Chance/ Match rural Kentucky student interested in environmental science/engineering/biology w/34 ACT, needs merit aid [4.0 GPA, <$30k]

If D27 is interested in Princeton, then she should apply RD.

Where are Princeton Students From?

Well D27 isn’t “slow” at English, reading, and science. She definitely has a chance. And the Princeton financial aid program is the same for both REA & RD admitted students.

1 Like

Thankfully, her dad has been doing this with her for months, going through each course sequence and option at the schools she has applied to. Since he is an engineer, he knows what will be required of her.

Your points are very valid; I know I could never be an engineer!

3 Likes

I’d take a crack. Dec 1 deadline. I can see in many ways being a fit.

1 Like

Someone else pointed out how env eng is more like civil engineering, and I just want to echo that. People who are passionate about saving the planet usually wind up working on the conservation side of the equation, not on the building/construction side, which much of env eng falls into.

Anyway, given your D has very high achievements, it seems getting in is not the issue but cost is. Personally, I would (and did actually) run NPC on the top 100 LAC and use the results as the first filter to toss out schools that are too expressive.

1 Like

Yes, that is why engineering is on the table, but she would be more into the eco-toxicology side, so her dad is advising her to go more of a chemical engineering route.

And yes, the cost is the issue. And hearing about some others with stats like hers shows me I really have NO idea what kind of merit will be out there until she applies. But with every application is another essay and another fee, so she isn’t looking to apply to 20+ if she can avoid it.

I don’t think we have mentioned this yet, but College Transitions has scraped merit data from the CDS and put it in one convenient database:

As always, there could be out of date or otherwise erroneous information, and this doesn’t cover topics like merit caps and so on. But as a sort of starting point to help narrow down a list, you can look for colleges where the average award subtracted from the OOS cost of attendance is relatively low, and the percentage getting merit is relatively high.

As we discussed before, further filtering for colleges with engineering is going to be tricky. But if it helps at all, there is a distinction between Environmental Science and Environmental Studies that might be of some use, and so you could try filtering for Environmental Science along with engineering. You may already be ahead of us since you specifically mentioned Environmental Science, but I thought I would note it anyway.

And just to give a random example of how this could all work together, Juniata is an LAC that does quite well in the basic merit analysis. $77,450 OOS COA, $40,048 average merit award, 22% getting merit. Not at all bad. No Greek life at Juniata. Also not near a major city, so that’s an issue. However, there are a lot of great outdoor recreation options in that part of PA, and it is actually on the train line from Pittsburgh to Philly via Harrisburg, so at least weekend trips are an interesting possibility.

OK, and then Juniata has strong sciences in general, and a very robust range of Environmental Science programs:

https://www.juniata.edu/academics/environmental-science-studies/?utm_source=wb-google&utm_medium=ads&utm_campaign=environmental-science

And actually, they have Environmental Engineering! I didn’t know that, and it isn’t ABET certified, but maybe well worth checking out.

I think at many schools you know exactly what her cost will be - but you need to be flexible to do so.

Chem E opens an entirely different list as it’s much more prosperous in #s.

When you have a budget, then you need to stick to it and throw out those that absolutely won’t hit. You can include some that might possibly hit - but you need to then be up front with your student.

Ga Tech can hit (tiny chance) but if it’s $50K a year or anything over $30K, you can’t go.

You should also remember, as cliche as it is, that careers are long. Want to end up in Seattle but start in Kentucky? No issue. My Alabama kid started in Utah (in a development rotational) and then did Phoenix, Irvine and Naples Florida before being placed in Irvine.

He had offers in the NE, MW, etc. because it’s where he applied for jobs. You’ll land where 1) you apply and 2) companies move - so you can start one place and move to another - if that organization has other locations.

But honestly, it’s not that hard to build a list based on budget - but you do have to make a decision - is engineering a real possibility. If so, then apply for that and change out. And check to see if you can change amongst engineering majors.

You also have to decide - what matters to you - cost, city, reproductive rights access - like SD School of Mines would be a home run in everything - and even major change - but then reproductive rights were brought up and you said no. But it’s city (cute one), nature in spades and hits cost full pay.

So you have to really decide what’s important - up front.

Honestly, it doesn’t sound like your student will end up an engineer but at the same time, we/I don’t know your student - just based on the description you provide.

So now I’m on to ChemE - which is different than EnvE - which may be like civil but may not - different schools have different focuses.

Now I’m taking out don’t want to be in the South, etc. but who will assuredly hit $30K - this is based on the most recent which is likely 2026/27 and some charge more for engineering. You’d need to check. I’m only through the letter L and here’s some guidance - so it’s not true that you can’t know who will hit $30K.

I would also note that first year costs can be over or understated. Rent in Atlanta may be more than what Georgia Tech says. I suffered this in Charleston, SC. The school was $14K room and board but off campus was more than that, just for rent. Meanwhile, my kid in Tuscaloosa - his off campus costs were lower than the schools room and board. So more rural places, you likely see a save but in city, maybe an increase.

