This is about to become real.....input appreciated

My bright-but-unhooked daughter was also a “low-key” high-schooler who “leaned conservative.” She has been very happy at Rice, which provides a collaborative and generally non-ideological college environment.

She was also accepted at Cornell, Wash U, and Emory–all schools at which your son would be a competitive candidate.

Time to give an update. He ended up applying to four schools - Kentucky, Louisville, Alabama, and Centre. Accepted to all four with merit, but he is only considering Kentucky and Louisville at this point. Long story short, it became clear he wants large research U in his own backyard, less than two hours from home.

He is confirmed so far as NMSF, and should be NMF (to be confirmed in next two/three weeks). He was accepted into Honors program at Louisville, specifically their Honors Science LLP. Will learn if he is accepted into Honors program at UK on February 16th.

Both schools give big merit awards for NMF. Louisville is full tuition plus $8k stipend for four years. Kentucky is full tuition plus $10k stipend, but stipend is for years one and two only. He will also get $2.5k a year in KEES money from state (lottery funded state scholarship). Not much gap between year 1 COA at Louisville and his merit (+/-$1k), but there would be about a $5k gap at Kentucky, so has applied for some local scholarships that could stack up to the COA limit. May get and be able to stack one of the NM $2,500 awards.

So all in, looking at tuition, R&B, and meal plans only, I think Louisville will be net zero 4 year cost. Kentucky would be less than $25k net four year cost, primarily in years 3 and 4 when stipend goes away. (He may consider moving off campus or being an RA, to reduce).

He interviewed last week for Singletary scholarship at UK. Would not increase his financial award, but a nice program and honor. Was invited yesterday to interviews for Louisville’s Guaranteed Entrance to Med School program and also their Brown Fellows program. Again, would not change financial award, but significant perks. GEMS benefit is obvious, while Brown is a neat program that would allow him to do something abroad fully funded all three summers.

All three (Singletary, GEMS, and Brown) have long odds and are unknowns at this point. Will play out over the next few weeks.

This is where it gets hard. This will be 100% his decision. I will be beyond thrilled and excited for him whatever he decides. He does look to us as his parents for advice and counsel though, so much that I have to watch my words sometimes because I feel like they have too much impact :).

Leaving out the two programs at Louisville, he would have clear choice, he would be going to Kentucky even with the slight cost difference. It is more of the state flagship experience I think he wants. I think he has noted a lot of subtle differences in the student body, professors, and campus life that just make it seem like a better fit. But he does like Louisville also, and with these two programs in play plus the cost difference it still has appeal to him. He can only attend one school at a time unfortunately!

Any last words of wisdom?

just wanted to add congratulations. a wonderful outcome!

Sweet! Congrats!

Note that GEMS requires maintaining a 3.4 college GPA and scoring at or above the national mean on each section of the MCAT. https://louisville.edu/admissions/apply/gep/gems

Still, if he wants to go to Louisville anyway, and wants to go on to medical school, having GEMS is better than not having it.

Sounds like he has some great options!

What happened to Cincy? He didn’t like it after all?

@OHMomof2 he did on paper, but once UK clarified their scholarship picture and kept the Patterson for NMF, he lost interest. Couldn’t get him to visit or apply to UC. He couldn’t picture any scenario where he pick UC over UK, so he didn’t want to mess with it.

These guaranteed-admission programs seem to promise quite a bit more than they deliver, i.e., the group of students who qualify to continue on to med school under the program is the same as those who would qualify to be admitted the old fashioned way.

It would be a popular option for a college to establish an guaranteed admission program that doesn’t have such onerous requirements. A reasonable proposal would be to accept only those with very high stats (say, SAT 1500+, ACT 34+, commensurate GPA), and then allow them to maintain a 3.0 college GPA and skip the MCAT. My guess is that they’d do fine in med school. I wonder if the med school accrediting authorities are blocking this?

@LOUKYDAD - he has some wonderful opportunities and momentous decisions ahead! He can’t go wrong with either choice! If I am betting…he will end up at UK!

