This is about to become real.....input appreciated

Oldest just finished up his junior year of HS (class of 2018), so applying this fall. A version of an “average excellent student”. Well rounded, tippy top stats. No hooks, national awards, interesting ECs or unique talents. No compelling “and”.

35 ACT, 4.0 UW, 4.5 W, currently 1 in a class of 350 in a very average, noncompetitive HS. Likely for NMF. He has taken 9 APs so far, including 5 his junior year. Potentially a National AP Scholar depending upon most recent scores. He will have taken 13 APs by graduation, plus a couple of dual enrollment CC classes. School subject awards for highest grade in AP Bio, AP Calc AB, AP Stats this year, as well as AP Physics, Precal, Honors Chem, Honors Bio, Spanish II and Comp Apps in prior years (they seem to limit him to 3 each year :slight_smile: ). A middling athlete, with some talent for running (track and cross country) but won’t be recruited and doesn’t want to continue running in college. Part-time job at local movie theater. Academic team, captain of quick recall. Elected VP of NHS and Beta Club for next year. Selected to be a part of a new student leadership and mentoring program starting in his HS next year. Significant amount of service hours.

Obviously he has been busy and engaged, but for the most part has made it look pretty easy. Disciplined but isn’t constantly studying and doing homework. Rarely more than an hour on a typical weeknight. Has always spent significant amount of time on the weekends hanging out with his buddies, and now a girlfriend. He is energetic and seems to be efficient with his time at school. Good at taking in and remembering information without a lot of review, plus strong math ability.

Favorite subjects so far have been anatomy, biology, chemistry, and math. Literature and poetry would be among his least favorites. Thinking of majoring in biology, biochemistry or neuroscience. Likely pre-med. He could change his mind, but if he wants to and sets his mind to it I believe medicine would be a realistic and good choice for him.

Personality wise, a bit low key, introverted but not painfully so, kind, thoughtful, sensitive, cautious, a peacemaker, doesn’t enjoy conflict or controversy, has a quirky sense of humor and doesn’t mind laughing at himself.

Leans conservative, but doesn’t wear it on his sleeve and is tolerant of other points of view. However, doesn’t want to wind up being isolated socially or otherwise for his own point of view.

In one sense we aren’t constrained financially, and I could afford to send him wherever he wants to go. At the same time spending more is measured in years of delaying an earlier retirement. I am not anxious to pay for something that doesn’t return something meaningful to him in the end (not just purely from a financial ROI standpoint but that is a part of it). I will pay up if I can see he really wants it and I can get comfortable with the value proposition. We are willing to chase merit.

I find myself going back and forth on whether any schools would be worth paying up for. Running out of time to make up my mind on that subject.

He has toured UK (KY), IU (IN), U of L (Louisville), and Centre College. He open to Alabama, and specifically their computer based honors program. He will likely apply to all of these except IU, and would happily attend at least one of them, so I feel like we have the safety covered. Looking for reaches specifically (from an admission or big merit standpoint).

He has self toured William and Mary, Washington & Lee, UVA, Emory and Vanderbilt while on vacation. Of these, he seems most interested in Emory and Vanderbilt (lottery I know, and merit unlikely). Has expressed some interest in the big merit at Georgia and Clemson also (another lottery I know).

Has a bit of a close to home bias. Doesn’t want to be far away from home unless there is some compelling reason to be.

So if you knew this kid, where would you tell him to apply? Where does such a kid likely to get into? Where would he have the best chance at big merit? And most importantly, where would he thrive and have the best outcome?

Maybe add Davidson. Look on their web page for the merit awards. It looks like you need to apply or get a principal to nominate you for the big ones but with your kid’s stats he should have a good shot and it sounds like it might be a really good fit for him academically and socially.

If you’re looking at Emory and Vandy, you might want to go ahead and add Rice. It’s right across the street from the big Houston medical complex so there are probably tons of opportunities for medical related undergrad ECs (should he go the med school route).

Miami (OH), Rose Hulman.

Neither is too far from central KY, both have a pretty strong focus on undergraduate teaching (not a lot of sections with 300+ students etc.).

Rose Hulman is going to be closer to a reach than many; Miami does offer up to full tuition and has a campus like few others.

Maybe Washington U? They like high test scores and his numerical stats are quite strong.

  1. If you think he might want to go to med school, figure out what residency requirements are for in state tuition for med school and work backwards. You don't want to pay out of state tuition for a public med school. Kentucky even requires so many of the public med school slots be reserved for state residents.
  2. Danville is a small town, almost Mayberry small. Centre's student body isn't much bigger than most high schools. UK has 20k undergrads. UK/U of L students tend to live and go off campus for events. If you go to Centre, the campus is much more of a 24/7 experience. Has he toured Transylvania?

Going further away from home is a lot easier if you go to college near a city with an airport that is a major hub. You can get home to anywhere in the states quickly and relatively cheaply from Atlanta, Chicago, Denver, Dallas, San Francisco, Charlotte, etc.

