Colleges your child crossed off the list after visiting, schools that moved up on the list. Why? (NO REPLIES)

Northeastern- DOWN and off

My DS27 and I participated in a Northeastern “twilight tour” which was an evening tour that took advantage of the extended daylight hours in the summer and allowed us to maximize our Boston area college visit day. If you arrived early, you were provided with a $15 voucher for the student center food court. This admissions office is a well oiled machine- clear signs were placed everywhere and the admissions center was manned with friendly student volunteers.

First was the information session. This was one of the most engaging ones I’ve been to. There was an interactive trivia game about Northeastern where they asked questions about the school and you could answer on your phone. There are so many pathways at this school that they had to spend a lot of time to differentiate between them- you could spend all four years in Boston, you could spend your first year in Oakland, London, and now a New York City option before transitioning to Boston in year two, or you could spend your first semester in a non-London TBD European city before arriving in Boston for spring semester of your first year. It makes your head spin to keep track of it all. Also they hammer the point home that they love love love their early decision applicants so much so that there are several perks including priority in the housing lottery for sophomore year housing!

On to the tour. If you want to be in the city- this is a great campus. It is right in the heart of Boston yet it feels like an enclosed campus (way more so than BU). There are two subway lines one on either side of campus. There are a variety of architectural styles and the facilities we toured were impressive. I could easily see why Northeastern has become a popular choice.

Now to the downsides. Our tour guide admitted that he didn’t think that advising was so great and he really relied on older students to navigate his way through the school. This was a red flag for me because the school is large and there are a lot of opportunities to be had but I could see my son getting easily lost here. With students coming and going, transitioning from other campuses, studying abroad, leaving campus for co-ops, there is a lot of student “shuffling” going on and so the student cohort is always changing. Granted that may be appealing to some, but I don’t think it’s a good environment for my son. Finally, our tour guide said that if you have two co-ops you have to take classes in the summer or pursue a fifth year and that a fifth year is not uncommon for Northeastern students. I sort of checked out after hearing that.

We loved the location and the energy and for a go getter who knows what they want and wants it in an urban environment this would be a great choice- it just wasn’t a good fit for us.

21 Likes

Boston College- UP

Weekday afternoon Summer information session and tour with D27. Easy parking in garage.

Wow- what a gorgeous campus! Certainly one of the most beautiful campuses I’ve ever seen and my son was in agreement. Stately Gothic buildings and beautifully manicured landscape. We make our way to the admissions office and it was a really welcoming experience. Two students are posted outside the admissions office to welcome you, check you in, and have a little small talk. Then you walk inside and another student is there to greet you say hello find out a little bit about you, to which you are handed off to another student…. eventually you are personally ushered into the information session by a student and directed to seats as if you were at a theater. It was a nice start to the visit and it really made you feel appreciated for taking a look at the school.

The information session was good- the main speaker was engaging and there were four students on the panel. Afterwards attendees were broken up into groups for the tour. Our tour guide was pleasant and was adept at handling a lot of questions thrown at her. Many of the buildings were even more beautiful on the inside than on the outside, and one of the libraries was jaw droppingly gorgeous.

There is a lot to like about BC- quality academics, lots of academic offerings, as well as the general feeling of more school spirit than at other campuses we’ve been to (to be fair more of a sports culture than other colleges we are looking at). It is a self contained campus in a pleasant residential neighborhood yet the Boston subway stops right on the edge of campus with all of the city’s offerings available to you. (Be advised it can be a long ride depending on where you are going as the BC stop is the end of the line).

DS27 and I were less thrilled about the fact that 40% of freshman are housed at a satellite campus one mile away from the main campus requiring a 10-15 minute shuttle ride. While our tour guide tried to spin it as a positive having lived there, saying it helped her bond with her freshman classmates and it provided a mental break between personal college life and academic life, she admitted you needed to plan your day more because you don’t want to keep going back and forth to your dorm during the day, and at popular times like the last shuttle before the 9 am class it can fill up forcing you to wait for the next one.

It stays on the list for now but is not a front runner. I would like to mention that this is the first Jesuit school we have visited. We didn’t know what to expect, but after visiting (we’re observant Jewish) neither my son nor I felt it had an impact on whether he would apply or not. There is some Christian iconography on campus but it wasn’t a big deal. There is enough of a Jewish community on campus that the religious affiliation of BC was a non-issue for us.

26 Likes

Deleted, wrong thread

Washington DC Roundup….

American- UP
There were three students at the info session/tour and three tour guides and so it ended up being a private tour- what a difference it makes! We were able to spend more time at places important to my son and breeze through areas he was less interested in seeing. The fact that the tour guide had similar interests was the cherry on the sundae. The campus is beautiful and the landscaping makes it feel larger than it is. The school felt more “comfortable” and “cozy” than impressive and to my son it just felt right. Being in DC is a perk- although to me it felt like a slight hassle as you had to take the subway to an outlying station and then wait for a shuttle from the station to the campus. Our tour guide said it was no big deal and that she goes into the city all the time. Son will be applying, but we have to do more due diligence about the reputation and offerings of the business school.

