You weren’t rejected from those 4 schools because you weren’t good enough, or because you were wrong about what you should be doing in high school. You were rejected because almost everyone is. You’d made a list of “I want at least one acceptance other than TX shoe-ins for valedictorians” without real advice from knowledgeable adults. That’s all.
It was a natural list for a kid to make, which is why thousands and thousands of great students (including valedictorians) make it every year. Everyone has heard of Harvard etc, and I guess your friends and the adults in your life who have been telling you that you’ll “definitely” get into one of those schools think “Harvard etc. is for smart people, she’s smart, hence she’ll get into Harvard etc.” Basic logical fallacy, made without research, but a common one.
Actually, chances are if you’d applied in 1980, you could well have gotten in. Those mega-top tier, top-of-the-glittering-mountain schools are WAY more competitive now, thanks to internet, Common App, etc. Thinking that a few more ECs would have made the difference for you is making the same mistake – e.g., thinking of a “good application” as a kind of guarantee. It’s not. Those schools are Willie Wonka’s Chocolate Factory, and most of the people who are trying to get the golden ticket have been told by someone in their life – probably many, many people – that they can get in. Yet there are only so many golden tickets – about 2,000 for Harvard, for instance… Whereas around 37,000 kids try their chances, and each of them has a cheering section of friends and adults who think they ought to get in.
Btw there was a girl on my hall at Northwestern (ages ago) who transferred in from Harvard … because she was miserable to be so far from home! That could have been you if you’d gotten in, LOL. You basically wanted the golden tickets so you could be close to home with bragging rights (or perhaps more accurately, Fulfilling Expectations rights), but you didn’t really want to go to the Chocolate Factory. And if you’d gotten the ticket, given how depressed you are now at not meeting the expectations of others in your life, you might have felt forced to go for the same reason … your friends and adults in your life would be telling you that’s what you should do. But, in fact, you got what you wanted. Now you don’t have to feel forced to go to Harvard or the suchlike, and then transfer back later to some place closer to your family and dogs.
So in the end, it seems the universe gave you the right choice
Congratulations, and good luck picking between your fantastic options!