Why No Vacation Invitation Responses?

<p>Reflectivemom, I think one of the issues is who people consider close. A beach invitation should not come between those who are close as they should be able to hash it out. What has really changed for our generation is social relationships. Many are too busy to develop genuine ones.</p>

<p>Orange, I’m sorry your son had such a tough year. I’m sure you’re anxious to see him with healthy friendships. Are you suspecting the situation now may be due to lack of foundation to these friendships? Social therapy groups for HS and college kids are springing up everywhere lately as many kids are having issues connecting. As a family MD, I’m getting more and more requests to refer.</p>

<p>kluge - I guess I really don’t understand your attitude that this inconsiderate behavior is typical. These are college students we are talking about - not middle school boys. I find it sad that you believe what is being described in “age appropriate”. Neither my son nor his friends, still in high school, would act this way. They would be much more “upfront and honest” in their dealings with the OP’s son. And, btw, I’ve found that the most responsible kids are generally those from large families - not “only” children - they are responsible because they have had to be. </p>

<p>If this has become “age appropriate”, and I don’t believe it is, it is because the parents have allowed/tolerated such. Remember the OP stated that she has also communicated with the parents and they haven’t been much better. Perhaps instead of being an issue of “age appropriate” it is more an issue of “The apple doesn’t fall far from the tree.”</p>

<p>BTW, I’m not criticizing them for being unable to accept/decline or even commit - but radio silence? That’s inappropriate. They could at least keep the OP and son apprised of their status.</p>

<p>I think I must have initially missed that these are college age kids we’re talking about here. This, in my opinion, is a different situation than if it were high school kids. I can better understand the reluctance of kids this age wanting to go away on a vacation with a friend’s entire family. Most college kids would probably prefer to go away as a group of friends with no adults. As I said before, we’ve taken various and assorted friends along on many trips over the years but the only ones to come along once my kids reached college age were significant others. Trips with a group of friends for a long weekend, etc. prior to returning to college in the fall always fell into the category of a ‘kids only’ venture, often with siblings included but not parents.</p>

<p>edited to add: this is no excuse for the rudeness of not replying, but it may explain some of the reluctance.</p>

<p>Kluge (and Reflectivemom) -</p>

<p>Thanks for your perspective. I tend to agree with reflectivemom. I could never accept that this behavior is age appropriate. It may be more typical now than in my generation, but I would never call it age appropriate. I believe that many parents today are raising very self-centered, opportunistic, inconsiderate young folks. And, the little applets don’t fall far from the old parental tree. My son has always been schooled in the notion that everyone at all times deserves consideration and respect. It is not that he is, let’s say, an only…instead, it’s because he was well-raised (note the pat on the back :stuck_out_tongue: ).</p>

<p>I view this from a very unique perspective. This past year, my son brought home from school someone who on the surface appeared to be a very nice, well-educated, substantial young woman. They had a serious relationship going and both were seriously talking longterm and promise ring and acted very seriously and nurturing toward each other. Girl then goes off on January term course trip…cheats on son with a stranger…then hooks up with another college mate on the trip for new relationship. DS gave her a diamond necklace at Christmas, met her at the airport coming back from the trip with a dozen roses, then she dumped him…and she expected him to get over it pronto and make out/go out with her best friend. They wondered what was wrong with HIM when he couldn’t/wouldn’t do that. No, Kluge, I think the problem lies in the upbringing. Yeah, there may be some variation among kids, but upbringing does matter.</p>

<p>Also, another example…son was heavily recruited to rush a frat (top on campus) and he accepted the bid. Son is a disability student, one of whose disabilities is processing speed, which makes it very difficult to get large numbers of tasks done quickly. As he started to get a bit behind in his pledge tasks, I encouraged him to talk with pledge trainer and frat president about the matter. I even had the occasion to speak with the frat president about the situation (during phone calls on the financial end of things). President assured us both that the matter would be worked out and handled in a responsible manner. The responsible manner they chose was to dump DS 3 days before initiation…thus crushing him, causing him to miss the housing lottery, not to mention violating federal law, etc. Now, he has a choice of being in a dorm room on the frat floor in the dorm, or getting the bottom of the barrel in room and roommate selection. Administration is trying to help, but at this point there’s only so much they can do. And, the guys he was formerly friends with now avoid him like the plague because they themselves would risk social censure if they continued their relationship with them. Oh, and may I add, that one of the boys in DS’s pledge class, who commited a destruction of property felony during the pledge period was only deferred out a semester and was forgiven his transgression because, as the president put it, “boys do make mistakes.” Oh, now, let me get this straight…we forgive felonies but not disabilities…unbelievable!</p>

