The Bell Curve is B.s.

<p>Note: In this post “Africans” means just black Africans and IQs are on a scale where Britain = 100 and America = 98 in 2006.</p>

<p>“The average African IQ is 70″ is something you hear on the Internet. It means that black Africans have an average IQ of 70. Some put it lower at 67. It has become an article of faith among HBDers and other scientific racists.</p>

<p>It is not just the Internet: it has appeared in at least 20 scientific papers and in several books and studies. It is what James Watson had in mind in 2007 when he said he was:</p>

<p>inherently gloomy about the prospect of Africa [because] all our social policies are based on the fact that their intelligence is the same as ours – whereas all the testing says not really.</p>

<p>The number comes from Richard Lynn, professor emeritus of psychology at the University of Ulster. He took some studies where IQ tests were given to Africans, took the average and got 67.</p>

<p>The number is suspect for a very simple reason: Africans do way better at school than you would expect from an average IQ of 67. Given their PISA scores and other measures of school achievement, you would expect an IQ somewhere near 82.</p>

<p>As it turns out, Lynn’s 67 is based in part on children who lost points because:</p>

<p>Some were not used to pencils and could not draw. One boy said it was the first time he ever drew a picture.
Some were not familiar with line drawings.
Some did not wear Western clothes and so did not draw people that way.
Many did not know about telephones, tennis, dollars, miles or other things common in America.
The main one: Most knew English only as a foreign language.</p>

<p>On top of that, Lynn marked down some scores and did not say why or how:</p>

<p>Boys in Uganda who averaged 86 Lynn marked down to 80.
Zulu children in South Africa who averaged 89 were marked down to 74.
From a study on Nigeria and Sierra Leone he took the two worst samples out of five. No reason given.
Of the 42 studies he could have used, Lynn used 11. They had an average IQ of 67. The studies he did not use had an average IQ of 80. He gave no reason for his choice (though he did not seem to know about those that appeared only in African journals).</p>

<p>There are good reasons to throw out some studies:</p>

<p>1.The test was not properly administered.
2.The test was not given in full.
3.The test takers were not a representative sample.
4.The test has known cultural biases.
5.The test has not been tried on a broad Western sample, making it hard to compare.
If you throw out all those you are left with 12 of the 42 studies. They have an average IQ of 81. Very close to the 82 expected from school achievement.</p>

<p>That is where the Netherlands was in the 1950s if you take into account the rising IQs of the Flynn Effect – which seems to have run its course in the West but not in Africa.</p>

<p>edit- btw I do not attribute this to mine own intelligence but that of a poster named abagond. Check his blog-- the man is brilliant.
Discuss.</p>

<p>The average person’s IQ is 100-110.
60s, 70s, and 80s are the average mentally handicapped persons IQ</p>

<p>Wait… </p>

<p>title: “The Bell Curve is B.s.”</p>

<p>post: “IQ tests are BS”</p>

<p>?</p>

<p>thats completely untrue. Go read more psychology.
The stanford-Binet test is the most widely used. So we assume he used this test.
Terman’s Classification<br>
IQ Range IQ Classification<br>
164 and Over Genius or Near Genius<br>
148 - 164 Very Superior Intelligence<br>
132 - 148 Superior Intelligence<br>
113 - 132 Above Average Intelligence<br>
84 - 113 Normal/Average Intelligence<br>
68 - 84 Dullness<br>
52 - 68 Borderline Deficiency<br>
Below 52 Definite Feeble-Mindedness</p>

<p>Also, we have to account for the Flynn effect which has changed IQs in america each generational so that the criteria for a 120 in 1950 would only bring a person a 100 in 2010.</p>

<p>Using this score basis, Africans ( citizens of a wide continent with a lot of disparities that cannot be categorized into one test) roughly have a similar IQ to Americans in the 1930s.</p>

<p>Keep in mind that test is from the 1950s so hopefully, if wealth and social status have increased ( IQs will also increase)</p>

<p>yes, I know IQ tests are ridiculous. But this study is a key factor of scientific racism and it makes me so angry when people say stupid things like black people are dumb–its in their genetics.</p>

