Why are pre-20th century philosophers so misogynous?

<p>Yes, I know - they were a product of their times. But philosophers are frequently quite forward-thinking for their time - it just happens that they don’t happen to be forward thinking about females in particular. </p>

<p>What I do find interesting is how Nieztsche once remarked that there has never been a major philosopher who married ever since Socrates.</p>

<p>PS: I’m no feminist and I do think that some of these philosophers do speak negative truths about women. But there are easily negative truths about men too.</p>

<p>Haha. Well I am a feminist, but I have nothing better to tell you than “they were a product of their times,” unfortunately. [edit] Just kidding! I think I may have found a reason for it. The philosophical titan Aristotle’s influence: <a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristotle’s_views_on_women[/url]"&gt;http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristotle’s_views_on_women&lt;/a&gt;, which simply wasn’t challenged until more recently.</p>

<p>I find that there tends to be more sexism in fields where there are less women. The more men work alongside women, the more they realize, hey, they’re not that different from me! Since philosophy–and other intellectual fields-- was highly dominated by men back then, that may be part of it.</p>

<p>Huh. Is that Nietzsche quote really true? That would be quite dramatic…</p>

<p>Men who can’t get women blame women.</p>

<p>At least in the case of Nietzsche.</p>

<p>lol, good point about Aristotle. But lots of philosophers (esp Nietzsche) did reject the conclusions of Aristotle, since Aristotle’s philosophy is extremely rigid. </p>

<p>Yes the Nietzsche quote is true:

</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Whoa. So philosophers were essentially like clergymen? Well… like the way clergymen were supposed to be, a lot of them still ended up getting rich and having affairs. </p>

<p>I’m so glad we now live in an age where fame whoring (or more politely, “striving for achievement and recognition”) is taken as a fact of life for everyone.</p>

<p>Perhaps because there aren’t many prominent female philosophers? Ask anyone to name several major philosophers. Almost all of the mentioned names will be males, if not all. Rarely do you hear of female philosophers. At least I haven’t heard of many. So, perhaps, since philosophers see themselves as thinkers, and there is a lack of female philosophers, they feel that women can not critically think and are therefore inferior, awful, etc.</p>

<p>But, that’s only speculation/theory. And just to clarify so that I don’t receive flak, I believe women should be treated equally. =P</p>

<p>Yes, that’s what I said too–that people in male-dominated fields tend to be more misogynistic. Don’t worry, no one will take it badly. It’s true that in the past there were almost no female philosophers, but it was simply because back then there were institutional barriers to women getting an education at all, let alone being taken seriously as thinkers. For all we know, there were women who wrote their philosophical musings down, but no one thought to read or preserve them because they didn’t consider a woman’s thoughts valuable. So when you think of the greatest classical philosophers from a long time ago, obviously they’d mostly be men. All the most famous examples of female philosophers, like Mary Wollstonecraft or Ayn Rand, were more recent.</p>

<p>And then there’s cultural barriers-- even after it’s technically allowed for women to be philosophers, if it’s not considered culturally “normal,” less women will be drawn to it, so it takes a while for the numbers to build up. That’s what we’re seeing with politics-- a very, very slow growth in the number of female politicians, just as there’s been a slow but steady growth in the number of female philosophers. You know… for some reason, the Tea Party seems to be contributing more to that than any other party lately… this is creating some cognitive dissonance, because I don’t like them and don’t want to admit that they do anything right :P</p>

<p>Hypatia is an example of an ancient female philosopher–not sure why she was seemingly overlooked. I guess her name got entangled in too many religious discussions.</p>

<p>Good points above. What I’m really wondering is this: was the level of misogyny as intense (and consistent) among people of other male-dominated professions? (aka the majority of professions back in the pre-20th century). Everyone believed in gender roles, of course, but I don’t necessarily think that gender roles should be equated with misogyny (one can love both genders even if one believes that they cannot have the same freedoms, even if one’s logic is flawed in the process). And I think many females were okay with traditional gender roles until the development of feminism.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Hahaha yeah - it seems that they’re even promoting negative stereotypes of women in general.</p>

<p>The Schlafly Phenomenon</p>

<p>^just looked her up - i really don’t think most “traditional gender role”-believing women are as extreme as that.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Does Abelard count?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It’s a sinister ploy to get females to vote for them by using female pawns as candidates.</p>

<p>Does that help restore coherence?</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I don’t think anyone considers him a major philosopher. </p>

<p>edit: wow i just looked the name up and he has an entry in stanford encyclopedia of philosophy.</p>

<p>He was extremely influential in the Middle Ages</p>

<p>idk if you’d count that as marriage though. Rousseau almost got married, and, if you buy him as a major philosopher, Sir Thomas More was married</p>

<p>that said, the point that philosophers tend to be cooky holds, although there is also the fact that many philosophers - Boethius, Averro</p>

<p>Oh okay I see. Has he even written anything that people read?</p>

<p>Interesting examples you brought up (and good point about the religious duties). It’s possible that the breakup stress (and lack of a second significant other) might have motivated what they wrote as philosophers. The point being, that they were probably alone most of their life.</p>

<p>According to Wikipedia, Logica ingredientibus is his most important work, though his autobiography is the only work that is readily available in English</p>