What's the deal with music conductors?

<p>I know they keep the beat and all, but what makes a good conductor good? Yesterday I saw a bunch of recordings by Karajan and then Carlos Kleiber. They didn’t do anything that really wow-ed me - they just conducted. </p>

<p>How much talent does it really take? All they do is keep the beat…</p>

<p>Gustavo Dudamel is so cool though!</p>

<p>Its all on the musicians.</p>

<p>The conductors fit the puzzle pieces together.</p>

<p>Hmm, old thread.</p>

<p>Anyway, the conductor has to take individually talented musicians and make them work together to create his own personal, beautiful interpretation of the music. That’s why there are so many recordings of one particular work. The conducting (i.e. “waving the stick around”) is just the most basic part of the job.</p>

<p>The musicians can play the music… But anyone who thinks that all conductors do is “put the pieces together” is incredibly naive. First of all there is so much more to music than the notes on the page. That is why the Bernstein’s Mahler is different to Boulez’ Mahler is different to Dudamel’s… The conductor has to make it their own. Also to keep 100+ musicians on the same page in terms of touch, feel and sonic effect is incredibly difficult.</p>

<p>PS a conductor really should not wow you with his actions but with his “sound”…</p>

<p>Computer Generated Music > Acoustic Music</p>

<p>^Hans Zimmer ftw.</p>