I’ll look at M plus later (I Know Miss State, SD School of Mines, UNM are for sure) but there will be more either likely are assuredly (as the three just mentioned) to be under $30K. If you want a school outside of Kentucky and it must be under $30K, it’s not going to be an issue if you are flexible.

  • UAH - $19-22Kish - depends on how they see your GPA; big savings due to automerit

  • Alabama - $22K ish - big savings due to auto merit

  • Arkansas - if you get the largest scholarship. It’s a maybe - but it’s city and nature

  • FSU / Florida A&M - FSU is a yes but only if you get an out of state waiver. Very possible with your stats. Florida A&M is a yes but it’s an HBCU. Note - they are put together because engineering is shared - a mile or two from each. For that reason, I wouldn’t want to go (buses)

  • South Florida is $34K with merit of at least $5K, likely more. So it’s a yes, under 30K

  • Idaho is a maybe - as costs are $43K with merit of up to $16K

  • Iowa State is $42K - 4.0+ (likely weighted) is $12K off - so maybe/likely

  • Kansas State is $44.6K and you get an OOS waiver ($19K off). Great reputation on the CC.

  • U Kansas is $46K and you get $16K off so right at $30K.

  • U Kentucky and U Louisville - and I assume you are applying to both. Both also have some enrichment programs for service and more.

  • U Louisiana Lafayette shows costs at $10K or so - lots of merit. I thought it’d be higher but I knew it’d be under $30K.

  • Louisiana Tech - will be low 20s at the highest level

  • McNeese State - OOS tuition is $11k so will work even adding R&B

  • U Maine - has a flagship match but doesn’t say which states (they used to identify them). If KY is one, it’d be $29K-ish. But not sure - and without would be out of budget. You can call and ask.

  • W Michigan U - $36K and it says $20K total over four years. I’ve emailed to ask -I like when they say per year. It’s in a city, there is nature nearby - so it’ll be close but I might find out it will easily beat. I called but got a voicemail.

  • UMN Duluth - $34,090 - they don’t list merit amounts but I called and was like - I’m trying to see if will go under $30K. And she said Best of Class (what you would get is $8K). So winner winner - why, very nice city and lots of nature nearby. Even if you get the next scholarship under, it’ll still be under $30K.

  • Miss State - really nice campus and nature abounds (not a city though) - mid 20s

  • Ole Miss - cute town - mid 20s - nature not as accessible as MSU - hard to tell but looks like mid 20s. These guys (Ole Miss and Miss State) have to compete with the Bama schools as they don’t have a large in state population so they have to get aggressive. Miss State is less partyish and more STEM

  • Missouri Science & Tech - rural so likely doesn’t work. Missouri has some lakes. St. Louis is the closest big city but not close. It could hit $30K - or be slight above. If you loved it, worth a flyer but not assured.

  • U Nebraska - is $46K and you’ll get at least $15K but i’m guessing more - could be up to $23K merit. Apply by Nov 1 thought - probably an easy app. They have their own if you don’t want to waste a common slot. In mid size/smaller city. Not going to be very geographically diverse. Likely local and surrounding states and some Chicago.

  • NM Tech - small school, great outcomes South of Albuquerque - but their expertise likely doesn’t fit. My guess is you’ll qualify for the competitive OOS scholarship which brings you $21K. But if you only get the Presidential, it’s above $30K. But at UNM, you’d get OOS tuition wiaved so I’d assume here too.

  • UNM - has everything you want - and would be well under budget - $23K or so worst case (this year)

  • New Mexico State - mid 20s

  • U North Dakota - $28-30K after merit -in the city (Grand Forks)

  • Akron - $35.5K - just says merit, not how much but guessing will hit

  • Toledo - says $32K with merit. Put your stats in the NPC and says $27K.

  • Youngstown State - just a few hundred OOS tuition - $25K

  • SD School of Mines & Technology - under $30K full price. Cool town, nature in spades - people mentioned healthcare access things - so that’s a personal call. Likely $$ to get to. Beautiful area for sure.

  • UT Chatt - $28K ish with merit - nature in spades, great tourist city. Very well beloved by locals here in TN

  • Tenn Tech - small town Cookeville - waterfall hikes nearby - also $28K-ish with merit. Majors outside of tech

  • Lamar - $36K and $10K off - I don’t think it’s for her - oil everywhere in Beaumont but access to Houston (an hour away) - Houston is a neat city

  • Texas Tech - $38,200 with $9K off so under $30K. But they also say if you get a $1K or more scholarship, you could get in state tuition - so it could go much, muchlower. Lubbock is blah - but that’s just my opinion. You are closer to N New Mexico and nice nature.

  • WVU - $47.5K and $18K off. Morgantown is nice - and you’re but 75 minutes from Pittsburgh - and I’m guessing not too far from home - although I can’t place which part of the state. Well respected in engineering.

