Actually it’s one in eight. We have had several threads on this very topic.
IMO, demanding proficiency in “college level calculus” is an unreasonable admissions hurdle at a public university. Many high schools do not even teach “college level calculus.”
UCSD’s math placement exam (link) doesn’t contain calculus. It does contain a few topics in pre-calculus such as functions and trigonometry. @cy7878 probably meant to say pre-calculus.
Note that UCSD does not have an exemption from its math placement exam for SAT or ACT scores, although it does for certain AP and other scores: Do I Need The MPE?
Around 50% of California high school students don’t take math beyond algebra 2. Excerpt, full link below (my bolding):
According to PACE, about a quarter of California students graduate without Algebra II, a quarter take no math as seniors, and nearly half never take an advanced math course beyond Algebra II. Those taking advanced courses are more likely to be Asian, white and higher-income.
Some San Diego students performed poorly on elementary math questions despite having taken advanced high school math. Correcting this problem requires high-quality instruction, but that is not merely a job for the students’ high schools. “To truly expand opportunity in STEM, California must treat early math recovery not as a K–12 issue, but as a shared responsibility across educational systems,” noted a recent UC report.
Pace study link:
https://edpolicyinca.org/publications/12th-grade-math
Here’s the UCOP report that states colleges/UCs have shared responsibility to fix the math issue.
Or @cy7878 believes that the UCs should only admit applicants who have demonstrated an extremely high level of math proficiency.
This view would be consistent with the view of many parents who think that UC slots are going to kids who are not as well prepared as their students. This IMO is at the root of this debate.
Agreed and it typically comes back to race and/or affluence. And we can’t talk about race in this thread.
Even focusing on affluence, it is the same dilemma.
And it should not be a shocker that math and professors would prefer if all college freshman came to them preprogramed to “do college level calculus.” It makes their job much easier.
But the purpose of publicly supported higher education is not to make life easy on the professors. Nor is the purpose to further stack the deck in favor of affluent parents with better access to educational opportunities for their kids.
Just to clarify- the UC group is looking to reinstitute SAT for STEM majors only, correct? (That’s what the math professor said on CNN).
Or @cy7878 believes that the UCs should only admit applicants who have demonstrated an extremely high level of math proficiency.
This view would be consistent with the view of many parents who think that UC slots are going to kids who are not as well prepared as their students. This IMO is at the root of this debate.
Thank you for putting words in my mouth.
I do not believe UC should ONLY admit students who demonstrate “extremely” high level of math proficiency.
I do believe UC needs to admit people who have the capacity to learn and think when given the right opportunity and environment. If all we do is keep harping on social inequalities even after the kids enter a college campus, the pattern will not change.
You are right. I did not mean these students were tested for their calculus skills. I did mean to say, they were lacking the foundational knowledge to start college level calculus.
It also appears that most UC math departments do not consider the SAT or ACT math sections adequate indicators for math placement. The exceptions:
- UCB suggest 560 SAT math to enroll in precalculus (placement testing is optional there; see Choosing Courses | Department of Mathematics ).
- UCI accepts 650 SAT math or 29 ACT math to enroll in calculus ( Calculus Placement Test )
Other UC math departments do not accept SAT or ACT scores to exempt new students from their math placement tests.
You complained that 1 in 8 “incoming Freshman can’t do college level calculus.”
Most CA high school students do not have the opportunity to learn “college level calculus” before entering college. So this benchmark is not a reasonable way to measure whether a student has “the capacity to learn and think when given the right opportunity and environment.”
I am fairly certain UC AOs believe they are admitting students who have the ‘capacity to learn and think’. Are you saying the 1 in 8 UCSD students who aren’t ready for calc can’t learn and think?
Social inequalities don’t disappear or are magically solved when a student graduates from HS.
Again. I referenced another thread here. It’s not a complaint.
I guess truth hurts.
And when you say “most” HS students don’t have the opportunity to learn college level calculus, do you have data to back this up?
so what do you suggest?
Truth hurts? Not sure what that means given that what you claimed about “college level calculus” isn’t even true
According to posts above, only about half of CA high school students get through Algebra II.
Fixing K-12 education isn’t the purview of this thread, but that’s where I would start.
I would encourage posters to read the UCOP report I linked above, it is very enlightening. As it turns out, the UCs already offer some alternative math programming in order to expand access to STEM degrees. There is no mention of not admitting students who aren’t ready to do calc (STEM major or not), nor recommending a return to requiring SAT/ACT.
I am not an educator, so defer to the UC leaders who have already put some programs in place. Some excerpts from the UCOP report to follow (the full report is 52 pages.) It’s not clear to me the UCSD profs buy into this report/goals/programs?
