Time to give an update. He ended up applying to four schools - Kentucky, Louisville, Alabama, and Centre. Accepted to all four with merit, but he is only considering Kentucky and Louisville at this point. Long story short, it became clear he wants large research U in his own backyard, less than two hours from home.
He is confirmed so far as NMSF, and should be NMF (to be confirmed in next two/three weeks). He was accepted into Honors program at Louisville, specifically their Honors Science LLP. Will learn if he is accepted into Honors program at UK on February 16th.
Both schools give big merit awards for NMF. Louisville is full tuition plus $8k stipend for four years. Kentucky is full tuition plus $10k stipend, but stipend is for years one and two only. He will also get $2.5k a year in KEES money from state (lottery funded state scholarship). Not much gap between year 1 COA at Louisville and his merit (+/-$1k), but there would be about a $5k gap at Kentucky, so has applied for some local scholarships that could stack up to the COA limit. May get and be able to stack one of the NM $2,500 awards.
So all in, looking at tuition, R&B, and meal plans only, I think Louisville will be net zero 4 year cost. Kentucky would be less than $25k net four year cost, primarily in years 3 and 4 when stipend goes away. (He may consider moving off campus or being an RA, to reduce).
He interviewed last week for Singletary scholarship at UK. Would not increase his financial award, but a nice program and honor. Was invited yesterday to interviews for Louisville’s Guaranteed Entrance to Med School program and also their Brown Fellows program. Again, would not change financial award, but significant perks. GEMS benefit is obvious, while Brown is a neat program that would allow him to do something abroad fully funded all three summers.
All three (Singletary, GEMS, and Brown) have long odds and are unknowns at this point. Will play out over the next few weeks.
This is where it gets hard. This will be 100% his decision. I will be beyond thrilled and excited for him whatever he decides. He does look to us as his parents for advice and counsel though, so much that I have to watch my words sometimes because I feel like they have too much impact :).
Leaving out the two programs at Louisville, he would have clear choice, he would be going to Kentucky even with the slight cost difference. It is more of the state flagship experience I think he wants. I think he has noted a lot of subtle differences in the student body, professors, and campus life that just make it seem like a better fit. But he does like Louisville also, and with these two programs in play plus the cost difference it still has appeal to him. He can only attend one school at a time unfortunately!
Any last words of wisdom?