<p>Bottomline is that I feel that much social propriety is out the window in this generation and it feeds directly from the self-serving parents who raised them.</p>

<p>Hi, AlwaysAMom -</p>

<p>To fine tune the college age kids reluctance to travel with a family thing.</p>

<p>All of the kids invited are all SUPER close with their families and travel with them all the time. The kids my son invited, while they enjoy their independence, truly value family. That makes it even stranger.</p>

<p>Thanks :)</p>

<p>Hi, UCGradMary!</p>

<p>DS is very willing to connect with peers, and he knows what a good relationship is…however, it seems that so many young people out there lack the “attachment” gene…that is, everything done for social convenience and very little depth of character. Many of these kids seem so shallow to me…all about appearances and self-satisfaction…no meaningful relationships even among those who claim to be bf/gf or bff. I pity this generation and the detached, emotionally deprived kids they will raise.</p>

<p>Thanks! :)</p>

<p>Sorry, Orange, I didn’t mean to imply that these kids didn’t value family. :slight_smile: My kids, and many of their friends we’ve travelled with over the years, also value family, and we are a very close family in every possible way. Having said that, I can’t imagine that my girls once they reached college age would have much desire to travel with the family of any their friends, with the exception of their boyfriends’ families, and they’ve done that. They certainly do with us, and as I said, boyfriends always come along, but not just ‘friends’. I’m not saying it’s ‘right’, or that I know for sure, just that it may be an issue. Who knows. I hope you can get this sorted out though, so that you can all have a great trip. For me, the anticipation of a fun trip is almost as good as the trip itself! :)</p>

<p>OB, After all this, I would just have S call them up and say “Are you going or not? We need an answer to plan our trip”. </p>

<p>Were these guys S’s high sch. friends? Sometimes things change after a year at college. My S grew up being great friends with a boy 2 houses down from us. They now attend the same college but rarely get together anymore. They’ve just grown apart.</p>

<p>Orange, wow, this HAS been a tough year for your son! The world must look like a mean place to your family right now. However there are great kids out there, great loyal friends and girlfriends are out there!</p>

<p>Sometimes disabilities that did not effect life much in HS have more implications in college. Does your son perhaps need some professional social support? </p>

<p>With all due respect, you my dear Orange need to step back from being social director and let him find his way with appropriate support. Talking to the frat president about any matter was a no-no as was IMing his friend. Let your son figure out if a friend is coming and relax.</p>

<p>Reflectivemom and OrangeBlossom: I would not expect middle school or high school students to respond in this manner to the invitation. I would expect college students to respond this way, however, because that’s the way college-aged people tend to act. Does that clarify what I meant by “age-appropriate”? Like it or not, “appropriate” or not, you’re not likely to get a bunch of 19 year olds to commit to going on a vacation with a friend’s family weeks in the future. Several people have posted to confirm this as a matter of actual experience. On the other hand, while several have written about how they feel students “should” behave, I’m not seeing anyone jump in and say “When I did that, all the students responded promptly and didn’t back out at the last minute.” OrangeBlossom, your expectations were probably unrealistic, and your anger is based on a response which was predictable if you had understood how people the age you were dealing with usually respond. That’s all I’m saying here.</p>

<p>Hi, UCGradMary -</p>

<p>Thanks for your continued responses…</p>

<p>Re Para. 1 - Yes, we know there are better relationships and people out there, but thanks for reaffirming that. :)</p>

<p>Re Para. 2 - DS has had outside support doled out at the appropriate level on a continuing basis since middle school…mainly to keep tabs on how he’s doing emotionally due to his disabilities and to help him find his way along life’s road.</p>

