They don’t know how to teach high school kids, and many are actually pretty poor at teaching undergraduates. They are also don’t understand standardized testing, nor do they actually understand WHY students are getting worse.
They are are observing a drop in the ability of students to answer the test questions that they are providing on their tests. That is the absolutely only thing that they have. They are not qualified to figure out the reasons for this, because they lack the knowledge.
The hubris that they are demonstrating is actually breathtaking. Imagine historians who have seen an increase in temperatures that are reported in newspapers since the early 20th century. Would we actually take them seriously if they would claim that they were the people who were best qualified to understand the reasons behind this change in temperatures, as well as being the people who are best qualified to develop ways to mitigate this climate change?
Yet, because the students are doing badly in their classes, STEM professors believe that makes them the people best qualified to figure out the processes behind the drop in math understanding, as well as being the people who are the best qualified to find a solution.
No, they are ONLY best qualified to figure out how well the students are prepared for these classes.
I will repeat this once again:
Most PhD programs in STEM do not put much effort (or any effort at all) in training their faculty to teach. In Engineering and CS it s worse than the rest. Historically, students in many PhD programs in engineering, biomedical sciences, etc, were actually discouraged from working as teaching assistants and the faculty advisors were encouraged to provide funding so that their students would only have to work as research assistants.
Things have become better, but this is how the vast majority of the present-day faculty in STEM at the UCs were trained. Faculty were hired primarily based on their research potential, and they were tenured primarily based on the research productivity and grand money. These are faculty at a set of R1 universities, not at colleges which engage primarily in teaching undergraduates. Most teach one undergrad class a year, or maybe a semester.
These are not a group of people with deep knowledge and understanding of pedagogy, nor are most of them really interesting in developing their teaching abilities.
So no, I do not trust that they know the reasons behind the drop in math abilities, nor do I believe that they have the best solution for the drop in math abilities.
To repeat: the only thing for which they are qualified is to identify and report the drop in math abilities.
So their claims that the reason behind this is the lack of SAT scores and that the solution for this is reinstating the SAT scores has little validity, unless it is supported by studies by people who understand pedagogy and sociology.
As an additional comment: if the drop in math abilities was the result of the dropping of SAT scores, there should have been a sudden drop in abilities as soon as the requirement was dropped, but very little movement after that. Yet there seems to have been a constant increase in the number of students who are not prepared.
I would also love to see their data. All I see is a claim that is being made by these faculty, without actual data to back them up. They’re STEM faculty, so they should understand the importance of providing fact-based evidence to support their claims.
In any case, if they believe that students aren’t prepared, the UC should ask people with the appropriate expertise to figure out why and to figure out the best way to address this. As it is, they are retreating to the old thought process of the wealthy and privileged, who believe that college education is only their right, and that the poor should only be allowed on sufferance.
A very good solution is summer courses for incoming students who are not prepared. Yes, you can actually bring students up to required expertise in pre-calc and geometry in a three month summer course.
However, the faculty who signed this petition seem to be more interested in gatekeeping than in anything else. That is why, I think, they demand the simplest gatekeeping solution. The status quo that existed before benefitted the wealthy, because the SAT benefit the wealthy. But, rather than find a solution to their problem that maybe doesn’t benefit the wealthy, they engage in mental gymnastics trying to “prove” that “No, SAT scores actually benefit the poor”.
I’m sorry, but that is the laziness of people who benefit from a situation in which college gatekeeping benefits wealthier students for admissions.