I just wanted share my kiddo’s experience with a direct entry program (think GEMS here). My DD2016 accepted at place in the direct entry DPT program at Marquette (900 applicants for 75ish slot) She had been talking about being a PT since freshman year of high school, she shadowed PTs during her senior year, she was absolutely convinced PT was THE career. Combine that with her personality traits of maturity and tenacity and it seemed obvious that a direct entry DPT program was the right choice, surely she wouldn’t change her mind! Low and behold, as is all too common with college students, this past Fall semester college sophomore DD hit a wall, she had been wavering on her intended career path since late last spring, not because of grades but sheer change of heart and change of circumstances. She struggled mightily with wanting to change her major, but not being willing to admit that it was OK to change her mind (it’s not something she does easily) and squandering an opportunity in a direct entry program. It was very apparent in her demeanor, she was pushing through, but the spark had dissappeared. Ultimately, she ended up changing her major, but due to the coursework already under her belt she was limited a bit is her options and has added a semester to her graduation date (although still less than DPT) but, the spark is back!

So my cautionary tale is…direct entry/guaranteed admissions plans are fantastic opportunities, but it is extremely important to “know thyself”. Sometimes “things”, “wants”, “needs” change and for kids that these types of programs appeal too, changing their plan of action can be near impossible emotionally AND academically. Medical school is accessible from many avenues, sometimes getting there on the most direct path isn’t all that it is cracked up to be!

I wish your son all the best in his choices. I am sure he will be successful no matter the path he picks! You have much to be proud of!

Louisville had an Saturday event day back in October they called Accolade where they invited high stat students to campus. DS and I went and the GEMS program was one of the workshops we attended. We noted additional benefits of the program are targeted opportunities to observe and learn about the profession, various medical specialties, and really get the sense of what it is like to like to be trained and work as a physician. Certainly there are opportunities to do some of that on your own, but perhaps not to the extent in a program like this. I like that from the standpoint I want him to know what he is getting into and make absolutely for sure this is really what he wants to do with his life. @labegg your points are well taken, exactly what is on my mind, and actually one of the key benefits of the program. Although they are definitely looking for kids who are “convinced” they want to become doctors, there is no binding commitment to go to med school at Louisville or anyone else.

They had several students from the cohort groups that are in the program now speak to the students and their families and answer questions. Truly an impressive group. We will get a chance to hear more on the interview day, which they invite families to come to as well to learn more about the program and opportunity. Half day on an upcoming Saturday.

DS sat down and talked to me last night (in front of the TV watching UK basketball game ironically). One day out from getting the invites to two Louisville interviews, he just isn’t pumped up about them. He is leaning hard toward UK to the point there is some desire to just pull the trigger and accept at UK and decline at Louisville. Progress fatigue and/or the fact in likes UK. Not sure how much of which. But he said he also has a fear in his mind of passing up some really great opportunity.

As we talked through it, it is clear the above in his mind is on the assumption he is going to be confirmed as NMF (and therefore receives at least the automatic NMF Patterson scholarship at UK) and is going to be accepted into the Honors program at UK. (The Singletary at UK isn’t a deal breaker either way)

Since he will have both assumptions validated (or not) by February 16th, about three weeks from now, my advice was for him to wait until then. The GEMS interview will be done by then but not the Brown. So go to the GEMS interview day. If he still feels the way he feels now on February 16th, he can make the call then to commit to UK or let the Louisville opportunities play out. Accept at UK, decline Louisville and cancel the Brown interview, and designate UK as his first choice school with NM.

I feel all but certain everything will work out at UK the way he wants them to, but it just doesn’t make sense to me to take a chance that somehow he doesn’t get the Patterson stipend (without it he would have full tuition only at UK, no stipend) or get into Honors at UK. If the unexpected happens, he would appreciate then having the Louisville doors still open to him.

I told him if he wants he can tell himself and anyone that he wants to (well accept the admissions folks at Louisville!) that he “plans” to attend UK. Just don’t do anything officially until February 16th at the earliest.

Do you think this was good advice?

I’m a fan of leaving options open as long as possible so, yes.

February 16th came around and it was all good news. He was confirmed as NMF. He got into the honors college at UK. And he got into the GEMS program at Louisville.

