Yet another school comparison thread (engineering schools)

Hello! I have just finished my junior year in highschool and have been thinking about college a lot. This is a little bit about me.

Academics:
-GPA: 3.97/4.06 (unweighted/weighted)
-ACT: 28 currently, most recent practice test was a 31, goal is a 33
-Class Rank - 1/78
-I attend a public charter school called Utah Military Academy

Extra curricular activities
-Varsity captain of the school baseball team
-JROTC Vice Wing Commander
-NHS Vice President
-JROTC Academic team commander
-Over 80 service hours in high school
-attended SAME Engineering camp at USAFA
-invited to and attended 2 AIPAC (American Israel political action committee) meetings for the state of Utah
-accepted to (and will soon be leaving for) the innagural Air force Junior pilots program. It is a scholarship to earn my private pilots license this summer all expenses paid one of 6 flight schools. I was assigned Kansas State University.
-recied several JROTC awards including 2 National level awards.
-debate team for 1 year
-held several jobs during highschool (customer service and ski instructor)

General
-white male (hope this doesn’t matter)
-avid skier and mountain biker
-grew up as a military child and lived all over the world
-love to travel
-live in northern Utah

Will resume shortly

Do you have money to burn? Otherwise U of U, or USU. You will definitely want a higher ACT, do you have any APs?

It would not let me edit the thread so here is everything else I meant to add. Syballa, I have taken AP calculus AB, statistics, chemistry, and will be taking calxuo bc my senior year. Will also be taking English 1010 through snow college. And a higher ACT is priority #1. I have my next test this Saturday and have been studying vigorously for it.

The schools (in no particular order)
-Utah State University - solid aerospace program and internship opportunities, I like the campus and feel of the school.

  • Colorado school of mines - small school in an area I love. Have not visited yet. Not many aerospace opportunities but a good mechanical engineering program. Seems to be a quality school

-MIT- Have visited the campus and fell in love. Everything felt right. The campus, the feel, the vibe, the people. Everything was right. But I know my act is not even close to where it needs to be yet.

Stanford - have not visited yet, and not sure if I will like it once I do. Need a much higher ACT like I will for MIT

More than willing to consider other schools

Scholarship ideas
I would rather go to a lower end school for a much lower price than go to a school like MIT and finish in a ton of debt. I will likely not get much need based financial aid. I am currently very competitive for a full ride ROTC scholarship, but do not have aspirations for the military and would rather find other options to pay for school.

So I hope all of this made sense, and would love some input on why to choose one school or another with the program, the school, and the price/scholarship opportunities in mind

Talk to your parents about budget. Don’t waste any time or effort until you know the numbers.

Yes, talk to your parents about how much they will contribute, and run net price calculators.

The deal with my parents has always been that they will pay for 3/4 of my education. But due to the insane cost of mit and the sorts, they are not sure that they can afford to pay for that much. We have yet to run financial aid calculators for these schools but plan to tomorrow.

However, I would feel bad about asking them to pay to there absolute limit though and that’s why I would accept an ROTC scholarship if that’s what’s needed to afford a school like MIT.

I’m sorry the budget seems so vague but that’s all I got. I guess I’m more concerned about the schools and school X vs school Y and why choose one or another. If I decide I have to go to one school or another, I will find a way to pay for it :slight_smile:

Do run the financial calculators at the school’s you are interested in. You may be surprised. For instance, MIT may have a high sticker price it also provides students with a lot of need based aid. Many years ago, it cost my parents almost nothing to send me to MIT where it cost quite a bit for my siblings at much lesser schools. Of course you need to raise your test scores and even then MIT is a long shot for just about everyone.

The other financial thing to consider is a schools 4 year graduation rate. It can be quite poor at some state schools, that are less money per year, due to class availability. My daughter choose a more expensive private school, with some merit aid, over a state school for that reason.

Graduation rates are available in a school’s common data set.

