Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

IMO, it’s easy to make the case that Merced and Riverside should, because they are enrolling Top 9% ELC students. Merced isn’t even operating at full undergrad capacity. (Not sure about Riverside)

ETA: just as an addition to some of my posts, UT Austin is test required.

2 Likes

Currently, it is not targeted for test prep. But if it becomes used in college admission, it would not be surprising if test prep companies targeted it.

2 Likes

I am not sure there would be a market for test prep for students to achieve a score of “Proficient” on the CAASPP. Students would not need to get a high score. They could also demonstrate math readiness by achieving a minimum score on any of a number of tests, including SAT/ACT for which there is already abundant test prep available.

In the most recent year with data (2024-2025), a total of 131,724 11th grade students in CA public high schools received a score of Proficient or better on the math CAASPP. (Source)

For comparison, 114,245 students from CA public high schools applied to the UC system, 89,284 of these were accepted, and 38,512 were enrolled. (Source)

1 Like

This.

However, even for kids who have been failed by their high school, there are ways to remedy a lot of this, especially if we are focusing in math. To begin with, pre-college summer courses can get a lot done. in general 18 and 19 year old kids are a lot better at learning than 14 or 15 year old kids. So many of them can get caught up on pre-calc over a three month course.

While people can make the case that private colleges don’t need to solve issues that are the result of underserved high schools, the UCs are public universities. If the state legislature decides that their mission should include remedying education flaws in the public secondary school system, then that will be part of their mission. I think that these classes should be free, since the students themselves should not be literally paying because the state failed them in high school.

1 Like

I was responding to this

I don’t think these professors sound “obtuse”

Many of the most selective private colleges offer precalculus or slow pace calculus with precalculus courses (and have done so since before COVID-19 when they were SAT or ACT required), even though students capable of being admitted there should have been ready for calculus or have already taken it when they enter. So this is not a situation that even the most selective private colleges escape from.

3 Likes

That assumes these kids are identified somehow before starting a college math course, though.

1 Like

This is true and not surprising or even controversial. We are talking about highly exclusive, elitist institutions with endowments that rival the budgets of small countries. Supposedly, they evaluate test scores (or applications in general) within context, especially for students that are from low-income demographics. That doesn’t change the fact that they like to reject all but a handful of applications. Thankfully, there are hundreds of solid educational institutions for students who may not have achieved a high test score due to financial/geographical/etc. challenges or anyone else for that matter.

Got it, no wonder I was confused because I didn’t write those quotes but you tagged me in your response.

1 Like

I don’t get it. You claim that university math professors aren’t great teachers, aren’t trained to teach, etc. and yet the solution to sub-par math prep is to enroll the sub-par math students in precollege??? Somehow the math faculty who struggle to teach well prepared kids are going to magically blossom into teachers who can catch students up in three months?

I took remedial math at a research university. It was a pre-requisite for starting my grad school program. I had managed to score high on the grad school standardized tests (not very challenging math as I recall) but had never taken math in college and had not taken calc in HS which was a requirement.

The instructor- who was fantastic- was NOT a member of the university faculty. He was an adjunct ( whose specialty was teaching remedial math to students who had always been tracked in “dummy math” which was me. I was surrounded by nursing students, med students, public health students, etc. all of whom had “provisional acceptances” once we got an A or a B in this special summer, no credit, remedial math course. You have never met a more motivated cohort of math students. We had all already paid for the upcoming semester, so HAD TO PASS THIS CLASS with an A or a B.

Some of us were fine math students but had missed a beat or two along the line (fractions, percentages, who knows). Some were terrible math students but with the help of this gifted remedial teacher knew they could get there. The class met every day and started with first grade math (addition, subtraction, carry the 4) and ended after first semester calculus. There were tears. There was old fashioned blackboard work and people vying to clean the chalk after class. There were songs and stupid poems and hand motions to help us remember the order of operations and cutesy graphics with farm animals suitable for a first grade classroom, not grad students from well regarded universities.

And the pass rate was 100%.

So I am a personal example of remedial math after HS is in the rear view mirror. But I think it takes someone who is not a mathematician or someone with a PhD in applied math. It takes a teacher who has studied, pioneered, practiced, learned the hard way that remedial math teaching isn’t the same as teaching Calculus to a group of math loving HS students. Someone who has mnemonic devices for virtually every formula, can perform songs from Grease with hand motions during geometry lessons with hilarious and bawdy lyrics. Find and train a few thousand of these folks and California can fix its math performance gap.

6 Likes

My sister, who had failed out of Brown, had this kind of great experience in a remedial math class in a California community college. She had a wonderful instructor who took my sister all the way from “I’m bad at math and will never be able to learn this” to “I love math, maybe I should be a math major?” She then transferred to UCB and did very well there. Community college can be a great pathway for students who need to catch up, and the door to UC admission is wide open for CA community college students.

4 Likes

Sorry my mistake

1 Like

Here are some UCB grade distributions for fall 2019 (last semester before COVID-19 disruptions, and with frosh students admitted under SAT/ACT required) and fall 2025 (SAT/ACT not considered for admission) versions of various math courses that are intended to be taken after precalculus.

MATH 51 (formerly 1A) (calculus): Berkeleytime

MATH 16A (calculus for business): Berkeleytime

MATH 10A (calculus and math methods for biology and premeds): Berkeleytime

There is also a precalculus course:

MATH 3 (formerly 32): Berkeleytime

It does look like the percentage of F grades in these math courses was higher in fall 2025 than fall 2019, but still in the single digit percentages.

There is also an introductory non-calculus statistics course usually for those who need to fulfill a general education requirement:

STAT 2: Berkeleytime

In that course, the small percentage of F grades was lower in fall 2025 compared to fall 2019.

It would be interesting to get data from professors about whether they needed to make exams easier or curve exam scores more favorably in fall 2025 compared to fall 2019. (My understanding is that there is an approximate target for grade distribution in UCB lower division STEM courses, and it seems pretty common to curve scores upwards when students are performing poorly on exams.)

1 Like

CNN just had a UC math professor on talking about why they want to return to tests for STEM majors. According to her, only 1/3 of incoming students are prepared for Calc I. She also said the CCs are failing students by allowing them to use AI on all assignments, quizzes, and exams.

IME many schools that were test optional or not required were still using their own placement tests like ALEKS. Does the UC system do anything like that?

2 Likes

They do. That’s how UCSD knew 800 of their incoming Freshman can’t do college level calculus.

2 Likes

The overwhelming portion of colleges that are discussed on this website use placement exams for starting math point, including UCs, as well as both test required and test optional colleges. This includes highly selective colleges like Caltech as well.

1 Like

Most or all have their own or outsourced (e.g. ALEKS) math placement tests. They are required at most campuses (but optional at UCB and may be optional at some other campuses for some majors) for incoming frosh who do not have other placement indicators (e.g. AP scores, college math grades, etc.).

You can web search “UC [campus] math placement” to get information.

1 Like

800 is something like 10% of incoming frosh at UCSD.