He has an interview for Brown Fellows at Louisville this weekend. Should find out whether he will receive Singletary at UK before the end of the month. Merit weekend at UK (an admitted student day basically) is less than 3 weeks away. Then he will make a decision.

The GEMS thing causes so much mixed feeling for me and makes it so much more confusing. If he preferred Louisville this would be easy. He would be going to Louisville. But he doesn’t. He prefers UK.

If it was just the undergrad to think about and the difference in scholarships it would be easy the other direction. He would go to UK.

It’s this GEMS thing. And less the guaranteed entry aspect and the program. They shared that they have historically given approximately half off Med school tuition to the incoming GEMS cohort. 75k or so less debt for Med school. At that level I could probably help him graduate from Med school with no debt. Not guaranteed, but they have had the program over 30 years and they have continued to do it. They want these 10 kids to choose U of L Med and this is how they do it.

Labegg’s comments above do way on mind to. On the other hand, the money aside, maybe it is better in the end not to go into UG with everything so determined. I don’t want him to feel that pressure or weight if it is going to become that.

Why does he like UK better? I think it’s a vibe thing. A feeling that it is more his crowd. Nicer facilities (dorms, classrooms, etc.). A perception that the professors are more engaged with the students. More of the flagship experience.

I’m expecting him to choose UK. He is a kid and the $75k in after tax money isn’t what he focuses on. I know UK is great deal too. I am going to be sick about the GEMS thing though. Especially if what I expect to happen does happen, and four years from now he is in the same spot, applying to U of L Med school but paying full boat. The alternate they give his spot to is going to be grateful. This is really his decision to struggle with at the end of the day, not mine. He has it pretty much funded either way.

And yes I realize he has great options and can’t lose either way. It is still hard not to obsess about.

Wow GEMS sounds pretty cool if he knows he wants to go to med school. Tough decisions ahead!

The extra med school debt is his to own, though.

He may regret it later, but he has to make the choice.

@PurpleTitan Agreed.

It is a bit of a weird discussion to have, because it is based on so many hypotheticals. Only an additional $20k of actual difference in cost, but hypothetically a $95k difference. If he goes to med school, if he plans to go to U of L med school, if they continue to offer the med school scholarship, etc.

But you are right. In the end he could end up buying that vibe he wants with $75k additional debt. His choice.

It is hard to help a 18 year old understand what $75k in after tax disposable income is worth. He had a part time job at a movie theater. Maybe I could express it in the number of theaters cleaned.

Heh. Maybe. Though if he becomes a doctor, they get paid decently.

If it makes you feel better, for a doctor, that’s not a huge amount.

For other working stiffs like us, it takes lots of years of work and not too much bad luck to save up so much.

Also (to make you feel better again), some families are spending close to 4X that amount more even though their kid has gotten full-ride to schools that can take them to their goals.

I hear you.

You can mess with this and transl;ate it into things he might care about: https://studentloanhero.com/calculators/student-loan-payment-calculator-2/

$75K at 6% is a $833 a month bill for TEN years. That’s enough for rent in a lot of cities. If he saved it those ten years, he’d have nearly $100K for a down payment on a house or to invest.

$24, 918 is just the interest he’d pay, enough to buy a nice car or motorcycle or boat.

IDK if that kind of visualization helps for you but it sure makes me personally want to avoid loans at all costs!

I second Wash U and the sentiment that it is quite similar to Emory. If he likes Emory, he’ll probably like Wash U too.

There is another private powerhouse in the South and i’m not sure anyone has mentioned it yet: Duke. It’s more of a partying, rah-rah school than Emory/Rice/Wash U – more like Vanderbilt than the other three. But like those other schools, it’s very strong all-around academically.

Venturing a bit north of the Mason-Dixon line takes you into the territory of schools like Princeton and Penn, and even closer to home is Georgetown.

Good point, @OHMomof2.

You could point out that you can reasonably expect investments to double in real terms every 20 years (and that’s a little conservative in forecasting). Which means an extra $300K by retirement in today’s dollars (so probably millions by the time he retires with inflation).