Reimagining placement and
preparation
Many of these efforts center on placement and
preparatory coursework—critical moments that
can shape a student’s entire academic
trajectory. Rather than assigning students to
remedial pathways that delay degree progress,
campuses are finding ways to place students
more appropriately and support them more
effectively.The 2020 elimination of standardized testing
requirements for UC undergraduate admissions
has added new complexity to this work. Math
SAT scores, known to reflect systemic inequities,
nonetheless offered utility as a shared reference
point for readiness. In their absence, campuses
are relying more on diagnostic tools, prior
coursework, and targeted supports to help
design entry points. While this shift requires
rethinking placement systems, it also creates
opportunities to design more equitable
approaches.At UC Santa Barbara, for instance, a newly
designed preparatory chemistry course has
shown promising results. The course was
developed in response to data revealing that
students experiencing one or more “effectors of
opportunity”—a campus-defined framework for
understanding marginalization—were less likely
to pass general chemistry than their peers. By
offering an on-ramp that builds foundational
knowledge without the stigma or cost of
traditional remedial models, the course has
helped narrow equity gaps later in the chemistry
sequence (UCSB-internal analysis).Placement into math has also seen reform
across the system. At UC San Diego, the math
department introduced a preparatory course in
2017 that precedes precalculus. As the number
of students placing into this course has grown,
the department has adopted an online format to
expand access. Importantly, this was paired with
the launch of a new support center, ASC@Math,
where students engage in individualized learning
plans. The overall approach is an effort to meet
students where they are, offering targeted, just-
in-time academic support.A similar recalibration has occurred at UC
Riverside. The campus transformed a non-credit
bearing workshop into College Mathematics
Fundamentals and Problem Solving (MATH
003), a workload credit-bearing course. This
change, combined with an adjustment to
placement thresholds, has led more students
into credit-bearing algebra and precalculus
rather than foundational math without degree
credit
9 EXPANDING OPPORTUNITY
UC Davis offers CHE 1V, an online preparatory
chemistry course that introduces foundational
concepts through real-world issues like pollution,
climate change, and sustainability. Designed to
support students who do not meet the general
chemistry placement threshold, the course is
primarily offered during summer session to help
students start the general chemistry sequence
on track in the fall. However, to meet growing
demand, the offering has been extended into fall
quarter. The campus is exploring additional
cross-campus supports—including outreach and
success coordinators—to strengthen placement
and preparation in both chemistry and math.
Some campuses have introduced flexible,
modular solutions that respond to students’
evolving needs throughout the term.In 2024-25, UC Berkeley piloted a short, half-semester
course (Foundations of Lower Division Math),
which focused on precalculus concepts and ran
alongside the standard calculus course.
Students could opt into this co-course at the
beginning of the term or later in the semester, a
valuable option for students who may have fallen
behind or earned a low grade on a midterm.
While each of these examples reflects a local
response to campus-specific needs, they share
a common philosophy: that students’ prior
experiences should inform—not limit—their
academic journey. By restructuring placement
and preparatory pathways to be more supportive
and less punitive, campuses are working to build
a stronger, more inclusive foundation for STEM
success.
Leveraging online infrastructure
UC Santa Cruz’s fully online calculus sequence
is approved for major credit at all nine
undergraduate-serving campuses and has been
available through cross-campus enrollment for
more than a decade.Systemwide access
Available to all UC students through UC Online,
the infrastructure is in place—but use across the
system remains uneven. This may reflect limited
awareness but might also point to broader
dynamics: campuses may prioritize their own
curricula, and advising practices will vary.A promising approach
Since its launch in 2012-13, the sequence has
served tens of thousands of students, with
consistently strong pass rates and student
satisfaction. Analysis of pre-pandemic course
outcomes (UCSC-internal) showed comparable
or stronger performance in the online format—
but also indicated that students who opted in
tended to have stronger prior math preparation.Looking ahead
Today, with greater familiarity and comfort with
online learning, students may be more open to
this option—but deeper, systemwide analysis is
needed to understand how to leverage this
shared structure for broader impact.
What the research says
UCLA’s Mathematics for Life Sciences (LS30)
course takes a modeling-first approach, using
biological systems to introduce students to core
concepts in calculus, dynamics, and feedback.
A multi-year study found:
• 80% of students reported increased
confidence in math.
• Grade disparities between first-generation
students and their peers were smaller in LS30
than in traditional calculus.
• LS30 students earned higher grades in
subsequent chemistry and physics courses than
peers who took traditional calculus.
Source: Garfinkel et al., 2022
The calculus gateway
Read more about structural barriers to calculus
success—and how redesigned placement and
instruction models across California higher
education systems support a more diverse
STEM workforce—in Charting a New Course:
Investigating Barriers on the Calculus Pathway
to STEM (Just Equations and the California
Education Learning Lab, 2021).
Which posts above?