The student will be somewhere four years, day after day. There’s alum with many schools, from Va Tech to Alabama to UGA and more on Wall Street or in related jobs.
Sure some are on a feeder list but that doesn’t mean they’re the right place for your student.
I would not ED period - to a place that I wasn’t 100% sold on.
That’s a lot of risk for an unknown- the likelihood that they end up in the desired career is still little.