This is all up to you!
Do you prefer a large school or a smaller one?
Do you like big-time sports?
What is the difference in price?
What is your major? If it is something like engineering, is there direct admit to Engineering school at MSU? You do have that at CWRU.
If you need to switch “schools” within the University…e.g., into Business or into Engineering, can you do that easily? At Case you can.
How is housing? Case guarantees 2 years and there is a good chance for upper classman.
What is the MSU surrounding area like? With Case you have the University Circle around you, free RTA passes.
What is your major? How strong is each school?