<p>Re Para. 3 - Point well-taken. Contact with frat prez was made at the direction of an official…not my idea. Also, other posters suggested parental contact with invitee & family to authenticate the invitation and to provide requested info. I’m a pushover for suggestions. I have take a very hands-off approach to his emerging adult life, and have been the biggest proponent of his testing the waters on his own.</p>

<p>Thanks for your help.</p>

<p>Kluge -</p>

<p>Thanks for your followup. FYI, one of the reasons we extended the offer(s) early was to be polite to the invitees and their families…to give them time to figure out their own schedules and see if the invitation would work into their summer plans. I generally don’t like to extend last minute offers for the more major events because I feel it is rude.</p>

<p>Also, please do not mistake my disappointment and confusion with anger…for it is not.</p>

<p>Also, before DS went to college, other invitations were handled in a much better manner with kids and families locally. So expectations were built on that baseline.</p>

<p>My very elderly mom often says she much prefers the gentility of her generation to the more rough-and-tumble of mine. I can only guess what she would have to say about the newest brood.</p>

<p>Thanks, again.</p>

<p>Perhaps they are trying to be respectful of you, but they just don’t know how to say ‘no’ without hurting the feelings of you or your son? Perhaps they are fearful that if they were to say no, they would rather do something else, you will interpret this a slight towards you, your son, and your vacation plans.</p>

<p>Personally, these kind of ritzy freebies are quite terrifying to me, but I would find it almost impossible to tell someone who offered them to me that. Cowardly and ungrateful as it seems, I would find it much easier to wait it out in the hope that at some point they would say “no, sorry, too late” and I would be able to say “oh, I would have loved to come, but don’t worry, my loss” than have to say something up front that I felt might hurt that person, however much I didn’t mean that hurt.</p>

<p>I would plan for it just being your family, but if you really must get a definitive answer, you or your son probably needs to speak to them again and make it clear that you won’t be offended if the answer is ‘no’, that you understand that summer is a busy time for people and perhaps they would like to spend the time with their own families. The more you try to harrass an answer from them, the less likely they are to want to go on a vacation with you, and the harder you make it for them to be honest with you without being afraid of your reaction.</p>

<p>Hi, Tli83 -</p>

<p>I appreciate your take…and I believe that you’ve hit on it. Our family is by NO means well off; we are simply very generous in nature (even at times when we should not be because of our financial situation). I can see that letting it slide is much easier than saying, “No.” While we would be disappointed if the answer were, “No,” our family is much more saddened by no response at all. An answer of any type shows more consideration and reaffirms the fact that DS is valued as a friend.</p>

<p>In brief, your answer seems the most logical to me.</p>

<p>Thank you so much for posting.</p>

<p>Kluge, As I posted, I have no problem with a kid not wanting to go on vacation with a family. Also, no problem with them not willing to commit. However, I don’t believe it’s “age apppropriate” to not respond - it’s rude. </p>

<p>College kids wouldn’t “tend to act” that way if parents and friends didn’t tolerate it. All it would take is plans canceled, invitations withdrawn, meals prepared and served only for those who showed up at at the defined time.</p>

<p>Sadly, it’s not just college kids - it’s mother’s of young children who don’t bother to RSVP for birthday parties, wedding guests who don’t send in a “pre-printed” RSVP card - but show up at the reception expecting to be seated, etc. </p>

<p>There’s a difference between “drop in/stop by” functions and those that require a bit of notice. The kids know the difference. They have no problem with advance planning for things they value - you only have to read a few facebook messages to see this.</p>

<p>Orange…I too thought your son was much younger. I’ve taken extra boys on many trips–to the beach, on ski trips, overseas even. However, trips with friends stopped at age 16. We did not want to take responsibility for misbehavior (drinking etc) and our boys did not want to contemplate the potential conflict of interests (our need for responsibility vs their friend’s need for excitement).</p>

<p>Last year my son wanted to rent a house for ten of his closest friends. He was having difficulty–as he was only 18. He initially asked us and we said we would rent it–but we would have to stay in the house with them. He found another brand new cottage which the owner happily rented to him. (Crazy person I guess). On the upside, it was quite a stressful holiday for him as he was worried about the house all the time, haha. Welcome to our world.</p>

