Suggestions on how to appeal an unfair essay grade?

<p>I was extremely proud of my timed DBQ essay when I finished in class.
I got it back today, and as it turns out, I got a much lower grade than I expected.
I’ve read my teacher’s comments and it seems she’s completely misinterpreted my essay. </p>

<p>Even if her comments had a legitimate basis, I would probably still get a 6 or so. She claimed that I used a lot of specific evidence but my organization didn’t make any sense.
But she gave me a 3. (3/9) </p>

<p>This has actually happened several times (giving me a much lower grade than I merited) so I’m feeling at this point that she just doesn’t like me.
What should I do? Would asking about the grade seem like I’m challenging her authority?</p>

<p>I suspect either she’s a harsh grader for everyone, or you’re not as good a writer as you think you are.</p>

<p>She’s actually not.
A lot of people in my class received 8’s and 9’s.
If you wish, you can read my essay and judge for yourself; I’ll PM it to you.</p>

<p>She might be a harsh grader, but I would ask to meet with your teacher to discuss it with her, either before, after, or during schools. Try to listen to her and accommodate her and don’t say “I deserved this grade because…”. Sound more like you are looking for help than being cocky. Try to take her comments, ask what you can improve on,etc… I know for English sometimes you can get a rewrite, but I don’t know if that would happened for a history DBQ. Just focus on this essay though, don’t bring up the other ones. Be willing to learn!</p>

<p>Here was the prompt:
Evaluate the effectiveness of Progressive Era reformers and the federal government in bringing about reform at the national level. In your answer be sure to analyze the successes and limitations of these efforts in the period 1900-1920.</p>

<p>Her comments:
-historical info is good
-organization needs work - you didn’t follow your thesis, additionally your thesis should have several parts
-your paragraphs must follow the order of the thesis
-you wrote “economics and social” but then wrote about politics</p>

<p>Here is my thesis:
While many others had worked passionately to provoke positive change in earlier time periods, the vast majority of these reformer’s significant victories occurred during the period between 1900 and 1920 in legislation against corruption (political), merciless Social Darwinistic economies and social issues. </p>

<p>It’s clear that my thesis actually does refer to politics. </p>

<p>While I did not explicitly state “political” in my thesis, that does not mean I omitted the idea of political reform. In context, it can be implied that “corruption” referred to political corruption, since it is unlikely that I am referring to a philosophical or theological means. </p>

<p>Especially since the entire paragraph following refers to the political corruption (tweed ring, machine politics) that was prevalent even before the Progressive era.</p>

<p>The organization of the essay is as follows:
Introduction
Success of Progressives
• Political
• Economic
• Social
Limitations of Progressives
• Political
• Social
Conclusion
As you can see, the organization of the essay is actually very deliberate and precise. Additionally, it follows the precedent implied by the thesis. </p>

<p>A “3” score implies that I had poor analysis, little to no specific evidence, and a poor understanding of the prompt.
I do not think that this is accurate.</p>

<p>There is a rubric that goes with grading AP US History essays, so only so much of the grading can be subjective.</p>

<p>Umm…stop venting and (KINDLY) talk to her about it. Ask her what you specifically need work on, or what she didn’t like. But do not challenge her.</p>

<p>Okay, I’m going to give you my honest opinion. As a former APUS student, I’ve written my fair share of DBQs and gotten a few grades that were lower than I thought they were. I’m not going to pretend to know exactly how your teacher grades and I have no idea if she graded you more harshly compared to the class. Looking at your thesis, however, I have some suggestions that could help you with future DBQs.</p>

<p>First off, I just want to say that your thesis is written very nicely, however, I’m not sure that it in itself answers the whole prompt. Guessing from your teacher’s comment on organization, she is a teacher that wants a thesis that pretty much outlines your whole essay. The prompt asks you to analyze the effectiveness of the progressive and governmental reforms from 1900 - 1920; it asks you to take a stand, arguing that the reforms were effective, were not effective, or somewhere in the middle. Your thesis simply states that the vast majority of these reformer’s significant victories occurred during the period between 1900 and 1920- you need to argue that they were or were not effective, and this will add multiple parts to your thesis. </p>

<p>For example, you could use the following thesis (excuse me if some of my facts are wrong- I haven’t studied the material for a couple of years): While some of the progressive reforms form 1900 to 1920 failed to permanently impact policy on the national level, the vast majority of their reforms were successful, inflicting lasting change on the social, political, and economic operations of the United States. </p>

<p>Then for organization- instead of organizing by successes and limitations, try a thee body paragraph system-one paragraph devoted to each social, political, and economic reforms in that order. If I were to use the above thesis, I would largely talk about the successes of these reforms, but indicate 1 or 2 in each section that failed to make a lasting impact on national politics. Make sure each paragraph has a clear topic sentence stating exactly what you will talk about.</p>

<p>One last tip: It’s always easier to argue more than one side of a prompt than exactly down the middle, but no matter what you do, your thesis most make conclusions on the facts.</p>

<p>Sorry for the long answer, but I hope some of this will help you on future essays. I’m sure this essay was good, but for timed US history essays the clearer and more direct you can make it, the better. I really hope that helped. If you have any questions, just ask.</p>

<p>oh, and I second TheAtlantic- talk to her and ask her what you can improve in the future,but I wouldn’t argue with her about your grade. She made her call- now it’s up to you to talk to her and find out exactly what she is looking for.</p>

<p>Did it really merit a 3, though? That’s pretty harsh.</p>

<p>Well ask her why it merited a three, and what it’s going to take you go get a 6-9</p>

<p>I think her comments sum up pretty succinctly what she wants from me…but her comments still don’t make any sense.
I’m going to talk to her about it tomorrow…I’m honestly not really expecting much from her, though. </p>

<p>@wpgm51
Thank you for the suggestions.
Here’s the thesis of someone in my class who received an 8.</p>

<p>As the progressive era approached, many political heads and government officials decided on reform. They wanted a nation as a whole to participate in the reform in all different aspects. The reform was very successful, but came slowly but surely.</p>

<p>Hmm…</p>

<p>Any reason for the gravedig</p>

<p>Just talk to her. At the end of the day, despite our fantastic knowledge, WE can’t tell you anything definitive.</p>