  • WIsconsin Stevens Point - the old Trail Blazers point guard and Olympian Terry Porter played there - don’t know anything else but it’s ABET for ChemE. Definitely in a more recreational part of the state, at least looking on the map. Hard to tell but the NPC says $29K with actual chem engineering classes getting a slight upcharge. Merit is $4K so should be under $30K.

  • U Wyoming $40K and $12K merit aid so under $30K.

If you need non-engineering schools, let me know - I can probably pull them from other lists - but I have some in mind like Salisbury in MD at $30K and College of Charleston (which is way over) - but I have a feeling your daughter like mine, if applying for Honors could get invited to interview weekend. If she could score a spot in the Charleston Fellows (a reach), not everyone in the same but we got paid $1250 a semester (so free tuition +) and then you’re $20K for room and board. It’s the South but a big touristy town and nature abounds. It could only work in that sense. There’s plenty more.

And one correction to #6 - I just looked at the Academic Common Market for majors. Turns out you’d go to LSU on the ACM for Environmental Engineering (but would need to stick with the major) - so you’d achieve under $30K.

My 3.95 34 act applied to about a dozen (ended up at UDel with merit), my 3.95 33 act applied to 20 (ended up at Clemson with merit although other schools came in cheaper). It’s hard when you are not full pay but aren’t eligible for FA.

2 Likes

Did you run NPC at all for those two students before applying and if so, did the NPC estimates wind up being fairly close to actual offers they got or wildly off?

1 Like

I did not, my kids just applied to schools they researched, but I have 5 college graduates and some of the schools were repeats, and I was pretty good at guessing towards the end, most were east coast publics with no merit tables. Covid threw a wrench in for the last 2 (twins), no tours.

1 Like

Yes, but OP has a $30K budget - so neither UD or Clemson are realistic. Hence I’m going through Chem E state by state.

But it’s not right to say as OP did- And hearing about some others with stats like hers shows me I really have NO idea what kind of merit will be out there until she applies.

Because you know exactly who will hit or likely hit $30K.

What you don’t know is their “flexibility” into potentially choosing those schools.

1 Like

You are incredible!! THANK YOU!!

1 Like

Could running a bunch of NPCs on colleges give you a better sense of what each will cost for your current student/child?

@mkeakhs I finished the list. I just edited and extended the prior email above (#66) I hope another really smart person says $30K for ChemE again - so I don’t have to build another.

If you decide - no engineering - $30K - let me know.

And I put LSU as a for sure in Env Engineering - because they are in the Academic Common Market (which KY partakes in).

OK - I can’t edit it but on that major, you’d pay in - state cost - not sure about merit. $28,770 - honestly, it’s a great campus but not what your daughter is seeking city wise (obviously).

1 Like

Both the Gold and Provost scholarships would get her to 30,000 but they are super competitive and there aren’t very many of them. 40 Provost for out-of-state students that brings tuition down to in-state levels and 15 to 20 Gold scholarships (these can be in state or out of state) a year. Then 50 Stamps scholarships, which of course is a full ride. So roughly 100 out of state kids get these scholarships out of 4500 out of state admits.

Georgia Tech does not really give need based aid to OOS so absent one of those scholarships they will not hit their financial requirements I don’t think.

3 Likes

I don’t believe OP has need - just a budget. Thanks for the #s - I didn’t realize it was that many.

You should visit more often. You always have good nuggets!!

1 Like

With an income of over 200K in Kentucky, fin aid is unlikely. It sounds as if you are wisely avoiding schools that do not award merit money. Your daughter has done as well as she possibly could have done, and she looks even better, because she’s coming from a state that has low education achievement, overall. That will help. However, her math score is a relative weakness, and she hasn’t yet had calculus. That will hurt a little - it’s not that they know that she will hit the wall in math, but it’s a possibility, and when they compare her to someone who already has done well in Calc BC, she could come up short. If she applies early action, it might help if the counselor includes in the cover letter that she is running an A in Calc AB, which she is taking now.

Take a look at RPI, near Albany, NY. It has environmental engineering, they really want women, and they may offer her so much merit money that it brings the cost close to U Kentucky in state, especially if you appeal their initial offer - I know that they will negotiate. RPI is only a step below the top engineering schools in the country.

Drexel is in trouble, financially. I doubt that they’re able to offer her enough merit money to bring it down to 30k. Bears further investigation before wasting money and time on an application.

2 Likes

She doesn’t take Calc AB or Statistics until the spring, that is when they fit in her schedule. But I actually had this conversation last night with my husband. I am ready to see how she likes Calculus because the AP teacher at our school is notoriously hard, he is a Stanford graduate. So if that is a challenge with either content OR contentment, it will be a major clue. But doesn’t help us for EA!

2 Likes

Calc is only one semester ?

I take it that D27’s high school operates on a block schedule. Is it necessary for her to take both AP mathematics classes? She could take AP Statistics in the spring & hold off until college to take calculus.

1 Like