I’m in a similar place, but a year further along, as the OP. My daughter will have 10 varsity letters when she graduates this spring from a top BS but she’s not a viable recruit at the mid sized D1 schools that she favors. She has one other notable EC outside of sports but it is hard to determine if it matters to many schools.
I think that if your kid has good grades and good scores from a top BS as well as solid sports ECs that’s enough for all but the most selective colleges and universities and sometimes it’s good enough for those too if the grades and scores are really good. Your college counselor, and Naviance, will help you determine what are reasonable choices for “likely”, “match” and “reach” schools. “Reasonable” is key though.