Teacher gives no feedback at all whatsoever?

<p>I’m in AP Lang and my teacher doesn’t give any real feedback at all.
When we write essays, she just has our peers edit the essays and puts in whatever our peer gave us. </p>

<p>For argumentive essays, is it true that historical evidence is irrelevant and should not be used?</p>

<p>If historical evidence wasn’t relevant there would be no point in studying history. It depends on the context if it’s relevant, just like anything else.</p>

<p>You can find another teacher to help review your essays, or even go online and find some online tutors or whatever that are willing to help you. Some are free. If you really want some good feedback, since your teacher isn’t helping, you’ll have to step out of the box.</p>

<p>She’s the only AP Lang teacher at our school.
The only time she’ s ever given feedback on something I’ ve written is when we had an assignment on satire.
I wrote my satire on Twilight without being aware that she is a hardcore Twilight fan. She proceeded to give me a 3/9, and was extremely defensive in all of her feedback.
For example, I wrote about how Edward’s love for Bella was seemingly only centered around her smell and his inability to read her mind.
My teacher wrote a huge paragraph about the purity of their love and the invalidity of my opinion.</p>

<p>I’m sorry, but that Twilight thing is absolutely hilarious. Even if she’s the only AP teacher, can’t you talk to other English teachers? They may not be familiar with AP, but they (I’m assuming) can still give you valid feedback.</p>

<p>I suppose.
I think I would find it just as funny if it didn’t affect my grade. :stuck_out_tongue:
Do you think I could talk to another teacher about it?</p>

<p>“When we write essays, she just has our peers edit the essays and puts in whatever our peer gave us.”</p>

<p>Ouch, as an actual grade? Is she really doing her job then? For the most part, peer editing is absolutely worthless.</p>

<p>Honestly, it is for all intents and purposes, a self-study class. My essay writing hasn’t really improved at all from the beginning of the year.</p>