Georgetown- DOWN and OFF

My son is interested in business and Georgetown offers International Business programs through both the business school and the School of Foreign Service. The School of Foreign Service had an info session which we attended. It was very boring and it was clear that the business school was a better fit for my son. Then we attended the main information session which was the largest attendance for anything we have been to- it felt like quite the shock after one on one time at American University. I couldn’t believe there were only two tour guides for the large amount of people present. The tour groups were HUGE to the point that you couldn’t hear anything and people were jostling to get to the front. It was 90° and we were in no mood to compete. We left the tour as there seemed to be little point in staying- we couldn’t hear anything, it was a reach school, and the whole experience was a turnoff. However M Street was nice and it looked like a great location to be in school.

George Washington University- DOWN

GW is right in the heart of DC. Our tour experience was good- the people were friendly, and the tour guide was super enthusiastic about the school. GW has a lot of academic offerings and it is a more immersive DC experience than American or Georgetown. However, there is very little campus, and my son is realizing he likes having a designated campus area even though he likes being in or near a city. GW reminded us of NYU in many ways- little green campus space, crossing public city streets to get from place to place, the college buildings sprinkled in between private city buildings. DS27 realized this type of college experience isn’t what he is looking for. We were also surprised to learn that GW has a satellite campus 3 miles away that houses about a third of the freshman (similar to the situation at Boston College) and even if you are on the main campus you still have to shuttle out there your first year since the mandatory freshman seminars are held there. Most likely my son will not be applying but I think for an urbanite it could be a great fit.

24 Likes

We made a trip to CA this summer with the intention of visiting 3-4 schools. Kiddo ended up removing two before we even made the trip because she decided she wants to go somewhere that offers an MAT 4+1 program or similar. But we still made the trip and visited Chapman and Redlands.

Chapman University was UP for her and down for me, primarily due to my concerns about if it’s a good fit for a trans student. But the tour was nice and the facilities were solid. They didn’t take us to a first year residence hall, which I found to be a bummer. I think kiddo was swayed by the impressive Dodge segment of the tour, as well as overall new-ness of the campus. She moved the school down a notch in her priority list after doing more research after coming home though, as I think the shine wore off and the culture fit seemed less of a match. The tour was a tad annoying, as they asked each kid their interests, but didn’t do much with that info, and even commented “okay good we won’t have to talk about dance very much, before taking us out of the way to visit the dance building and venue. But full credit for wearing microphones with small broadcast speakers!

University of Redlands was “meh” for her but initially UP for me while on site. I thought it was welcoming and homey, even though our intended faculty meeting got changed to a grad admissions person who clearly had no idea who we were or why we were there. Campus was quite large and spread out for the number of students they have. The esports room is cool. The Johnston Center concept is neat. But ultimately just didn’t ring the right bells. At the end of the day and with additional research she felt there wasn’t anything interesting enough to keep it on her list (said she would have a hard time knowing what to write on a “why is” essay).

14 Likes

UVM - UP. “I could see myself here”. Lots of students out and about, studying in groups, seemed friendly and happy. He didn’t mind the cold and snow.

University at Buffalo - UP. “I like it”. Honestly, I’m not sure what he really liked about it. He did like that he was able to get Indian food in the cafeteria. Students were friendly and were enthusiastic about the school. Not a lot of out-of-staters, very NYS. The freshman dorm complex was huge..maybe he liked that? (As an adult, UB was fine but probably moved a bit down…it just seemed really large and while the classrooms/lecture halls seemed nice, the buildings were not particularly inviting on the inside or out. I liked downtown Buffalo but while it is not far, it is not right off campus either. (Wings were good!))

Hobart and William Smith - UP. Beautiful campus on lake. Admissions office ran event that took kids out on the school’s research vessel with two warm and engaging Professors, who showed off some of the scientific equipment used in science labs. Students leading tours were friendly and down to earth and really seemed happy. Just really a fantastic day (weather was beautiful so that helped).

St. Lawrence - UP. He went into this with low expectations but came away favorably impressed. Tour guide was great, school grounds were beautiful. I think what probably sold it was the culture around outdoor activities (skiing, fishing - the tour guide’s friend had caught a muskie in the local river) and the science labs. The tour guide, who was a Poli Sci major, did a great job sharing about his friends’ involvement in summer biology and environmental research and the cool things they were doing with their professors.

Clarkson - UP. I’m slightly surprised he liked this one as much as he did, only because the school is so heavily focused on engineering while he is more focused on biology or biochemistry. But students were friendly, Professors at the admissions event were warm and engaging, and Clarkson has a pleasant campus. (The buildings are kind of plain and utilitarian but the campus does have a pleasant feel). Also, there is a very outdoorsy culture. I will say, for engineering students it would probably be an amazing school. They are a ton of SPEED teams that are open to all as well as maker spaces etc. This was the only school that didn’t show us the library - they just sort of pointed out where it was; they showed us ALL the shops for the SPEED teams, however.

