Would You Support a Second Prohibition?

<p>Hello everyone on College Confidential. Let’s say there the 28th amendment has been ratified by Congress and it states that the 21st amendment (Isn’t it ironic that this amendment that ended Prohibition is the same number that’s the legal drinking age in the United States?) which repealed the 18th amendment is now repealed. Would you support a Second Prohibition? Why or why not? The US Government, however, added a provision to the amendment which allows drinking in religious contexts so that the 1st amendment would remain as the Founding Fathers desired it to be. If you want to, you can extend this further to abortion and gay rights.</p>

<p>Personally, I have this really peculiar behavior with controversial legislature. I would advocate neither cause because it doesn’t affect me directly, but I would support the Second Prohibition. Though I support the Second Prohibition, that does not mean that others should follow my beliefs and fix themselves to do what makes me secure. The United States based itself on a system where the “church does not interfere with the state,” so I believe that America should not do this because of alcoholics (who also provide nice revenue). I take this stance towards abortion and gay rights as well. In my heart I would be against it, but I believe that America should do what it promised and give these people the right to be someone or do something.
I follow Islam very rigorously and believe the story of Hazrat Lut (or the Prophet Lot), but that doesn’t mean that everyone else should. And if someone feels opposed by this, why don’t they leave to another religiously-inclined nation? I probably would leave the country and go to Pakistan or Iran or something, but that doesn’t mean that America should become a nation of religion.</p>

<p>Another thing: Many people against gay rights are still fighting over whether gays should be allowed in this country. I’m sorry but homosexuals have won the right to live in America and as a result should get their rights as PROMISED by America.
If I lived in a religious country, then I would have the right to go against this way of life, but I don’t.</p>

<p>It’s a controversial topic, but what do you think?
To any advocates for alcohol, advocates for abortion, advocates for gay rights, alcoholics, people who have used abortion (if there are any), and homosexuals: I am not against you in any way and I agree that all of you have the right to exist in America due to the Constitution. I am not hateful or spiteful to any group that may be offended by this post–I just wish to see the opinions of some people.</p>

<p>I wouldn’t support prohibition. I think the drinking age in the US is ridiculous as it is.
I do think you have an attitude towards belief that deserves to be admired though. It’s sometimes hard for people to accept that others will not necessary have the same values and that they don’t have to.
Personally I think people who don’t want to drink alcohol don’t have to drink it, and people who do should have the right to.</p>

<p>nooooooooooooo</p>

<p>thruyourfaketan: Thank you for the compliment. I brought this up at debate once and then some people called me a “terrorist” for doing so… oh well…</p>

<p>In a word, no. In fact, I think the age should be lowered to 18.</p>

<p>it didn’t work the first time. it’s not going to work the second time around. you can’t take away what some always had and suddenly make it illegal.</p>

<p>I would not support a second prohibition that is most likely doomed to fail.</p>

<p>Hello everyone on College Confidential. What are your stances on abortion and gay rights (since they are more controversial topics)?</p>

<p>uhh no, prohibition doesn’t work.</p>

<p>I’m pro-choice and very pro-gay rights =)</p>

<p>Hahaha, yes because we need a resurgence of speakeasies and mafia crime. Good job! </p>

<p>Btw- we’re in the middle of a second prohibition- it’s called the prohibition of weed. Alcohol is legal while weed is not. Stupid, stupid. Pot is fine- just legalize and tax it already you stupid politicians. </p>

<p>I am pro-gay rights (I am also not straight so it is very personal). It is ridiculous that in the year 2010, we STILL have to fight for people to have equal rights.
I am pro-choice. Women are gonna have em either way, might as well make them safe and legal!</p>

<p>…I was expecting more thought-provoking answers…
Anyone?..</p>

<p>I would not support a second prohibition because I’m tired of the government trying to assert its power over peoples’ lives in ways that it was never intended to do. We don’t need a nanny state to tell people what they can and cannot have. People need to be able to make their own choices.</p>

<p>Nope. Alcohol sucks, but prohibition has too many negative effects on economy and crime. For the same reason, I support legalization of marijuana.</p>

<p>I have a similar stance towards abortions - Morally I think they are wrong (except in extreme cases), however, banning them wouldn’t decrease the amount significantly and you would see a great increase in fatality rate for mothers. In no circumstance should abortion should be banned at all in instances of incest or rape etc., but I think their should be greater barriers against abortion, or really we need a much larger emphasis on birth prevention. </p>

<p>I’m pro-gay marriage as well. Really no reason they shouldn’t - if your only argument is the “sanctity” of marriage, then I really need to point out that 1) Most marriages aren’t really that sacrosanct, 1/2 of marriages end in divorce 2) government is not a theocracy 3) churches could still ban gay marriage.</p>

