Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions

My post above around #1938

1 Like

If the UC leaders want to re-instate a test requirement that’s their prerogative (not sure they will value WSJ’s opinion). That won’t change the goals of the UCOP report or obviate the need for the various stem programs already in place at the UCs. (Some of those programs were put in place prior to COVID when UCs required tests)

1 Like

I am sure they don’t value the WSJ’s opinion. It would be nice, however, if they took into account the views of 2 UC Berkeley math professors in this commentary. The numbers they cite of unprepared students are alarming. But as noted above by MWolf , they may be obtuse–see comment 2091

“On the other hand, yes, faculty in fields like math and physics (and other fields) can actually be that obtuse.”

The numbers are also more than a little misleading, which is . . . unfortunate . . . from math professors. The 1 in 12 number was for all UCSD students, not just STEM students, and it is far from clear how they support the “elementary or middle school” comment given that the test on which placement is based is not even testing grade school math concepts. As for the “coin flip” comment, I can’t find where they got this, except maybe from a 2016 UC Berkeley analysis, which was prior to the advent of (successful) summer programs at Berkeley to address the issue of unprepared students signing up for Calculus. Not all kids will be ready for calculus, but this is true at every school.

Perhaps more importantly there is a huge causation problem here. (You’d think math professors might have learned that correlation does not equal causation.) Not surprisingly, the UCSD stats (on which this movement seems to be based) declined at the exact same time that 1) Covid kids were hitting college age, and 2) UCSD drastically expanded their admissions to underprivileged students from low resource schools. Yet the cure-all is somehow just to start requiring tests again, despite the lack of evidence that it was doing away with the test that caused the change in preparedness? That’s a misuse of math, IMO.

Do you mean Stanford, Harvard, Dartmouth, Yale, Penn, Brown, CalTech, JHU, and UT-Austin to Require Standardized Testing for Admissions - #2190 by Mwfan1921 ?

That post contains a link to https://edpolicyinca.org/publications/12th-grade-math which says that:

  • 25% of CA 12th grade students are not in any math course.
  • 17% of CA 12th grade students are in a math course lower than algebra 2.
  • All other CA 12th grade students (58%) are in algebra 2 or a higher math course.

The 25% not in any math course are not necessarily those who stopped math before algebra 2. They could include students who stopped after algebra 2, precalculus, statistics, or calculus. So 58% is the lower bound of CA high school students who will complete algebra 2 by graduation (and 83% is the upper bound).

Note that many of the larger school districts in CA have high school graduation requirements that include the a-g subject requirements for UC and CSU, even though the state minimum high school graduation requirements are significantly less. Of course, not all students completing the a-g subjects will be eligible for frosh admission to UC or CSU (due to grades or GPA being too low).

1 Like

Per the LATimes in 2024 . . .

About 44% of high school seniors fail to complete two semesters of advanced algebra, according to UC.

https://edpolicyinca.org/news/uc-stirs-furious-debate-over-what-high-school-math-skills-are-needed-succeed-college

The page that you linked says that “About two-thirds of California high school students have taken algebra 2 by 11th grade, according to Michal Kurlaender, a UC Davis professor of education policy.”

That link has both quotes from above.

Could be sloppy reporting. Or maybe the 2/3 number includes those who only took one semester of algebra 2.

Regardless there are plenty of HS grads who haven’t gotten to precalc. In addition, there are plenty of students who have taken precalc, and some even calc, and still don’t have a solid foundation in either.

Or “advanced algebra” means something other than algebra 2.

1 Like

Regarding UC requirements, it doesn’t.

Perhaps the confusion is because until recently students could substitute a Data Science course for Advanced-Algebra/Algebra II.

1 Like

As far as CA high school students taking (and passing) the required A-G courses for UC and CSU admission, unfortunately that problem is bigger than just math. Here is a CalMatters article for example: Many CA students don’t take classes needed for college admission- CalMatters

2 Likes

A while back you wrote . . .

Is this what the math prof letter recommended? If so, I missed this. Can you point me to it? In my experience, those advocating for test usage generally try to pivot to using the tests to compare the qualifications of applicants.

College Board says that their “College and Career Readiness Benchmarks” are 480+ for Reading and Writing, and 530+ for Math. Do you think these “benchmarks” would satisfy those clamoring to reinstatement of the tests.

1 Like

No, those numbers are not from the math prof letter. I took the numbers from the CSU multiple measures assessment for math placement into normal GE area 2 college math classes for non-STEM majors, just as an example of test results that could be used for a student to establish math readiness: https://csustudentsuccess.org/multiple-measures/math/non-stem

Yes, I also read that the College Board considers 530+ for math to be the benchmark that represents college readiness, so that could be the benchmark; I don’t know the reasoning behind the CSUs choosing 570+ as their threshold.

No, I do not think this type of benchmark would satisfy many of the people who are clamoring to reinstate tests, as I think they might be looking for something different (I think many people want tests to be used as a way for high performing students to show their strengths on a test).

My suggestion of using the CAASPP is simply that it is a test that is supposed to evaluate students’ basic math readiness for college, and it is taken by the vast majority of CA public HS students for free in 11th grade already. It could therefore be part of a broader UC-wide framework to establish readiness… either as a basic admission requirement (like the A-G requirements), or as a way to identify students who require more basic courses than a standard curriculum (like the ELWR requirement, or the CSU readiness assessment linked above). I do think it is valuable for students to have a published system-wide benchmark test that is taken in 11th grade and can guide their application season planning.

3 Likes

Got it. Makes sense, although potentially not without some of the usual problems with standardized tests. And given that the SAT/ACTs aren’t really built as a benchmark, they would seem a very strange choice.

I think the key to understanding this debate, though, is your observation . . .

I agree with this 100%, which is why I am dubious of the entire discussion. If UC set a benchmark like you are suggesting, then there will be a whole lot of parents who will be livid when their kid scores much higher yet still doesn’t get admitted. Just like now.

1 Like

This opinion article seems to belong in this discussion.

https://www.the74million.org/article/why-students-reach-college-underprepared-for-math-and-what-to-do-about-it/

My son will start teaching Calculus this week at an inner-city university so I have been following this topic and sharing some of the responses here with him. I am hoping he can be successful in adjusting his approaches if needed to best teach these students with possible varying math preparedness, while keeping his expectations of their success high.

Do inner city universities like Columbia and NYU necessarily have more students under prepared in math than other universities?

I’m not sure, but I believe the CUNY system does depending on which city high school the students may have attended previously.

1 Like

I’m not completely sure whether this belongs in this thread but it’s my best guess? It’s from the Daily Cal and is about students failing CS classes for various reasons including AI cheating (in the CS classes), and inadequate math knowledge because of AI cheating (in previous UC Berkeley classes that were supposed to prepare them for math in CS class).

This isn’t about standardized tests, though… the concern is not as much about the students’ preparation when they started college, but about how AI cheating seems to be affecting getting the education they are supposed to get in college. There is probably a better thread somewhere about AI cheating and math skills in general, or maybe we should start one, but it seems to be rather connected.

1 Like

:100: this seems like a bunch of kids deciding not to do the hard work after they got to college and instead relied on AI while they skipped the actual learning.

2 Likes
10 Likes