The six or eight super-elite schools like Harvard, MIT and UChicago are a crapshoot for everyone, but with a 35 ACT and a 4.0 he has a decent shot anywhere.

Moreover, several highly ranked schools have a reputation for favoring high test scores and not caring much about hooks, significant ECs or academic honors, especially if a student applies for Early Decision. By reputation, those schools include Vanderbilt, Notre Dame, Wash U., Cornell, Emory, Georgetown and Tufts. All of them are excellent schools.

I tend to look at the Jesuit schools because of their academic excellence and good feel to their campuses. You don’t have to be catholic or fear recruitment. Near to Kentucky are Rockhurst in KC, Xavier in Cincinnati, St. Louis in St. Louis, Regis in Denver, Detroit Mercy, and about 20 others. My colleges sister school is Webster University in St. Louis and formerly headed by the great Jacqueline Brennan. These schools have the desirable features of other privates and something special too.

Also, look n beautiful Debuque, IA where there is a consortium of privates. Actually, Iowa has many small privates with good academics.

If he goes to medical school, would the amount you contribute for his undergraduate school affect what you may contribute for medical school, if any?

Seconding WashU. They have a surprisingly large number of full and partial tuition competitive scholarships. Pretty campus, really nice kids, great academics and advising. If Emory appealed to your S, WashU likely will as well.

Some really helpful posts here, but I would start with @ucbalumnusL would you contribute his college fund to med school if he did something full-freight like Alabama honors college? He would still be in-state for med school in KY (for both fees & admissions, in-state can be a winner for med school).

@ucbalumnus Yes it would most likely.

Nobody has mentioned Tulane, Wake, Richmond, SMU, UT-Dallas, Cincy, and the two Miamis, so I will.

I’m actually pretty confident that out of WashU/Vandy/Emory/Richmond/Centre/W&L/Tulane/Wake/SMU/UT-Dallas/Cincy/Miami/Miami, he’ll get at least one major scholarship and possibly several.

If he’s National Merit look into OU, UCF and UT Dallas (even if he’s not NM).

@roethlisburger I had assumed in most cases if you are out of state as full time student you typically are still considered a resident of your home state. I will look into that.

Centre did a good job with the visit. If cost wasn’t a variable, out of his in state options it would be his first choice, with UK and their honors college a close second. I know they would be a lot different experiences, and there are aspects he liked of both.

He has seen Transylvania’s campus up close while in LEXINGTON but has not done a full visit. He has mentioned before he might be interested in applying there also.

@50N40W I agree he should look at Miami OH. Can you expand on your comment about the campus?

There have been a couple of kids we know from his HS who went to Rose Hulman. If not interested in engineering I guess you would still see it as a good option for a pre med kid? Maybe this is a bit of a strange criteria to focus on, but all things being equal I think he would prefer the male female to be a little more favorable, closer to 50/50 at least.

He should add Rhodes college to his list. It offers great merit $$ for tip top students.
10 years the daughter of an old time CC parent, with top grades/ scores and whose goal was Med school, was accepted at Yale and also offered a full tuition scholarship at Rhodes. She went to Rhodes, was at the top of her class and was then accepted, again, at Yale for Med school.
UG GPA and MCAT scores are EXTREMELY important for med school admissions and going to a U like Rice or Wash U that had loads of students who are ALSO pre med can make med school acceptances very competitive.
Just be SURE that merit scholarship deadlines are met for whatever college he applies to for merit consideration.
They are often early and some may equire separate applications.

The way I read Kentucky’s rules, the child’s domicile remains that of the parent as long as the child is a dependent of the parents. If your kid was independent from you for tax purposes and living OOS when enrolling in med school, there’s a possibility he might not be considered a Kentucky resident. Transy may be a good compromise if he likes UK and Centre. It has the LAC education, but the experience of living in a city. He could even make it over to Commonwealth stadium, Rupp, the Singletary center, or W.T. Young.

I’m going to go out on a biased limb and suggest that you keep your eye on University of Florida too. The president is trying to draw in more OOS students and it seems like there will be increased opportunities for scholarships based on what the state legislature is doing (long story - check the UF threads for info).

A good friend of our family’s son went to UF for undergrad, and then medical school. It is an excellent place for that pursuit. Plus UF has many other good programs if he changes his mind.

Gainesville (north central FL) wouldn’t be terribly far from KY, though of course it is not close either.

Just a thought! You have had good suggestions here. Congratulations on reaching this exciting time with your son!

I’m looking for the same kind of options for my quite similar son (probably leans liberal rather than conservative, but otherwise near perfect match). We are looking for merit as well, although son has been a bit taken with prestige bug. He wants to apply to Stanford. But he will have Oklahoma and Miami of Ohio for safer bets. Im pushing for Wash U, Rice, Emory, Vandy, W&L, Trinity. We’ll see.