<p>Your son’s friends should have spelled out their discomfort–and maybe they have tried to do that but he hasn’t quite picked up on it? Is it possible that an only child might not pick up on some of these social subtleties?</p>

<p>If it’s any help, we still enjoy our beach trips with our sons sans friends. They are quite happy to chill with their books in and among a few snorkles and a few nice meals.</p>

<p>I finally figured out why I couldn’t relate to this.
When my D was off at college, and finally came home for a family trip, I didn’t even * think* of inviting one of her friends to tag along, because I wanted her to myself!
She had gotten to live * all year* with her friends, & I wanted to get a chance to see her :slight_smile: Im not sharing </p>

<p>Another thought- since this young man reportedly has had a rough year, what with the starting college and frat difficulties, maybe he didn’t want to invite anyone- and wanted a break.</p>

<p>I feel like I am a pretty easy going parent compared to what I could be, particulary with kids with learning issues. I have learned to “pick my battles” and " don’t sweat the small stuff".</p>

<p>I sense more than being annoyed over this not working out the way the parents anticipated.
Bringing a friend or not, after the request is made ( Did S ask to bring someone, or was he told that he could/should bring someone along?), is something that should be “owned” by the person making the request. </p>

<p>Yes, it is annoying when people don’t reply. but why get bent out of shape about it? There are so many other things to get worked up about, that it seems to be taking the place of a backstory that we don’t have the details of.</p>

<p>I forgot about his head on collision and his earlier jaw surgery, maybe the poor kid just wants to regroup and recover for a while- I wouldn’t blame him</p>

<p>Hi, Cheers!</p>

<p>Don’t think we would face the problems with “kids” wanting to drink, cavort, and generally push the limits…all the guys are pretty nice, laid-back people.</p>

<p>Don’t think there was any discomfort on the part of his friends, just confusion.</p>

<p>Re your kiddo’s renting a place for the group and getting a taste of adult dilemmas…It’s so amazing when you try to explain to them that these isolated incidents aren’t so isolated when you’re an adult…they fly at you like tennis balls pitched by serve machines. Thank heaven they so want the adrenaline rush and the challenge, else all these “little” details to manage would really frighten them.</p>

<p>I think that DS is at peace with a family (and dogs) only trip. He loves the water and the beach and is a very serene guy. After all the months away at school, we do look forward to having him all to ourselves, but I am trying to be loose and let him have his lead and feel adult-like and independent if he so chooses.</p>

<p>:)</p>

<p>

This absolutely would work. Seriously: problem solved. You would not have to worry about any college students showing up to upset your carefully laid plans once the word got out. They have other opportunities; they’ll take them. You will remain undisturbed.
*
Why am I flashing back on every conversation I ever had with a childless adult who couldn’t understand why parents failed to “control” their unruly toddlers, and with parents of young kids who sneered at the obviously incompetent parents of teenagers? The answer is so obvious: make them behave! Failure to do so is conclusive evidence of poor parenting.*</p>

<p>All you can do is smile and shake your head.</p>

<p>OrangeBlossom: Sounds good. I’m thinking tour son could use a little R&R from the last year! Sometime regrouping with family is what they need.</p>

<p>Emerald, it’s been a long time :)</p>

<p>I think that my cultural background fuels the celebration of life’s milestones and events. I can see where that might cause over emotional involvement, but I do try to monitor that.</p>

<p>Son started the summer quite stressed and angry…my guess is the acting out of all of the emotional and academic ups and downs of the year gone by. Now, he’s in a really great job that he loves so much that he’s thinking of scrapping his original educational plans in favor of it. He loves the people he works with. Also too, he is beginning to settle into a pleasant and regular social life at home. I think there’s still residual stress in him because he keeps really crazy hours/sleep disturbances (which works just fine with his job, but which would prove problematic in the fall because he has all early classes). Additional pleasant time just being should remove that.</p>

<p>Thanks for remembering my son’s terrible auto accident 1.5 years ago. However, in all fairness, the jaw surgery was experienced by Carolyn’s daughter.</p>

<p>Appreciate your thoughtful comments. :p</p>