17 Likes

UVM- SAME

Summer weekend visit with DS27. We have been visiting mostly very competitive colleges that are high targets/reaches and we have found it hard finding schools to round out his application list. UVM ticks a lot of boxes on paper and with an acceptance rate over 60% it seemed worthwhile to check it out. In addition, UVM is promoting campus visits by offering a $1000 year scholarship for four years for attending an official info session and going on a tour.

The campus is beautiful- I must preface this with saying the weather was picture perfect- 78° and sunny, not a cloud in the sky, and none of the humidity we have been dealing with at home. I kept having to tell myself and remind my son that for a large portion of the school year the campus is covered in snow and it can be brutally cold. As my son is a skier he doesn’t seem to mind, but it is important to keep in mind a winter visit is probably in order if this becomes a top choice.

Anyway, the campus is pleasing with a mix of old and modern. Premeds will probably love the level 1 trauma center hospital right on campus but I didn’t love how it overshadowed a lot of the area we toured. Our tour guide was funny- not in a corny way but I was genuinely laughing and having a good time. My son is interested in business and the business school building was nice on the inside and the undergrad program sounds decent, although we have concerns about not being closer to a larger metropolitan area for internships, guest speakers, etc. It was clear that one of the strengths of the school is environmental science/studies/policy and sustainability.

Burlington seems like a great place to spend four years. It’s close to a lot of outdoor recreation and for a town as small as it is there is a lot going on in terms of cultural events as well as a lot of restaurants and shops easily accessible to students. A highlight of the weekend was renting bicycles (it’s probably been over 10 years since I’ve been on a bike) and riding on an unbelievably beautiful bike path going along Lake Champlain and at one point the path traverses across the lake. We did see some homeless people downtown and it seems that you still need your street smarts even though you are in Vermont.

A lot of what I’ve read on Reddit and some other postings on this site talk about issues with housing at UVM- that there isn’t housing for juniors and seniors, that you have to work hard to get off campus housing, planning Sept/Oct your sophomore year for your junior year, and that the Burlington housing market is expensive. The admissions officer at the info session painted a rosy picture of housing saying “50% of upperclassmen move off campus”- which didn’t align with what I read nor did the tour guide seem to agree when questioned later about the housing situation. She did say moving off campus wasn’t a huge deal and you just have to be organized and prepared and most students enjoy living off campus.

We left thinking it looks like a nice place to spend four years. For a state school it’s got a smaller size, and unlike most state schools UVM has only 23% in state students. It also has a 20% Jewish population with a very active Hillel that runs programming out of a beautiful building. For now it is not a top choice but compliments the other schools on his list and perhaps we will revisit if he is considering it more seriously as we go through the process.

15 Likes

Middlebury - SAME/UP. My 27 went with a classmate for a tour while they were in the area visiting friends. It was a Saturday, so I think that impacted what buildings they could access. But he was still impressed by the campus and found his guide to be personable and relatable. Of note for him was the college’s strength in languages and its proximity to skiing and other activities he enjoys. It’d be a long shot application for him, which I think is what makes him reluctant to move it up his list, but I think he liked it more than he was expecting to, so we’ll see.

Colby - DOWN and off. This was my second formal tour of the college, since it was high on my 25’s list for a while, but it was my 27’s first. I think he was curious to check it out to try to understand what was so appealing to his older sibling. We ate at a local pub the night before our tour, and I pointed out that the place probably saw a lot of college kids on weekends. He didn’t believe me, so I encouraged him to ask our server, and she confirmed what I had said, but also added some unflattering descriptions of Colby students’ behavior at the bar (destructive to property, etc.). We’re not so naive to think there won’t be town vs gown tension, but I think my 27 was disappointed to hear how disrespectful some of the students our server had dealt with actually were. Small sample size, but that still stuck with my 27. It was unfortunate to hear because we know a number of lovely kids who really enjoyed their time there. It goes to show how a few bad apples can really have a big impact on the overall impression of a school.
Anyway, I do like how Colby does their info sessions - super short and minimalist. I appreciate that they do not make you sit through a presentation of info that can, and honestly should, be easily found on their website. They leave most of it to the tour guide, and if you have more specific questions, the AO is available when you get back to admissions after your tour. Campus itself is stunning. First year dorms are grouped together, the new arts center is beautiful, the athletics facility is pretty amazing, and new dorms for upperclassmen are set to open this fall - they look to be, well, pretty amazing too. There are a number of spots to dine on campus, and we did get to see one of the main dining halls. Our tour guide was also one of the most engaged and knowledgeable students I’ve ever come across on one of these tours. He did an excellent job showcasing the many opportunities he’s had at Colby, both in terms of fun and in terms of helping him meet his longer term professional goals. Internship access, the alumni network, good relationships with and support from/access to professors, and career support were a big part of the conversation. It would be an amazing place to spend four years, but for my kid, he just could not see himself on this campus or in this community.

