Vigilantism is justified when the government has failed to enforce the law.

<p>This is the current LD topic in speech and debate. You guys have any theory, philosophy, thoughts on this? Anything would be appreciated. Thanks.</p>

<p>All I know is that LD is teh h4xorz.
I love it.</p>

<p>I agree but I can’t use that in a debate :D.</p>

<p>what’s yo value criterion? i guess i’d set up a framework in which the best course of action is the one that keeps the most people obeying the laws, and i’d go from there. aff would argue that vigilantism would scare people away from disobeying the laws but neg could talk about how the law would lose its value if people were going against the law to enforce it. or are you supposed to set up different value criteria for your two cases? haha i dunno anything about debate HOPE THIS HELPED GOOD LUCK</p>

<p>also, personally, i think that vigilantism is stupid and never justified. eye for an eye makes the world go blind ‘n’ what not.</p>

<p>FOR THE RECORD</p>

<p>i’m part of an unmoderated newsgroup, and bad things get done all the time there but what makes it worse is the “vigilantes” that get mad at the offenders and try to tell them to stop their behavior. usually the vigilantes do worse things than the offenders ever did or intended to do, because they feel justified by their sense of self-righteousness. when you don’t have rule of law it’s easy to cross the line between justice and revenge.</p>

<p>we’re having a massive flamewar right now over things that were done by accident, things that were said and done six years ago by people we don’t know, things that might have been done but we have no idea because a lot of people lie … basically the whole group has degenerated into one big argument, and that’s all because we don’t have some good moderators to delete posts and ban obvious ■■■■■■. and because in the absence of good moderators everyone feels they have to play the role of makeshift moderator on behalf of the group.</p>

<p>Remember Judge Dredd… </p>

<p>I am the law… the jury, the judge, and the executioner.</p>

<p>hell no, the laws oppress us enough as it is.</p>

<p>Vigilantism is just anarchy. Everyone has different definitions of what the standards of social law out to be, and so criminals would consider themselves vigilantes doing what they believe is right (namely their own belief of what they should get out of the world, their own value of justice), and the same would be for those who strike out against those criminals - they are just imposing their own beliefs on the world.</p>

<p>Vigilantism is crime, simple as that.</p>

<p>The Dark Knight is a great movie, but is not reality.</p>

<p>I suppose vigilantism would work in theory to get people to obey the laws, but it invariably leads to the vigilantes making their own laws. Pretty much what ^ said.</p>

<p>yes but on the other hand some order, by even vigilantes’ hands, is better than utter chaos and anarchy no? But yeah I’m sure that justice, liberty, etc. are going to be common vps, and order, control, etc will be some common vcs.</p>

<p>Ahh… once again, human goodness is underrated, and the use of power is overrated.</p>

<p>update: i saw Watchmen and my opinion has remained fairly intact </p>

<p>we’ll see where it goes when i read the graphic novel</p>

<p>Vigilantism can be used to restore the Rule of Law.
Look at your neighborhood watch as a minor version of vigilantism. They go out and do the patrol job of the police. Just that keeps the criminals a little bit more careful in that particular neighborhood. </p>

<p>In Skidmomre, Missouri, the Justice system was very just to Ken McElroy, but not the people… Ken McElroy was a bully who robbed, raped, shot at towns people for over 20 years. He always got off with minor punishment, through intimidating witnesses. Cops couldn’t or wouldn’t do anything. After being released again, this time for shooting a shop keeper, he came into town on a Saturday afternoon. He was shot on Main Street in front of many people and nobody saw anything. No one was ever arrested. Finally the people of Skidmore got justice, not revenge.
Athens, Tennessee in 1946 was a case where the elected officials were going to steal an election again. The people had repeatedly asked for help from the Federal and State governments and received no help. The County Sheriff was corrupt and ran the county as a dictator. He and those elected officials of his party wouldn’t let the opponents watch the counting of the votes. The police beat poll watchers and shot a Black man when he attempted to vote for the opposition. The opposition party was made up entirely of WWII vets who had just returned from fighting dictators in other parts of the world. When the Sheriff and his cronies tried to lock up the Poll watchers, a firefight broke out. The Vets won both the firefight and the untampered election. Order was restored. </p>

<p>Whether you agree with vigilantism or not, when people get so fed up with the corruption or neglect of elected officials and the Courts, don’t be surprised when things like those happen. Human nature is what it is. If justice is not meted out by those whose job it is, people will get frustrated and cases of vigilantism may pop up. </p>

<p>So is it justified, yes sometimes; sometimes it is even necessary.</p>

<p>I want to be THE BATMAN</p>

<p>Watch the ****ing dark knight. Theres actually a scene there where dent and wayne discuss vigilantism. I can send you the script if you want it</p>