Frankly until you come back with a 34 ATC, MIT and Stanford are just fantasies. You might look at schools that like teh ROTC stuff though. CSM will cost you over 40K a yr even with a 33 ACT, as that only gets you smoothing money for the mark up. Do you have an idea of your parents income? Do you have regents all lined up for the max money?

However, graduation rates tend to mostly track admission selectivity, as weaker students tend to be less likely to handle full course loads, and most likely to fail and need to repeat courses. Class non-availability is a commonly cited excuse, but it is probably exaggerated by students who do not want to tell their parents that they avoided the 8am classes at a cost of graduating late.

Students at the edge of affordability of the college may also be more prone to dropping out due to running out of money, or having to take lighter course loads and graduate late due to needing to work to earn money to pay for school.

A comparison of the college’s actual graduation rates versus those expected based on student academic and financial characteristics would be much more informative than raw graduation rate.

You could probaby get decent merit at RPI. Some of the big publics have great aerospace programs (Michigan and Purdue spring to mind immediately) but not much merit $ to be had there and certainly skiing would be a problem.

Are you considering the AF academy as well?

Ask your parents for a realistic $$ amount, not a general percentage. Sit down with them and look at net price calculators on different school sites so they are aware of what costs are.

If you want to broaden your search for more schools that might offer merit aid, start here with the list of schools with accredited engineering programs: http://main.abet.org/aps/Accreditedprogramsearch.aspx. You can narrow down by whatever is important to you - location, size, etc.

Aerospace engineering is limited - but mechanical can get you where you want, so keep an open mind.

Also to keep in mind with the graduation rate conversation - it can often be difficult to graduate with an engineering degree in 4 years. There are many requirements, and most need to be taken in sequential order. It’s not uncommon to need to take some courses over the summer or an extra semester or two to finish up, so keep that in mind.

To everyone, I am well aware that my act is not where it needs to be yet, but I still have several months to improve it so I would like to just compare schools for the moment assuming I was accepted to all of them

Momofsenior1, AF academy was my 1st choice for a long time, therefore my resume is built heavily on leadership and service which is great for the academy, but isn’t as helpful everywhere else. I went to visit the academy and spend a week in an engineering camp there. I left that camp with a great experience but confident USAFA was not for me.

What kind of benefits would I gain by attending MIT/Standford vs. CSM vs. Utah State? Where do the strengths of each lie relative to each other?

Consider your in-state public University.

MIT and Stanford are private schools that you will have a low chance of attending and affording. Go ahead and apply but put more effort into finding other schools as well.
So look for more affordable schools. CSM is very engineering focused and Utah State will have more non-engineering courses/

Are you applying for ROTC scholarship?

With your stats and activities, assuming you have solid PT, I think you are a great candidate for a 3 or 4 year Army ROTC.

My son went this route. He cast a wide net, because some schools were only affordable for us with the ROTC scholarship. Half the schools he applied to also kicked in R&B for ROTC scholarship winners.

ABET accreditation really levels out the playing field for the depth of study for Engineering. School name recognition is really not needed as much in Engineering field.

I don’t know how far you wish to travel, but Clarkson in NY and Ohio University are both great ROTC programs with solid Engineering. WPI is another school without big name, but with many hands on experiences, including study abroad.

Some schools are much more theory than hands on. You don’t need a top name. Focus on your method of learning, affordability, co-op, intern and research experience.

Longhaul, yes I am applying to Air Force ROTC. That is the fallback if I get accepted to a school such I like but can’t afford it. I’d rather not go that route, but I would be happy to serve if that’s what it takes :).

And thank you for the other school recommendations, I will look into those. A big reason I like the idea of some of the “big name” schools is if I decide to change my major to statistics something of the sort, I won’t have to transfer schools.