Bates - UP. We arrived in time to try to grab lunch somewhere in downtown Lewiston, but the place my 27 had picked ended up being closed the day we were there. We did get to see some of downtown Lewiston. Yes, it definitely has some issues, but my 27 actually liked it better than Waterville, I think because it is bigger and seemed to have more happening downtown. So we went with my backup plan, which was to get a dining hall voucher from admissions. My 27 was a little curmudgeonly at lunch for some reason, but we managed to agree that the dining hall was nice and spacious, which is good, considering there is only one main dining hall. Food selection was limited due to it being summer hours, but it was fine. We got back to admissions just in time to begin our info session, which was led by an AO and a student engaged in a sort of back and forth interview. I’m always a fan of hearing directly from students, and the perspectives from both of them steered clear of the boilerplate stuff. They were both refreshingly honest and down-to-earth about the school and their experiences at Bates. Afterwards, we were split into two groups for a tour: parents in one, interested students in the other. My 27 really enjoyed this approach and his tour. The campus appealed to him a lot and he got a good, down-to-earth vibe from the guide. My tour guide was knowledgeable, honest, and engaging, but not to the point that he didn’t feel like a “normal” kid. In short, both guides were the kinds of kids that my 27 could see hanging out with or getting to know. Campus was more compact than I expected, especially when compared to Midd or Colby, but I think this kind of appeals to my 27 as it makes the place feel more intimate. The dorms and room we were able to view were really nice, although I imagine there is a range of different housing. What appealed to both my 27 and I was that while some buildings seemed only “ok” on the outside, they were modern and inviting spaces on the inside. He is not a huge fan of splashy campuses and he likes a place to feel inviting and authentic for him - warts and all. Another plus for him was the relatively easy access to Portland and good access to outdoor activities. It’ll be a reach for him as it is for everyone, but it strikes me as the kind of place in which he would thrive were he to be accepted.

26 Likes

Continuing on the summer tours in no particular order…

Connecticut College: DOWN. We kicked off the morning in an info session - surprise! You know, I think some of these would honestly be better if people asked questions, but no one ever does. That being said, this session focused a lot on the curriculum, pathways, and academic centers at Conn. I thought the integrated approach would be a great fit for my 27 and that in general it’s a good way for students to explore topics if they’re undecided and at the same time discover connections between topics that they never thought might have existed. There were two tour guides available, and they agreed to just split the room in half instead of having people pick. At first, I wasn’t sure we’d end up with the tour guide that would click for 27, but I was wrong. Our tour guide was great, and it didn’t hurt that the guide had grown up in our state (but no longer lives there), which automatically made her relatable for my 27. The campus at Conn is beautiful. I do wish we had been able to visit this one when students were on campus to get a sense of how much time students spend on that gorgeous green quad! We were able to see the newly renovated student center, which looked great, and visited a first year dorm, which was fine and had triples, although the co-ed bathrooms could be awkward for some. The main dining hall also looked nice. We asked questions about whether athletic teams dominate the social scene, to which our guide said not really. After the main tour, we elected to head over to the athletics facilities, which are across the road and sit above the river. The views are great there, but we both found the facilities a little underwhelming, All that being said, my 27 did not care for the location - right off 95 and too far from a real downtown, and while he really liked the campus and the academic approach, it moved down, but not off, his list.

Tufts: SAME? DOWN? We spent the night before our tour in walking distance of Davis Square. I lived there after college, so it was fun to show my 27 my old stomping ground and give him a sense of what the area around Tufts is like. He really wanted sushi, and we had a great meal at Sakura right in Davis if anyone else is visiting that area. Our info session was probably the largest of the ones we attended this summer. This was the only info session where the presenter addressed the use of AI in applications. For example, with regard to the “why Tufts” question, they are really looking for evidence that applicants have engaged deeply with Tufts and are paying attention to whether applicants may have used AI to provide a generic answer. They want students to point to specific things about the school or experiences in their engagement with Tufts that make it their choice.
There were four tour guides on offer that morning - we initially picked one of the athletes, but then my 27 switched when it was clear that there was a smaller group with another guide. We visited the library, the student center, talked about our guide’s favorite Tufts traditions, housing and dining (specifically whether it’s difficult to find off-campus housing for upperclassmen), and saw the outside of dorms and the arts center. Our guide said professors were accessible and that he never expected to major in his chosen field, but that the introductory class he took in that subject as a first year (it’s a humanities major) really surprised him and that was that. He’s really enjoying his classes. In an era when it feels like kids need to have their lives mapped out by the time they’re 18, I am always happy to hear when a student normalizes changing plans when you get to school or going in undecided. We have had tour guides who came in with a plan and stuck to it, and given that my 27 is undecided, he connects more with students who are similarly uncertain about their future and on campuses where that “lack of a plan” right from the get-go is normal. The main quad where Jumbo the elephant stands is lovely and the views of Boston from atop the library are also nice. We’ve been to other hilly or large campuses that require a lot of walking and even stairs, but I was not a fan of all the steps… My 27 liked the campus and the area around it well enough, but I’m not sure he will opt to apply. He needs to edit his list as it is, and in his case, Tufts is a high reach, and I’m not convinced that he liked it enough for it to make the cut.

