Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

No, they didn’t. They provided the results of what they analyzed. We have no idea what was included in those numbers, as I referenced above.

2 Likes

If you read the second, non paywalled link I posted…it hints at other reasons for the change.

1 Like

Here are the last nine years of LSU’s first year retention data, per their CDSs.

2024 - 84.7%
2023 - 84.0%
2022 - 83.5%
2021 - 82.9%
2020 - 85.8%
2019 - 83.0%
2018 - 83.7%
2017 - 82.9%
2016 - 82.8%

Not seeing a statistically significant change in retention rate here. Maybe their CDSs are wrong, or they were looking at ‘adjusted’ retention rate.

4 Likes

One of the things I really love about the American higher education landscape is the amazing diversity of options. That some schools now require test scores, some are test optional, and some are test free, just adds to that diversity of choice to me. And it seems that each of those options is likely truly best for certain schools depending on a number of individual factors/priorities/characteristics of that school.

3 Likes

They said that for students who didn’t submit, so the overall doesn’t tell the story. They are comparing the TO vs. not TO.

In 2023/24 CDS, it shows 86% and 14% on the tests - so no TO there.

Same the year before - 87% and 13%.

So not sure what % are actually TO - it might be a very small sample.

In the 2024/25, it’s only 47% (40% + 7%) - so that might be the first year that TO is included or has impact. They don’t have a 25/26 yet.

They would have to share #s but given they put the #s I posted in their statement, I would assume them to be true.

I understand.

Yep. So it would be quite unlikely that a difference in retention rate would be statistically significant.

Without seeing the data, we can’t answer these questions, which has been my point. And again, LSU can have whatever testing policy they want to have.

One key difference is LSU not particularly selective, admitting the vast majority of applicants. LSU may recognize that kids who don’t submit scores have worse rest of applicant than typical admits, but they aren’t selective enough to avoid admitting a large portion of such below average students. In contrast Bowdoin admits only 7% of applicants and can be quite selective of which students they want to admit and reject.

Another difference is the rest of application became far less insightful during COVID, with many students struggling in their HS classes due to adjusting to remote learning, and many HSs giving such students unwarranted "A"s in recognition of these remote learning challenges; combined with fewer ECs/awards with everyone locked in, less reliable LORs with less interaction with teachers, etc. Bowdoin’s last ## years stats primarily involves the pre-COVID period.

nvm

However, money constrained students tend to have great limitations on that choice, and the policies of their in state public universities can affect a large percentage of the choices that they do have.

1 Like

They typically have options, at least the first two years. That they choose to disown or thumb their nose at those choices is not the rest of society’s problem. Entitlement runs deep.

NVM - looks

Like someone already shared the non-paywalled article

Sure, I think this would be a correlary of one of the categories of things I don’t love about the US system is that it is quite expensive. That said, depending on the money constrained group one looked at, it would be interesting to see how limited their diversity of options actually was. (E.g., a high achieving lower income student in California reasonably would have test required Ivy+, test optional that meet full need, and test free state schools all as options. An achieving middle income student in CA might have something similar with merit aid at many privates).

But the premise that lack of funds constrains choice is not one I’d disagree with.

Well, this is new. After several years of test required but flexible, now Yale wants to see your SAT or ACT scores: https://yaledailynews.com/articles/yale-reinstates-sat-act-requirement-after-six-years-of-flexible-policy

3 Likes

But what do STEM professors at Berkeley really know…..

More than 600 University of California faculty members, led by mathematicians at UC Berkeley, are calling on the system to reinstate standardized testing requirements for science, technology, engineering and mathematics applicants, saying that six years of test-free admissions has not reliably assessed readiness and professors are often teaching middle school math to incoming students.

Without standardized testing in admissions, professors said they don’t know whether incoming students can handle college-level math. The open letter, addressed to top UC leaders, asks for SAT or ACT exams to be required beginning in fall 2027 and for STEM faculty to be given formal oversight of readiness standards in their majors.

“We now observe preparation gaps so severe that instructors must reteach middle-school mathematics while simultaneously teaching the material students need for sciences, engineering, economics, and other quantitatively demanding fields,” they warned.

2 Likes

That matches what Penn State found in 2024 - basically, test scores are useless/pointless EXCEPT for math readiness, because there’s no way to know if an A in Precalculus was earned through quizzes and tests, or through extra credit and multiple retests.
Any field where a sound understanding of precalculus or at least Algebra2/Geometry is a necessary foundation for entrance to major classes needs some sort of test result (SAT, act, AP, anything that certifies the student is ready for college math, calculus preferably but ready for precalculus at least.) Students are still free to show readiness otherwise - for example, students who are getting an A in calculus are generally assumed to have enough of an Algebra2/precalculus background.
Students who show potential but where they don’t have a test score and no way to evaluate how strong the precalculus background is may be offered Summer session with a class called “Bridge to Calculus”.

1 Like

A number of other schools do this too.

Fundamentally, a state system can decide how they want to operate. They can acknowledge (or not) that many of the state’s K-12 schools are relatively weak, and create programs at the college level to address said issues.

U Texas Austin does this, because with the 5% auto admit policy, the school admits plenty of students from weak schools. This article detailing UT’s programming is still relevant, so we know these programs can have success. It’s just a matter of the state system’s priorities. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/05/18/magazine/who-gets-to-graduate.html?unlocked_article_code=1.l1A.wgXw.3xkJwLzo63X_&smid=url-share

1 Like

Isn’t there some value in gauging a student’s ability to comprehend and interpret complex writing and demonstrate command of the English language in general? Maybe they have A’s in English classes through retakes/re-submissions as well and a common baseline verbal test can clarify that.

3 Likes

Ask any professor who teaches a class which is analytical reading/writing intensive.

Teaching a class filled with the 750 verbal SAT kids- literature, Russian history, political theory, etc. vs. the same curriculum for the 500 verbal SAT kids (and plenty of adjuncts teach at both simultaneously) is NOT the same experience. And reading their essays and papers- wow.

Agree with your point!

7 Likes

I can’t speak to what professors teaching students with different STA scores have found, but my experience as an over-involved parent and lawyer is that: (1) decent math SAT scores say something basic and predictive about readiness for higher math, and it depresses me how poorly US students do on not just SAT Math but a host of math tests at varying school levels (I’m in NYC and as a public school fan I’m a little crushed by how poorly pub school students do on pretty basic state math tests), and (2) SAT English is much more about close reading and logic – which are very valuable talents/skills for burgeoning lawyers, but fundamentally underinclusive in what makes a good writer, researcher, and student of the Humanities. It’s very hard to test the skills that go into Humanities research and big picture thinking. Having good close reading skills is always helpful, but it’s such a small piece of the foundational skills one needs to be a strong Humanities student. The SAT Math seems more inclusive of the basic skills one needs to be even marginally successful in higher math.

1 Like

Kids who perform poorly on the verbal SAT are not likely to be able to write a coherent paper, synthesize primary sources, compare two literary works, argue a point of view using facts to support that view, etc. Whether a high verbal SAT guarantees that a kid CAN do all of these things is a different issue. Many can, some likely cannot.

But try teaching a class on The Enlightenment to kids who struggle reading anything longer than 5 pages. Or who cannot use a topic sentence in an essay.

2 Likes