Hi. I’m an Asian male and a computer science major freshman at the University of Alabama. FWIW, I’m an international student first time going to school in the US. I cannot speak about the other school, but I can talk about UA all day.
Like a lot of others, UA got my attention thanks to its very generous scholarship. However, I found out there are more to UA than just football and scholarship, and I have really enjoyed my time here.
What I really like about UA is that with its scholarship, it attracts a very large and diverse group of people. There are 53% out-of-state students (just a quick comparison, 17% at Rutgers and very very small percentage at Texas A&M), so you’re able to make a lot of friends from everywhere in the US here. Also, with its large population, you’re sure to find your niche somewhere at school.
And football. When I first came here, I knew nothing about football. I didn’t even know our school is so great at it. But after just one semester, Alabama football is definitely my pride. It is a lot of fun regardless of how much you care about sport.
And lastly, I’ld talk about academics. Yes, UA is not the highest ranked, but it is not a bad school by any means. At first I was very concerned about prestige being an Asian kid directly from Asia. However, I realized that the ranking really does not bear a lot of importance in the future. Yes, a CS degree from MIT or Stanford may raise a pair of eyebrow or two, but what really matters is what you can create. And in preparation for that, I think our CS department is doing a very good job. An upperclassmen told me that his friend who transferred from UA CS to Georgia Tech CS claimed that UA prepared him more than enough for his classes at Georgia Tech. After experiencing first hand, I can say that our CS program is quite rigorous, and you should not be afraid to go to here.
IMHO, UA is a bigger name school than Rutgers and Texas A&M (thanks to football), even though the other two have great engineering programs.
In the end, it all comes down to how much prestige means to you, and how much you are willing to pay for that.