If you are thinking ME, don’t overlook the U. My son with the stats you are shooting for 3.98(UW)/33, almost chose to go to Utah from Oregon. The Spiral Curriculum is innovative. He got a great financial package. It’s one of the only places, maybe the only place, where you can ski in the amount of time it takes to golf, actually less. Because of the proximity, skiing doesn’t have to be an all day or all weekend long ordeal. At least, I’d take a tour.

As for Stanford and MIT, even if you improve your ACT to 36, it will still be a long shot. That’s saying NOTHING negative about you. They both simply get far, far too many fully qualified applicants for the slots they have. To make matters worse, Stanford gives significant weight to legacy candidates. MIT doesn’t though.

How much CAN you afford though? You need to run numbers before anything else. At least have an idea what your FAFSA EFC is. MIT and Stanford are irrelevant distractions. Do you have subject test results? Is your ACT really imbalanced? What are your AP scores? I don’t think you do have months to fix your ACT/SAT score (in relation to your spriations). You want to get your application rolling as soon as possible. Having a reality check now is a good idea. Craft your list accordingly.

@Kbat11700
“A big reason I like the idea of some of the “big name” schools is if I decide to change my major to statistics something of the sort, I won’t have to transfer schools”

There are many universities you may never have heard of if this is your concern. Just to name a few traditional STEM institutions consider Clarkson, RPI, Stevens Institute of Technology, WPI, VPI, Colorado School of Mines, Carnegie Mellon University, Case Western Reserve University, RIT, Rice, NJIT, Rowan and many more. Many of these schools have AF ROTC. If admitted to most of these schools you will find affiliated ROTC programs.

For WPI AF ROTC see https://www.wpi.edu/academics/departments/air-force-aerospace-studies. For the general WPI college program see https://www.wpi.edu/project-based-learning/wpi-plan. The average unweighted GPA for students entering this university is 3.86. They may not know this in UTAH as we have only one undergraduate from there. This actually works in your favor.

The following listing shows all Accrediting Board of Engineering Technology (ABET) programs in the US alphabetically. These are universities which offer ABET accredited BS degrees in Aerospace Engineering. See http://main.abet.org/aps/Accreditedprogramsearch.aspx.

Many of these universities offer the full range of engineering and science majors. New England skiing is OK in NH, VT, and Maine, but it is not Utah!

WPI '67

FWIW: http://www.espn.com/action/freeskiing/story/_/id/7186883/espn-freeskiing-picks-10-best-colleges-skiing

Your own flagship may indeed be hard to beat in this regard, as well as on price. Their aerospace emphasis track within MechE seems well-developed; you’d probably be at little if any disadvantage with this degree compared to an Aerospace degree, in terms of the academic content. CU Boulder might hit the sweet spot as far as having more of an aerospace department and still proximity to mountains/skiing, but that’s a fairly pricey OOS public. (Maybe a good bet if you decide to go ROTC… though if ROTC would then consume all of your ski time it could be an unhappy catch-22!)

The question to ask yourself is whether it’s important to you to be someplace where extensive aerospace-specific research is happening, with opportunities for undergrads - schools like Purdue, UA Huntsville, and Iowa State. (I believe Iowa State leans more toward aerodynamics and planes, whereas Huntsville and Purdue are more space-oriented, but I could be off base on that.) Based on your current stats, you’d be eligible for merit at Huntsville covering 67% tuition; that could go up to 100% tuition with a 30+ ACT and full tuition + housing at 34+. Iowa State would give you $8K/year off the ~$36K OOS COA, so not a bad deal.

On the other hand, if you can save enough money by staying in-state, it could give you the financial breathing room to pursue summer opportunities that will balance out what your school offers.

Also consider schools in the Western Undergraduate Exchange, where you’d pay 150% of in-state tuition instead of the OOS price. There are some good engineering schools there, including Colorado State and Montana State (on the good-skiing list). From this list, only Cal Poly Pomona (not SLO, which doesn’t offer the WUE discount) and New Mexico State offer Aero.