Or vice versa - Calc could give her an entry into what engineering might look like.
It could, but my 5 have all graduated from college, plus a masters and doctorate degree. You don’t know what you don’t know. ETA, we didn’t receive any FA even with 3 in college at the same time. Well, Villanova offered work study.
Correct, we are on a 4x4 block schedule. She actually added an extra dual credit college class to take 5 in the fall.
So, D27’s spring schedule is AP English, AP Calculus, Stats DE, Physics DE, & AP Psychology. I wouldn’t drop Physics 152. If D27 thinks she can handle it, then she should stick with her planned schedule.
Current (fall)-
AP Literature, Physics 151DC, Physics 152 DC, Engineering II, Biology 101 DC
Spring-
AP Psychology, AP 2D Art, AP Calc AB, Stats 220 DC
Thanks for the correction. I would have deferred Physics 152 to the spring & taken AP Calculus AB in the fall, but I do understand that scheduling conflicts do happen.
D27 should register for four full classes next spring.
Taking calc in the spring doesn’t help you for applications at all, since she will have to have submitted all her applications without having started Calc. Stats is easier, not usually a problem.
While her academic achievement is excellent, and her APs and ACT scores are very nice, she will be at a disadvantage compared to those who have already taken Calc AB or BC in 11th, or even to those who can show a first semester’s grade in Calc from 12th grade. Good as the score itself is, her weak spot is that math ACT score.
Is the calc teacher at her high school hard, but a good teacher, or is he just a bad teacher, in addition to being a tough grader? What really matters is can he teach Calc, because if he cannot, I wouldn’t want her to take it with him at all. I’d sooner have her take it over the summer at the local community or 4 yr college, if they have a section with a great teacher. If she has to take it with him, maybe you should identify a great calc tutor for her, ahead of time, just in case.
In a way, this is a tough choice to be making. She will have to take calc for pretty much any STEM major, but it’s really important for engineering, and you have no way of knowing whether or not she’s going to hit the math wall with calc until she takes it, hopefully with a very good teacher. The issue isn’t just EA, it’s whether or not she’s applying for engineering, and you and she won’t know how she hits the wall with Calc until after her applications are in. If she were to get a great merit offer at an engineering school like RPI, and then realize after she’s there that engineering doesn’t work for her, she might wind up deciding to transfer, whereas if she is at a large university with other schools too, and lots of majors, she could probably just change her major but stay at the same large university. She might want to consider private liberal arts colleges that have a school of engineering with environmental engineering, but they’re not likely to offer enough merit money to get to 30K cost of attendance. At engineering schools that are generous with merit money, she could get a very decent merit award, because they really want to increase the number of women attending. That’s why I mentioned RPI.
Lucky for her, she has an excellent Calc tutor in her dad. He is fantastic. He is a mechanical engineer working in a chemical plant in our town.
Her schedule was pretty locked in because of certain classes only being offered in the fall, spring, etc. She would have loved more foreign language but it isn’t offered and she just didn’t have the room for it in the end. Our high school really pushes “career readiness” with End of Program assessments in areas like food certification or welding. So they require elective pathways as underclassmen and that can hurt someone wanting to take advanced classes for college. She took AP Chemistry as a sophomore and was one of only a few allowed to do that.
I will say, she chose to take the harder classes because she loves to learn. She wasn’t really thinking of college applications as a sophomore. Maybe we should have been! But she is a deep thinker and wants to learn for the sake of having more knowledge.
I can’t stress enough her attitude is exactly right. It can be counterintuitive sometimes, but I think the kids trying to optimize for college applications often end up actually undermining their applications due to unintended consequences. And meanwhile, pretty much all colleges love mature, curious, self-motivated kids.
So very likely some (or all) of the colleges to which she applies will see her that way, and that will help her get some great options.
And then even more important than that, she can do it all again in college, and have a great experience and get great options for whatever comes next.
Of course around here we are happy to give frank answers to optimization questions if asked, and that’s fine. But I just wanted to take a step back and make it clear that those are the trees, not the forest. And the kid you are describing has a forest she can be proud to present.
There’s a great essay in here, about coming from Kentucky, from a public school, where the goal is getting kids ready for blue collar jobs right out of high school, while she is trying to get advanced classes in order to get into a selective school.
That sounds a bit stereotyped to me.
Just found this thanks to others talking about Beloit. If she decides against engineering, Beloit is guaranteeing $30k. Small city, not far from Chicago, that sound like it would fit all her needs.
Thank you so much for saying this! I definitely agree. It seems like a game that we are trying to “win,” so I have to take a step back and remind myself that she will bloom where she is planted because she does love education and is eager to meet new people and have new life experiences.
Have these engineering courses given the student enough of an idea how much engineering will be of interest?
And frankly, I have not exactly completely solved that riddle myself as a parent. Like I can’t help but want nice outcomes for my kids, and sometimes I have to remind myself that letting them control the process and make their own decisions is more important than me chiming in with “strategic” guidance.
But this community has been great for me in terms of hearing other perspectives and ultimately improving my self-restraint. So that’s nice!
Hard to say, as she adores the teacher, and she is the only girl in the class, and that is fun for her, ha! Also, we have a brand-new, state-of-the-art lab/facility, so that is enticing.
It seems to be more surface-level technology and project-making than a deep engineering curriculum.
I would not rule out very wealthy universities in your case. Your daughter is an attractive candidate because she is a) from a rural area and b) from an underrepresented state. And yes, it would be good if she could take that ACT exam again and boost the math score, but maybe a strong recommendation from her math teacher might compensate for that.
The reason that I might add some more expensive but wealthy schools is that the additional funding available on campus can often make up the difference. Like cushy campus jobs where you get paid for relatively low stress work; summer grants; RA positions. Not to mention the sibling effect
We are also part of the donut hole ($200K+ combined income) and have financial aid, not merit, at an ivy. We got a package that covered 50%+ of the cost. But my kid has also hustled: $4000 in summer funding, $1500 for working 10 days of reunions each May (you can make more if you work commencement as well). She is not an RA this year but that position pays $21,000. Her friends who work as undergraduate TAs for intro stats and first year math get paid for weekly office hours but students seeking help are not always plentiful so they often just get to do their homework while sitting in an office. No one is getting rich making $18.50/hr but it’s not a bad gig–
When her younger brother entered school this past fall ( with financial aid at a LAC), our total expected contribution remained the same overall, so her financial aid this year covers tuition and board; we only have to cover the cost of her off campus apt. Which means that it is only costing us $15,000 or so for this year for her. If you average out the first 3 more expensive years with the cheap final year, it has worked out to less than a state school. She earned another $10,000 in summer grants. Also managed to land a $50/hr part time job via the alumni network (note: that one was not on campus)
In our case, we were also able to get a match for a financial aid offer from another T10, which made a giant difference. The two were $35,000 apart, so who knows how these formulas actually work–
Of course, these kinds of schools all have exceedingly low admit rates. And it is a ton of work to apply to so many schools. But if she has the stamina, then I would throw a few more super wealthy privates with engineering programs in the mix in addition to Princeton. Hopefully you will be in a position to compare offers this spring—
Good luck!!
Congrats to your student. My only concern with your story, if I was weighing what you said about my student, is that it requires a lot of luck, and a lot of “hope” for future years and additional funding - i.e. pay more today but hope it averages out over four years. That’s a lot of risk for someone to take on (like finding grants later and a $50 hour PT job).
Thank you for sharing this. I have realized she should apply to as many as she can see herself attending. So we have opened up some options and are hoping for a financial package that works for us.
Do you mind sharing the schools your daughter is at? You can DM me if you would rather not post it.