<p>@bekah: Tutoring is a great tool, and I wholeheartedly agree that the better students should be coaching the worse ones.</p>
<p>However, I fear you missed some crucial points in my argument. First, the penalty/perk system would not be based off academic achievement, but effort. Thus, if one does their homework and attends study sessions (among other things), they will be rewarded. Hence, the system is not elitist at all. It does not favor those with innate academic talent; instead, it provides perks to those that work hard. Also, you said that punishments are not the way to go. I agree. Punishing a student with detention or suspension is not really getting anywhere. However, the penalties I suggested were actually helpful ways of getting less-achieving students more exposure to academic material. For example, I mentioned a Saturday class that would be mandatory for those that performed poorly (i.e., did not turn in their homework, blatantly didn’t study for a test, etc.). Is my argument now made more clear?</p>
<p>How about you refute my points one by one, like a mature person? Or are you going to resort to name-calling like that other poster?</p>
<p>In any case, I’m going to sleep b/c of my Chem exam tomorrow. I hope that will provide enough time for you and your coalition to refute my points.</p>
<p>omg, the marshmallow test exposed shocking human variability to me too! it made me rethink life, and kids, and biology. And now I think * everyone * should have to take The Marshmallow Test. And it * can’t * be an m&m. it * has * to be a marshmallow.</p>
<p>IceQube, you seem very certain of the worth of academic success in school. Why is this? What is the purpose of school for you?</p>
<p>Many of you are taking a narrow-minded views. Consider a human 200 years from now looking back at us and thinking, ‘how did those people manage to live such successful and productive lives creating the foundations for modern technology with which we live today, when they merely had biological brains for their thinking instead of our hybrid super-minds?’</p>
<p>Intelligence is defined very relatively. I am smart because most people are not as smart as me, not because of some intrinsic property of my mind, which is smart. The differences in intelligence are exacerbated in modern society in which we rely on our brain for so much more than it evolved for. That is for social groups, etc.</p>
<p>Furthermore, all grades are defined by some statistical distribution that relates to the capabilities of society at the time. Forty years ago, it would have been a rarity for a student to take Calculus in high school. The expectations are always growing. Therefore, if we expel people with GPAs below 2, there will very quickly be a new group of people with below 2 GPAs, and they too will be expelled. Before you know it, everyone but the top few students will be expelled. I will let everyone else here make the judgement as to whether having only a couple people be educated is counterproductive to our society.</p>
<p>@ Studious- I think that your system would work in an idealized world but most lower performing students that I know have jobs. They put in effort during school, but they spend nearly every other waking moment working. I don’t think it’s fair to take away money from already struggling families in the name of skills that aren’t applicable in their daily lives. However, I live in a rural community, so the system might just not be right for my town but it would work very well in a bigger city.</p>
<p>Now, here’s what would make this debate a bit more interesting and a lot less vehement: Instead of using a metric that was not created for this theoretical purpose (GPA), think of a metric that would be able to quasi-accurately determine whether or not someone should be allowed to remain in school or not. I think we can all agree there are numerous exceptions to the “Sub-2.0 = should be kicked out” policy. The questions are: What type of student should be kicked out and, more importantly, what indicators show that Student A is the type of student that should be kicked out?</p>
<p>The only students that should be kicked out are criminals - the ones that pose threats to other students. And actually, they shouldn’t be kicked out as much as they should be put in a special school, or jail. </p>
<p>Disruptive students should be reprimanded, not kicked out. Unmotivated students should not be kicked out either. As I previously said, kicking students out doesn’t do anyone any good.</p>