<p>I’ve been accepted to my dream school, but for a while I was convinced it wouldn’t happen. I was bitter about not working harder. I was bitter that I didn’t “perfect” those standardized tests or become a National Merit scholar. What really defines a person in the end? Because I didn’t have that 2400 SAT or 36 ACT, I had to ensure my application/s kicked ass. Do those National Merit finalists and the like deserve more than us in the end? You can’t subgroup these kids, right, but should I feel bitter about kids who get these entitlements and yet do nothing else? And these “entitlements” ensure them acceptance to any college?
I’m excited for the future, but also in a haze about what anyone really deserves.</p>
<p><em>Bangs head multiple times on keyboard</em></p>
<p>One of the absolute last things that defines a person is whether or not they are a National Merit Scholar. UGH.</p>
<p>This post makes so very, very little sense to me.</p>
<p>^ LOL ChocolateBanana. She/he offers the best advice and I love the banging the head on the keyboard thing. It’s so fitting. feilisha - I don’t think that kids who achieve NMS status really get any other benefit other than a small sum of money and recognition on the official website. Let’s try this: More profs than not were not National Merit scholars :rolleyes:</p>
<p>^At my school, we got cookies and juice. AWESOME.</p>
<p>@ChocolateBanana: I’m not saying achieving that status “defines a person”.
@Millancad:I apologize for the confusion. Even I don’t know what I’m trying to say.
@Vertigo: What will bother me is if these National Merit “scholars” clinch acceptance to a top tier school without having done anything else in high school.</p>
<p>I am a he. </p>
<p>And @Millancad, now I am craving cookies. AND juice.</p>
<p>^^Feilisha, they do NOT “clinch acceptances” to top-schools. Not at all.
And usually, those people probably HAVE done other stuff.
And even if not, that’s just the way it goes–that’s the way the game is played.</p>
<p>There is absolutely NO reason to feel bitter or anything about it. Just be happy with getting into a great college yourself. :)</p>
<p>Thanks, ChocolateBanana. I hate playing the game, but we will see who breaks the rules.</p>
<p>^^^^Oh, I think I get what you’re saying now Feilisha. Being NMS does not clinch an acceptance at top schools. Avg score for NMSF nationwide might be 211-ish. It’s not a big award.</p>
<p>^^Just be happy with how you did–and be happy for others. Bitterness is usually a wasted emotion that just rots away far superior feelings.</p>
<p>I always assumed that if you were a NMSF/NMF, you were guaranteed admission. Hmmm… and in retrospect, Millancad, you’re right; it really isn’t that big of an award.</p>
<p>But that’s the thing - I don’t think that acceptance is cinched by one factor alone. Just as it isn’t achieved via standardized test scores, GPA, or extra curricular activities, solely. Acceptance is a combination of alllll of the former. Haven’t you heard? Perfect 2400s get turned away from Harvard.
Same principle.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Meh, I received the award and only added it on my application as part of an addendum. It’s good for the scholarship, and that’s it.</p>
<p>Now, let’s say someone makes it to Blue MOP and places in Best Category in ISEF. Earning those kinds of accolades takes incredible intelligence, dedication, and natural proficiency. If someone does win these awards (and others at this level), we could assume that he or she does indeed deserve (but not guaranteed) entrance to most of her schools, given that everything else is above average.</p>
<p>@Vertigo, thanks for being more realistic than I’ve been; I shouldn’t be bitter nor should I be thinking in a shallow, immature mindset. It’s good to know that in the end, these top tier schools take you in.</p>
<p>^^And you might not even get the scholarship. I didn’t. But I got an NAF scholarship, and you can’t get both, so I guess that’s cool.
But it’s like max $2000, I think, which isn’t much most places.</p>
<p>Even people with big awards, like USAMO finalists and stuff, get rejected from the HYPMSes of the world. Nothing is a definite in. Except winning Jeopardy, everywhere but Swarthmore.</p>
<p>That last sentence was a joke.</p>
<p>Millancad, that last sentence will hold true for the rest of eternity. And I don’t mean your “That last sentence was a joke” sentence.</p>
<p>Confidence defines a person. :)</p>
<p>@rupee, or bloated arrogance?</p>
<p>@millancad: at least you got juices and cookies… I didn’t even get that!! Not fair :p.</p>