16 Likes

Last up for the summer as school is about to start, with one more visit planned for the fall.

Babson: DOWN and off. We had lunch at a place in Wellesley - probably a locale that college kids only frequent on parents’ weekend. I had never been to Wellesley, and it certainly is a lovely Boston suburb, but I didn’t get the sense from the part we saw that there was much connection between the downtown area and the colleges. That being said, it may be different from the Wellesley campus, which we did not see. The info session was divided between an AO presentation and some insight from a student, who mostly discussed their experience with the Babson equivalent of a first-year seminar, which groups students together for the year to create a product and launch it from scratch using seed money from the college. If the business they start makes money, it is donated to an area non-profit; if it does not bring in a profit, the college takes the loss. It sounded challenging, a great way to learn to take risks in a relatively low-risk environment, and an opportunity to explore the many different options for concentrations within a business degree. I personally thought it was really cool. But my 27 was stuck on the idea that the AO had started the presentation with the pitch that Babson really has only one major and a host of concentrations (full disclosure - he knew going in that it’s a business school). I see this as an attempt to distinguish the school, but to me, it’s really that they confer one degree and have a host of majors or concentrations - but maybe this is just semantics. It didn’t matter when I tried to tease out this distinction to S27. With the info session done, we headed out on a tour with our two assigned guides. It’s a lovely and peaceful campus with good green spaces and well-kept facilities. Perhaps its most distinguishing feature is the massive rotating globe in the center of campus, apparently the second largest of its kind in the world. Our tour had a sit-down moment in one of the academic buildings during which our guides addressed the issue of campus safety. Now, we’re used to guides pointing out blue light systems, discussing shuttles or the equivalent of uber services (Colby and Bates both have something like this), or speaking in positive overall terms about how campus safety operates, but this totally threw us for a loop. Wellesley and the area in which Babson is situated is not exactly what I would call a rough town (there’s a country club right across the street), but our guides spoke about how well policed the campus is, that the response times were short, and that they had sniffer dogs as well. It was strange and confusing, and after our tour we spent a reasonable amount of time googling if there had been any recent safety-related issues to merit this part of the tour instead of talking about the programs and if the place should stay on his list. Ultimately, it raised more questions for us than it answered. The athletics facilities were nice, and the maker space was cool too. We did not see dorms, but we did get to see the student center, as well as their finance/trading room which was packed with Bloomberg terminals for student use. Our guides really emphasized the value of alumni connections, and many big names were dropped throughout the tour. Clubs sounded as if they’re competitive at Babson, which also doesn’t work for my 27 (I don’t think he could hit the ground running as well as he might need to in that environment), but I will say from what our guides described as their lived experiences, the school does seem to somehow balance a supportive and collaborative environment while also focusing on what is inherently a very competitive field. While it was a long shot fit for my 27 way back when we were discussing which schools to visit, I’m still glad we made the trip because I think it helped him really accept that he didn’t want to specialize in business (similar to ruling out engineering after our visit to Clarkson this spring). I’d also say that if you have a kid who is set on an undergrad business degree, it seemed like it would be an exciting and dynamic place to spend four years.

Holy Cross: UP. We arrived in Worcester at a perfect time for lunch, and I had already planned to visit the Worcester Public Market before heading to campus. It was fun, and while not within walking distance, it gave us a chance to see a tiny smidgeon of the area. After some great momo dumplings, Jamaican goat curry, and a few Jamaican patties, as well as boba tea, we rolled up the hill to admissions. Parking that day was a bit of a mess, and our email from admissions didn’t indicate that there was a parking garage available. After multiple loops, a friendly, if frustrated, campus safety officer pointed us in the right direction. Needless to say, we were not the only hapless admissions visitors looking for a spot, but I probably could have done a tad more research too.
The info session here was pretty standard. The one major takeaway for us was that they strongly recommend that applicants do the optional interview, which the AO described as an informal conversation. In the summer, these are conducted by AOs, but during the school year the virtual ones are usually scheduled with an upperclassman.
There was only one tour guide available that day, but our group was a manageable size, so it was OK. S27 loved this campus. And no, I did not mind all the steps and climbing here because it felt more spread out than Tufts. He especially liked the science center and the newer student recreation facility, which was full of natural light and very inviting. The library was the most dramatic of any of the libraries we have toured together with a classic, imposing reading room. I don’t know much at all about architecture, but it was the kind of space that oozed quiet study. We asked if the library had spaces for group study, or if the quiet levels were determined by floor like at other campuses, and he indicated that most, if not all, spaces in the library were pretty quiet. Apparently, in the quietest of the quiet sections, there are QR codes on the tables from which students can anonymously “report” loud or disruptive behavior and a librarian will come to address the situation - that is intense, but my 27 was not turned off by it at all. We followed up with the question about whether there are spaces for more casual study or group project work, and he said absolutely, that he often uses the music library, and just going through some of the buildings, there were certainly ample areas for group study. The newer arts center is stunning from the outside as well as the inside. We also checked out “Easy Street” - the flattest part of campus - where we could see the outside of dorms, but we did not get to see a dorm room. Not a concern for my 27. The newer senior housing looked great from the outside. Finally, we wrapped the tour at the chapel, which was unfortunately already locked for the day. What struck my kiddo the most during the “why did I choose Holy Cross” part at the end of the tour was that our guide said what he has come to love the most in his time there is the community’s commitment to dialogue and listening to/engaging with other viewpoints. It was a really thoughtful answer and not one we have heard from students elsewhere. My 27 loved the campus, both the buildings and the green spaces, and there was something about that answer from our tour guide that really struck him, so Holy Cross moved up his list.