<p>I did say average is 100-110, I just didn’t go low enough (wasn’t sure if the 80s counted.)</p>

<p>The state told us that because my class (28) students were gifted, we had IQs in the high 120s. </p>

<p>We also got a nice packet about the rights of a gifted child and the difficulties entering high school where you’re mixed with other students.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>So, nevertheless, you are admitting they are inferior?</p>

<p>Actually, a lot of (tribal) Africans get screwed up on these things because their huts have no corners and their windows aren’t rectangular. You’d be surprised how much things like that affect these outcomes.</p>

<p>Point that psychologists have known for years: It is scientifically laughable to claim to be able to quantify the vast mental faculties grouped under the term “intelligence,” and all such efforts have failed.</p>

<p>hey nil… if you are out dancing in your yard (party time), i’m guessing you got accepted to a school that you like?</p>

<p>I agree with BillyMc. </p>

<p>It’s nearly impossible to measure intelligence. The way I see it, intelligence is your brain’s capacity to store and recall information. IQ tests are bogus. They require being taught something first. If you take say, an American who went to college and one who lived on a farm their whole life with no formal instruction, tests would say the college student is more intelligent. Not necessarily true. The farmchild could be the next Einstein.</p>

<p>IQ tests are decent measures of intelligence. Sure, IQ scores will rise with a good education. But that’s because years of rigorous education don’t just fill your head with a bunch of facts; education actually builds cognitive ability and raises intelligence.</p>

<p>Are IQ tests perfect measures of genetic/inherited/natural intelligence? No. But how would one go about separating “natural” intelligence from acquired intelligence? Smart is smart.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Your choice of punctuation here made that statement sound very hypocritical ;)</p>

<p>Hmm,not really jgraider. I love dashes and since dashes do not show up in the CC box, I have been reduced to using to hyphen marks. I assure you that I know that hyphens (in that context) are improper punctuation marks.</p>

<p>chaosdog, I am not admitting anything about inferior Africans. I am just pointing out that</p>

<ol>
<li>The study is flawed.</li>
</ol>

<p>As I stated in my second post , the Bell Curve study is outdated because it hasn’t been redone in the last 50 years. Also, as abagond pointed out. In some African countries, people may speak other languages beside English.</p>

<p>The IQ test was the equivalent of you taking an IQ test in Hausa. Do you speak Hausa? Probably not. Since the IQ test has a strong verbal component, the test was remarkably flawed even if Lynn didn’t fudge results a little.</p>

<p>Next, I am not oblivious to the fact that IQ tests are annoying and subjective. Like I said, I just wanted to post this information because children in classes all around America are learning about the bell jar study as if it was scientifically sound. It is not. I remember my shame when it was mentioned in my class.</p>

<p>I think that a dash would imply a break in thought so that the “it’s in their genetics” clause would be your refute to the general belief that makes you angry. Basically, I read it as though you were saying, “That makes me angry. It’s not their fault that it’s in their genetics.” But maybe I’m just crazy :)</p>

<p>Is it possible for IQ to drop from a third grade score? Mine was tested at 142 by both a psychologist and a neurologist but I feel like it has probably dropped. Especially since I had a concussion in 6th grade.</p>

<p>No that clause was just a reference to an argument people make.</p>

<p>Also your interpretation makes no sense in the context of my passage.</p>

<p>^Uh, jgraider actually makes a good point :stuck_out_tongue: But we get what you meant.</p>

<p>@Saugus. Completely possible. IQ doesn’t really begin to cement until middle school or so.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>…Which is why I called it hypocritical. But I don’t want to derail the thread over this, so never mind :)</p>

<p>Alright. Lets move on.</p>

<p>Spread the word about the TRUTH of the study to your classmates and teachers, my CC buddies!</p>

<p>For anyone who wants more background on IQ testing–including the racial issues, and how lower IQ does not result from a stupider race, but rather a negative environment–this is a good article:
[gladwell</a> dot com - none of the above](<a href=“http://www.gladwell.com/2007/2007_12_17_c_iq.html]gladwell”>http://www.gladwell.com/2007/2007_12_17_c_iq.html)</p>

<p>Nurture>Nature</p>