<p>–
If you can tell, I’m a pragmatist by nature and I really don’t care about the whole big government/small government debate.</p>

<p>

To which part of it are you referring? The part where he was alseep-ish, drunk, and sort of did things he shouldn’t? I think that’s most applicable, but the allusion still doesn’t make that much sense to me.
Oh, actually, I just went to Islamic view of Lot on Wikipedia, and I think you’re talking about his forbidding anal sex. Is that right? Didn’t know he was so different in the two religions. Muslims actually don’t believe in the story to which I was subtly referring! Crazy!</p>

<p>Anyway, no, I would not be cool with a prohibition. I don’t think that’s actually a very controversial topic.</p>

<p>I support gay rights and marriage equality. </p>

<p>I don’t think anyone is an “advocate for abortion,” but yes, I’m pro-choice. The most commonly stated reason for having an abortion is to be a better mother, presently or in the future, and 61% of women who have abortions already have at least one child ([Source](<a href=“http://www.guttmacher.org/media/nr/2008/01/07/index.html]Source[/url]”>Concern for Current and Future Children A Key Reason Women Have Abortions | Guttmacher Institute)</a>). So, women usually aren’t doing it selfishly. I think a lot of people have the wrong idea about that.
My views on abortion, are, I suppose, somewhat like Margaret Sanger’s, but without the eugenics :). That is, I long for a world "[where</a> children are wanted before they are conceived](<a href="http://thisibelieve.org/essay/16953/]where"&gt;http://thisibelieve.org/essay/16953/)," but I wish to pursue that world through supportive programs and education, not legal means.
I recently saw a bumper sticker that had a dove of peace carrying an olive branch and said “Pray for an end to abortion.” I thought it was great. Pray for it, hope for it (and hopefully pursue it actively and kindly), but offer an olive branch to those who make the incredibly difficult decision of whether to abort.
Conversely, the first time I drove past Planned Parenthood and saw posters with large images of fetuses, calling these women – who are at an emotional peak no one would envy – “murderers” and other vile names, I was horrified, even though I knew they would be there.</p>

<p>No to 2nd prohibition. </p>

<p>Pro-life.</p>

<p>Pro-gay rights, but it’s not really a forefront issue for me. I’m sort of a libertarian, so I don’t care who you like or who you choose to sleep with. Funny to see old fuddy duddy Republicans get all p!ssed about the subject though.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Not only is that an incredibly manipulated statistic, it’s also straight up not true. It bothers me that it’s so commonly believed.
It’s taken from the number of divorces each year and the number of marriages each year. No one keeps track of how many marriages end in divorce, overall, as far as I’ve seen. A recent WSJ article mentioned rates for certain age groups and ethnicities, all significantly lower than 50%. I’ll see if I can dig it up for you.</p>

<p>Not looking good on the digging it up front, but anyway, national statistics about what I’d call “life patterns” are incredibly inaccurate. They differ hugely based on income, ethnicity, age, location, etc. Find a specific statistic if you want to know your “chances” at staying married.</p>

<p>Ooh, found 43% of marriages end in divorce: <a href=“http://online.wsj.com/article/SB120595531417249409.html[/url]”>http://online.wsj.com/article/SB120595531417249409.html&lt;/a&gt;&lt;/p&gt;

<p>Ah-ha! Found it: <a href=“http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704107204575039150739864666.html[/url]”>http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052748704107204575039150739864666.html&lt;/a&gt;
Choice exerpts:

See how much they differ by age range and ethnicity? A stat that includes the whole nation is useless for pretty much everyone.</p>

<p>I would not support another prohibition. Both because it wouldn’t work, and because I think people have a right to drink if they want to. I would support stricter controls over people drinking outside their own homes… Because drunk driving kills people.</p>

<p>On gay rights, I’m divided in my mind. I definatly do not think it should be illegal to be gay. What adults choose to do in their own homes isn’t anyone else’s business.</p>

<p>Abortion is an entirely differen’t issue for me. I believe that baby is just as much a human being as you or I, and that therefore the choice to kill it should ONLY be made in situations where we would also kill a child that made it out of the womb.</p>

<p>^^</p>

<p>K, Millancad, I take that back. However, you have to admit, a lot of marriages aren’t really that great… It’s been violated in quite a few forms. However, not to the extent I believed, then.</p>

<p>^ I agree with that. If it’s the sanctity of marriage they’re worried about, they should arrange their own marriage system and follow it. There’s really no reason the government even needs to be involved in marriage, except for tax purposes.</p>