19 Likes

Did a little tour of upstate NY schools.

Binghamton - SAME. This was my second visit to Binghamton - once for each kid. I had the same reaction both times, which is that Binghamton is great, except that it’s in Binghamton. It’s affordable, top notch academically, happy kids, well-maintained campus, but unfortunately in the middle of absolutely nowhere. My daughter is applying because it feels kind of mandatory (nearly everyone in her HS applies, and many attend). I think we’d all be happy if she ended up there but she’s not super excited about it.

Syracuse - DOWN…but then ultimately UP. Showed up the night before the tour and went out for dinner in downtown Syracuse. The whole experience was so depressing that I started counting the minutes until I could leave Syracuse. It feels like an abandoned spooky ghost town. The businesses are all empty and the streets are lined with men asking for money. I felt very unsafe and - to be clear - I’m not easily scared - I live in the Bronx and I work in Times Square (where we had two stabbings today). Anyway, I felt like the school would have to be an A+ to counterbalance my experience in town - and it really lived up to the hype. I loved the mix of old and brand new buildings. Everything felt well maintained and cared for. Our tour guides were engaged and clearly loved their school. Lots of talk about all the fun they were having. Accidentally ended up in a conversation with a student in my daughter’s intended major who raved about it (and she’s not a tour guide so she didn’t need to embellish). My daughter was sold in the end - maybe not to attend (it’s still the middle of nowhere) but she will at least apply and has some good ideas for her “Why Syracuse” essay.

Cornell - DOWN but not out. I think my complaint here is that the tour was all business. It didn’t seem like they wanted to focus on anything fun. I don’t know if this was just our guide, or all of them. Basically it was all about this school and this major and this research opportunity, with very little about what the kids do for fun, or how they build community. They are also one of the few tours that doesn’t take you to see a dorm room. In fact, they don’t even show you the dorms from a distance, so the tour felt very unfinished. I was there for my nephew who is just starting his college search and he was really ready to love Cornell, but I think in the end felt like he liked what he saw, but there was a lot he still wanted to see.

19 Likes

University of Miami- UP

The school was having an open house for prospective students called “Preview the U” that we decided to check out.

I don’t see a lot on these boards about UMiami, but my son and I left impressed, both of us liking it a lot more than we thought we would.

The campus is gorgeous- it’s situated around a lake with a fountain in the middle. Many of the buildings look brand new. For us New Englanders it was a treat to see an iguana basking in the sunshine on campus, tropical birds in the trees, and all of the lush foliage. It’s also the only campus we’ve been to with a large outdoor swimming pool close to the center of campus.

The event was extremely well run- a phone app had the campus map and schedule of activities for the day. There were student helpers everywhere- proudly wearing their green and orange. If you stopped someone to ask for directions, they’d also ask a little about you and ask if you have any questions about the university. Everyone was super friendly- even when we ate in the dining hall, the dining hall attendants would say hello and ask how your day was.

My son is interested in business and he was really impressed with the business school information session/student panel. He found it more engaging than at other schools and felt like they weren’t saying the same thing he is used to hearing. Usually this is the time my son checks out but he was really engaged in the presentation. He really felt they articulated what you should be looking for in a business school and what sets them apart. Afterwards he talked with one of the students on the panel for ten minutes and exchanged contacts.

I was most impressed with how the school feels like it is in its own bubble. To one side of campus is a beautiful expensive residential area and the other side is unattractive commercial sprawl. The campus is its own oasis that is self contained and feels a world away from the city- it feels more like a resort. There is a light rail in front of campus that goes to downtown Miami (about 30 mins away).

This was the only school in the south that we have visited so it was novel to see beach volleyball courts on campus, signs promoting a scuba club, and and outing club that in addition to hikes offers things like stand up paddleboarding.

There’s a lot to like about Miami, and my son will definitely be applying. Yes, it was hot and humid when we were there, and I’m sure it can get rough at the very beginning and end of the school year when the temperatures are high. In my mind Miami had a reputation as a “party school” but I don’t know if that’s from back when I went to college- I really didn’t get that impression from our visit- the students seemed like bright achievers (The school also jumped up 9 places to #55 in US News this year). Unfortunately the business school has an acceptance rate of 16%, so we will stay tuned as to whether this merits further consideration.

