The Flight To Quality In Colleges Grows: Harvard Applications Up 57%

"Last March I wrote about the ‘flight to quality’ in college admissions. While the pandemic perhaps has distorted and possibly accelerated some trends, recently released enrollment data from the National Student Clearinghouse on fall 2020 enrollments demonstrate that the flight to quality is growing —-for many Americans, a college diploma is no longer enough —-you need the right diploma, from the right school, in the right major.

In the prestigious Ivy League, applications for next fall’s entering class are booming. Applications for early decision admission at Harvard University were up an extraordinary 57% over last year according to a report Saturday in the Wall Street Journal, and other Ivies did nearly as well. For every Harvard applicant accepted early decision, more than 12 were rejected." …

In the end, Harvard will accept and enroll a class of students pretty much the same size as the have in the last several years. A “flight to apply” doesn’t change the enrollment numbers. No additional students will “get the right diploma” because more are applying. It will just lower the acceptance rate, repeating the fairly meaningless “it’s harder and harder to get in” trope.

4 Likes

Even though the number of this year’s students who will receive diplomas from Harvard or some other “elite” college won’t change much, their composition will to some degree. The biggest driver for the unprecedented increases in applicaitons to these “elite” colleges is the test-optional policy. Some applicants benefited from it while some others were hurt by it. The policy is a necessity this year, and perhaps next. But if it becomes permanent, this dramatic bifucation in applications will cause lasting distortion and dislocation.

I don’t think distortion. Finalists are always strong and by Fitzsimmons’s own acknowledgement, somewhat interchangeable.

It isn’t easy to get to finalist, scores or no scores. You’d see a real change if they went to a truly random process. But they haven’t.

Imo, we need to get away from the idea that no scores means subpar. Some, sure. But they’ll get weeded out.

2 Likes

I don’t buy this claim from Fitzsimmons that finalists are always strong. I’ve personally witnessed mediocrities and more. And that was before distortions caused by COVID.

1 Like

The term “flight to quality” implies that people are worried about the quality of lower ranked schools and therefore apply to higher ranked ones. The increases this year anecdotally at least seem much more linked to taking a chance in a largely test optional environment than any real fear about the quality of schools below the top 10/20/30/whatever arbitrary number counts as “elite”.

1 Like

It’s a one-time blip, unless they continue as test-optional after this year. People who would not have had the test scores to apply, decided to give it a shot this year, since they didn’t have to submit a test score that they couldn’t achieve.

1 Like

I agree with @RichInPitt and others - there will be no real difference.

So 100,000 more of the 2,000,000 college applicants will also have applied, and been rejected, from popular colleges. They still will attend the exact same colleges as they would have anyways, had they not sent in an application to Harvard. Whoopdie-doo.

Besides, the elitism of referring to Harvard and its ilk as being “higher quality” is palpable. Of course, from Richard Vedder, that’s hardly something new.

To get an idea of how his mind works, he has claimed that, somehow, privatization of public universities would reduce tuition. How he could make that claim with a straight face is beyond me.

So I will not take the advice of a person who makes claims, and sticks to them, despite all the evidence pointing the exact opposite.

I mean - in which world does he live in in which private colleges and universities cost less than public ones?

BTW, higher popularity is no more based on quality when we speak of colleges than it is when we speak of anything else.

The only reason that we perceive this is because rankings of colleges include popularity. Imagine if Consumer Reports included factors which increased score based on number of sales, number of possible colors, number of wealthy people who bought this vehicle, and the opinions of the car salespersons. That is the equivalent to the college rankings, and that is what the author of this piece considers as measures of “quality”.

As an aside, he also wrote of “the disdain many colleges show towards male students today relative to what they show towards women”. This is not at all surprising, considering how much he whines about “poor suffering men” in academia. But that’s just an aside.

1 Like