a student. Teachers in my district have to do reams of paperwork just to give a student a D or F. Otherwise, a parent can sue the school and get that D or F legally reversed. Adding perks like shorter lunch lines and free football games further shelters students from the real world. </p>

<p>In the real world, there is no grade recovery. There is only hard work. There are no short lines at the buffet for hard workers. There are no free football game tickets for hard workers. Adding incentives to the system runs the risk of ingraining the idea of incentives, permanently, to some students’ minds. We don’t want the students working hard just for free football game tickets. We want them working hard so they have a decent shot at succeeding in society. We want them to sacrifice a little happiness now, for shot at a lot of happiness later. </p>

<p>This brings me to the marshmallow test, and to the question of deferring gratification. Some kids seem to be more adept at deferring gratification. Are they hard-wired to do so? Or can science manipulate the brains of kids that are not adept at deferring gratification to make the kids more adept? Or is the ability to defer gratification a learned skill? </p>

<p>Back to perks and incentives - I think that each of the kids needs a personal, one-on-one, talking to by the principals of their schools about the importance of an education. Perhaps the purpose of school is unclear for them. I think that most kids that don’t do well don’t have parents that stress the importance of school. In that case, principals can act as surrogate parents.</p>

<p>I would say no mainly because I suspect that on the rare occasion some of them are just bored. The best story I know of this is my brother. He never took a hard class in his life (think foods, study hall, & gym), graduated with a 2.0, but guess what? He got a 36 ACT his freshmen year. His excuse? He was just bored. He is a rare occasion, but I know that some of that group of sub par 2.0 are bored, so why should we necessarily punish them?</p>

<p>@IceQube about teacher’s being punished: That’s an interesting point that I had not considered. Then what would you suggest? I just think the penalty should somehow help them academically as well. If you gave them extra homework, they just wouldn’t do it. A mandatory Saturday class seems like the solution.</p>

<p>Anyway, the US education system needs reform. I’m not sure perks/penalties are the way to go, but it’s a thought. I really think that motivation is the issue, though. Bad teachers don’t help, but I believe anyone can learn something if they put their mind to it (extremely complex topics notwithstanding). </p>

<p>I know this sounds awful and elitist, but could separating schools by academic skill/intelligence help? That way, those of a lower intelligence wouldn’t be demoralized by their smarter peers and wouldn’t have to worry about lagging behind in class. Also, smarter students wouldn’t be held back by their less gifted peers and would be able to fluorish academically. As it stands, many public schools have unwritten divides. AP, Honors, and Regular classes are filled with entirely different student populations in my school, for example. Maybe separating these kids would be good for everyone.</p>

<p>@IceQube: Since when do those that work hard in life NOT receive perks? Perhaps it’s not football games, but it’s higher income and more success. I agree with you that deferred gratification is a great way to achieve success. However, most students aren’t as mature as you are. They need that extra push to discover their talents and succeed.</p>

<p>And as for principals acting as surrogate parents, I just don’t see students warming up and listening to them. At least not those that don’t care about school. Just like they blow school off, they’d blow off just about anything the principal says. That is, unless the principal threatened to throw them in Saturday classes. ;)</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s a good idea in theory, but I doubt that it will be implemented, for the reasons I listed. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Culture, the ability to defer gratification, and by extension, motivation, are all issues that play a role. My proposal is for principals to talk to students one-on-one about the importance of school, thus instilling in students what their parents may not have. I’m not sure about how to address some more biological issues. I’m also unsure about motivation - perks are “ehh” to me.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I personally feel motivated by my higher-achieving peers. I want to be like them. I don’t know how a chronically underachieving student would feel. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Yes, but those perks are more subtle than free football game tickets and shorter lunch lines. </p>

<p>–</p>

<p>A slight tangent:</p>

<p>I’ve always felt as if issues need to be addressed head-on, no matter what. E.g. I’ve always had this vision of raising my son/daughter and telling him/her what the meaning of life was at a very young age. And when they go to school, I have this vision of telling him/her that school is a proving ground, a kinder microcosm of society, and that school should be taken seriously, for if one cannot even succeed in school, he or she won’t succeed in society. Teachers generally won’t demean their students. But bosses may and can. In school, we are taught not to cheat. But in society, people do “cheat.” Just look at the corrupt politicians. I would run the marshmallow test on my kids, and explain to them the concept of deferred gratification. </p>

<p>So, applying my philosophy to those underachieving students, I’d like to see what a stern talking-to would do. What if the students were given a serious lecture by the principal, with the parents present, about the importance of doing well in school, complete with statistics and the consequences of not doing well. No sugar-coating. Just put it out there - if you don’t do well, you won’t get into college, and the odds will be against you. Principals should also explain to students the marshmallow test, and how the kids who participated in the original marshmallow test were followed around for 20 years, and the ones that abstained from eating the marshmallow consistently did better than those who did. </p>

<p>Sigh. I feel as if I have no fresh ideas to bring to the table. I’ve just been reiterating my point about telling kids the purpose of education.</p>

<p>It just seems like every time someone in my school’s administration tries to talk some sense into the students, they don’t take it seriously. When my principal had an hour-long drug dangers meeting, people were snickering and joking the whole time. Many of them probably took drugs within a week of that meeting. </p>

<p>Some kids need more than a stern talking-to; instead, tangible rewards and punishments would be more effective (at least in my opinion).</p>

<p>Ugh. This is so elitist I can’t stand it. All of your arguing points, from welfare to education reform just show that you have a complete lack of experience in either of those situations. For a lot of people on this site, school has never been hard, and money has never been an issue. We are all very lucky that we have the specific skill set to succeed in the American school system, but from my experiences with tutoring, most people need things explained to them one on one, which simply isn’t feasible.
I guess this makes me a liberal, but I think that we should help people instead of punishing them. And by we, I mean the high achieving students. We can suggest all we want, but an impersonal intervention by a cold authority figure isn’t going to work. If we truly want change, we have to do it ourselves. Unfortunately, there is a view that lower performing kids are somehow lesser than us, even though they just have a different skill set.
I’m not sure there’s an easy solution to this problem, but since we recognize that there is one, we need to get out there and do things, not just pass the buck to adults who have already had little impact.</p>

<p>First of all, IceQube, I sincerely hope that you’re a ■■■■■. If that isn’t the case then you desperately need to check your privilege. The vast majority of people in the United States have no access to a good education, and in these horrible schools that are so commonplace in this nation students often feel threatened every day by their peers and have no choice but to drop out in fear of being physically harmed. And let’s not forget the financial aspect - some students have no choice but to drop out because they need to work full time to support their families. Perhaps it is not the best long-term option, but when the objective is survival rather than success it is necessary to do what is best in the moment. </p>

<p>I honestly don’t know where to begin with your ignorant comments. Your viewpoints are classist, sexist, and baseless. It seems your “statistics” more closely resemble derogatory stereotypes.</p>