11 Likes

UNH - same for 27, up for me. This was a tour of one of the colleges within UNH (COLSA) and focused on academic programs. A lot of facilities in COLSA had been recently renovated and the main building had up to date labs and classrooms and inviting study space areas where students were studying individually or in small groups. Several professors spoke about their labs and they were enthusiastic in talking with the group. The opportunity for student participation in research was touted repeatedly. Student tour guides were smart, friendly, engaged in a lot of clubs/activities, and down to earth.

We didn’t do the standard tour that included information on general resources - academic, res life, social, recreational etc. However, we walked through campus to get to where we were going and it was a really pretty campus with pretty buildings and lots of tree lined pathways. We didn’t see an actual quad but honestly we didn’t explore because it was absolutely pouring. Lots of students walking in pairs despite rain. We walked through one of the student commons-type buildings with a cafeteria, it was a bit outdated but fine. Fairly busy.

I thought it would be a great option for someone interested in life sciences, ecology, or animal science. My 27 thought it “didn’t stand out” BUT I think he wants to go a bit further away from home so I’m not sure anything could overcome that bias. The downtown Durham area is very walkable from campus but is very small. We ate at a cute sandwich shop just off campus. Portsmouth and the beach are maybe 15 or 20 minutes away (“like I would go to the beach around here in the fall or winter” said 27…which is fair, even in July the water is brutally cold) and the school did mention the Amtrack train station in town which goes to Boston and up into Maine.

11 Likes

Harvard -

My S26 visited the campus twice during a one-week tour of area schools. Spent time with two students he knew from high school. Attended a class. Decided not to apply - felt it was going to be a rat race. My words, not his.

Yale -

Also visited Yale. We ate dinner off campus, got to see how New Haven is indeed a little rough. Got panhandled within steps of stepping outside a dorm. Watched a Yale student get busted for a fake ID by one bouncer, even while same bouncer was cheerfully giving us directions to a nearby restaurant (quite the multitasker). Our AirBnB shared a hallway with some equally-cheerful varsity football linemen who were exceedingly polite and well-spoken. Overall, Yale’s people made a great impression on me, but I think the setting was too rough for him. Vanderbilt is a similar island in the middle of a city, but the vibe felt better, like the school is more comfortably assimilated into the nearby city.

U of Pacific -

This was going to be a safety school with a lot going for it on paper. On site, it was hot as a furnace in late May, but everyone kept remarking how mild it was that day. Also, S26 is pretty advanced in math, and the admissions presenter kept directing him back to scenarios he was already well past. It was a big red flag that they might have a hard time placing him. Finally, the (American) tour guide asked what side of the road we drove on at home. Didn’t know our home state was one of the 50. All of it combined to make him think he wouldn’t feel at home there.

Boston University -

Kind of the opposite choice from Yale and Vandy, in an urban school. School felt threaded through the neighborhood. Might be perfect for someone who wants to feel like they are moving to a particular neighborhood with access to a great school, but it wasn’t the right scenario for him.

13 Likes

Visited some Pacific Northwest schools last month. D is a high-stats, high-achieving kiddo, but we are full pay, so we focus on schools that give merit aid.

Seattle University - Moved up. Went on official tour. We were surprised how much we ended up liking the campus. It is only 50 acres, in the middle of the Capitol Hill neighborhood in Seattle, with about 4,500 undergrads (and another couple thousand grad students). What the campus lacks in open green space, (there is almost none, other than a couple of small fields used by locals to play with their dogs) it makes up for with the landscape design. It is really like a small well-thought-out arboretum. The streets flanking campus feel less college town and more nice urban neighborhood, with real restaurants and bars that the Seattle locals visit, in addition to college students who can afford to eat out (not cheap!). Diverse student body, hip-seeming students, and the chance to live right in a nice part of the city for four years. Honors college and good student-to-faculty ratio. D will be applying. Tour guides weren’t great, admissions presentation wasn’t great, but still overall a good option. Good for people who like that Macalester is right in the city, but want some other options.

University of Washington (UW) - Stayed the same. Unofficial tour. Felt especially massive visiting after Seattle University. Campus lives up to the hype as a beautiful place. The new dorms and new green space hangout area between them is really nice, and we visited on an uncharacteristically sunny day, so a lot of students were out using it. The main library is obviously great. It is so big that feels like it is it’s own city, and it does have a larger student body population than many college town populations. Applying out of state, so likely not worth the cost, but D will likely apply anyway.

University of Victoria (Canada) - Moved up. This university seems to never show up in the CC threads, so happy to add some info here. It isn’t easy to get to (from home it requires a plane, a 2+ hour drive, a ferry, and another car), but once we arrived…wow! Victoria is well deserving of its listing in many lists of “most beautiful cities” and “best cities in the world”. Peaceful, clean, lovely housing stock (that non-Canadians are banned from purchasing), on the water, just beautiful. The campus itself was amazing. Green, filled with trees, flowers and open space. The new dorms and the law school are stunning. Most of the older campus facilities are …meh. Very 1960s-70s and uninspiring. Also they are all different and not much cohesiveness of style. But the campus itself makes up for it. Really stunning and living in Victoria for four years is basically unattainable as a non-Canadian any other way. D will be applying.

