OK, since you mentioned NY:
The son of a friend wants Secondary Math Education, but tests horribly. Here’s a list I put together for him… most probably have Elementary Ed as well. All are within 4 hours of our Long Island home. He wants a small school, so most are smaller than you mentioned. All accept ballpark 50-75% of the applicants. It may give you a starting place.
Or, plan B, use the College Match feature on this site!!
But as long as you’re going for education, you may want to take a look at certification reciprocity with you home state, or wherever you see yourself living after graduation. Each state has its own requirements for teacher certification. Some states will happily accept the certification of another state, some make it a bit more difficult. You can find the info on each state’s Board of Education website, under “teacher certification.” Or google “states offering teacher reciprocity with ____” or something close.
cost (K) size
Albertus Magnus Coll New Haven, CT - 40 – 1356
Alfred Univ Alfred, NY - 35 --1908
Bloomfield Coll Bloomfield, NJ - 35 --2036
Cabrini Coll Radnor, PA - 50 --1432
Cairn University Langhorne, PA -30 --928
Caldwell Uni Caldwell, NJ -40 --1644
Central CT State Univ New Britain, CT -25 --9500
Fitchburg State Uni Fitchburg, MA -17 --4163
Gwynedd-Mercy University Gwynedd Valley, PA -40 --2244
Kean Univ Union, NJ -24 --13052
Keystone Coll La Plume, PA -32 --1670
Marywood Univ Scranton, PA -41 --2244
MA Coll of Liberal Arts North Adams, MA -22 --1600
U of MA Lowell Lowell, MA -20 --12287
Medaille Coll Buffalo, NY -34 --1800
Millersville Univ of PA Millersville, PA -26 --7424
Misericordia Univ Dallas, PA -37 --2427
Molloy Coll Rockville Centre, NY -24 --3444
NY Inst of Tech -Old Westbury Old Westbury, NY
Niagara Univ Niagara University, NY -38 K --3175
Rhode Island Coll Providence, RI -27 --7553
Richard Stockton Coll Galloway, NJ -24 – 7515
Rowan Univ Glassboro, NJ -31 --9947
Russell Sage Coll Troy, NY -38 --1659
St Francis U Loretto, PA -40 --1832
St Vincent Coll Latrobe, PA -40 – 1693
Seton Hill Univ Greensburg, PA -50 – 5497
St Francis Coll Brooklyn Heights, NY
or Patchogue NY
St John Fisher Coll Rochester, NY -38 – 2960
St. Joseph’s College, Brooklyn, NY
SUNY Old Westbury Old Westbury, NY
SUNY Oneonta Oneonta, NY -18 --5822
Temple Univ Philadelphia, PA -33 --27,587
Western Connecticut State Univ Danbury, CT -25 --5583
William Paterson Univ of NJ Wayne, NJ -49
Wilson Coll Chambersburg, PA -39 – 753
York Coll of PA York, PA -25 --5182
Alvernia Univ. Reading, PA - 37 --2346
Castleton State Coll Castleton, VT -29 --2068
D’Youville College Buffalo, NY - 32 – 2139
DeSales Univ Center Valley, PA -41 --2468
Dowling Coll Oakdale, NY -25 – 3260
Edinboro Univ of PA Edinboro, PA -18 --6090
Felician Coll Lodi, NJ -40 --1775
Gannon Univ Erie, PA -39 --3000
Holy Family U Philadelphia, PA - 36 --2139
Indiana U of PA Indiana, PA -26 --13,000
Keene State Coll Keene, NH -26 --5206
Keuka Coll Keuka Park, NY - 36 --2600
Kutztown Univ of PA Kutztown, PA -32 --1670
Lyndon State Coll Lyndonville, VT -28 --1406
Mansfield Univ of PA Mansfield, PA -26 --2824
U of New Hampshire Durham, NH -36 --12,000
Plymouth State Univ Plymouth, NH -27 --4328
U of Rhode Island Kingston, RI -36 --13,000
Rivier University Nashua, NH -37 --1559
Coll of St Rose Albany, NY -36 --2881
U of Southern ME Gorham, ME -29 --7400
St Thomas Aquinas Coll Sparkill, NY -37 --1800
Wilkes Univ Wilkes-Barre, PA -38 --2302
ETA-- sorry, I just spent 10 minutes formatting this table so nicely, but the computer ate it up. The first number is ballpark cost, the second is student body size.