University of Puget Sound: Moved up. Tacoma is fine, nothing great, but nice location and access to other beautiful PNW locations. The campus is really really beautiful. It feels almost like a PNW version of University of San Diego, or Santa Clara - borderline country club feel, but with massive Redwoods and Maples instead of palm trees. Clean, safe feeling, in a suburban neighborhood, but feels separate and “campusy”. Buildings are all matching red brick and look lovely. New facilites are really nice - some older ones need work, but overall really comfortable place. Student body is small - quite a bit smaller than what D wants, but she will be applying.

19 Likes

Fordham Lincoln Center- Down and Off

Fordham Rose Hill- Same

Fordham double feature! With DS27 we started at Fordham Lincoln Center. The information session was packed. The speaker was engaging but not a lot of new information was provided. I appreciated the frankness of being told submit SAT of 1380 and above, otherwise don’t submit.

The campus is just a couple of buildings in one square block of city with its own private courtyard “campus”. It is in a fantastic part of Manhattan. As small as it was, it felt more like a unified campus to me than NYU since access to the green space (what little there is) is restricted to people connected to the school. Fordham did a great job of making it feel like a little bubble separated from the city. The buildings are all connected indoors so you don’t have to go outside in the winter. (When my kids were little I read them a book series called Sideways Stories from Wayside School about an elementary school mistakenly built as a skyscraper and the Lincoln Center campus reminded me of this). Be prepared for a lot of elevator riding if you come here.

We didn’t see a dorm during the tour, which I thought was a loss for Fordham because if you look online the freshman dorms look fantastic.

I loved the Lincoln Center campus- an insulated little fort of a campus with central Manhattan right outside the walls (and Central Park two blocks away). Unfortunately my son didn’t have the same reaction. “No way. It feels like a prison. There will probably be days that I don’t even go outside.” Ok then! Off the list and onto the subway.

We rode the subway to the Bronx and made it to the Rose Hill campus. One area outside the campus has the New York Botanical Gardens and an Italian neighborhood known for its restaurants and bakeries. We came from a different direction and it was loud, chaotic, and a little rough. Crossing into the Rose Hill campus was entering a gorgeous green oasis with striking Gothic architecture. It really is a beautiful campus. Everyone was super friendly and people seemed happy here. My son definitely preferred this campus to Lincoln Center, even though that campus is closer to possible business internship opportunities and all the other amenities of Manhattan. Everything is still accessible from the Bronx- it’s just that it’s a 30+ minute ride away and you need a little more planning to go into Manhattan.

I will mention that as a Jewish family the Jesuit nature of Fordham was more apparent and its presence felt on the Rose Hill campus much more than at Boston College or Georgetown to us. It was not noticeable at all at Lincoln Center. Even though it felt more prominent at Rose Hill it wasn’t significant enough to prevent my son from applying.

Rose Hill stays on the list for now. My son likes the business school curriculum and access to Manhattan. He wasn’t so excited about the surrounding neighborhood that we walked through. Stay tuned…

14 Likes

We have visited a crazy amount of schools between my two kids. I’ll do a quick blurb for each, but feel free to reach out if you want more details.

D23 - Applying for Game Dev or Computer Science with an interest in econ (she ended up at USC double majoring in game dev and business)

Up:

USC - This was the dream school since Freshman year. We thought she would hate it when we visited, but she LOVED it. She felt right at home and it confirmed it was where she wanted to be.

Northeastern - Way up. They did an amazing presentation that really got my daughter excited about attending. They focused on co-op, cross discipline, and study abroad all of which my daughter was excited about.

Syracuse - Way Up. This was a big surprise. After USC, she felt most at home here and was really excited about the programs. She would have done a unique combined program that she couldn’t have gotten anywhere else.

WPI - Way Up. After we visited, I thought this was one of the best schools for my daughter. Smart and social students doing incredibly interesting things.

Clark - She wasn’t really considering small schools but she loved the personalized attention and the new developments the school was adding. This was the first time she could see herself at a small school.

Harvard - We visited because we were in Boston, but she absolutely loved it to the point it upset her because she knew how hard it would be to get in (she ended up getting waitlisted and not pursuing since she got into USC) It was the deep intellectual nerdiness of our tour guide and the intellectual opportunities he talked about that really got her excited.

Boston College - This is hard to say as Up because she didn’t apply, but she really loved it. She loved it so much that it completely eliminated Jesuit schools from her list because if she couldn’t get past the religious aspect there, she wouldn’t anywhere. We both thought it was the most beautiful campus we visited and we loved how involved and happy the students were.

Barnard - This is another weird one because we went for the first time for Admitted Students Day. And we loved it. We were there all day and they put on an incredible program and exposed her to so many opportunities and programs she would have at her disposal. And she met so many students that she could see herself among. Furthermore, we did a tour of Columbia and the students looked happy. But she was already set on USC at this point.

Same:

University of Rochester - This was a beautiful campus with kind, smart students. It’s more a fit for my younger daughter and she is applying. Students were really interested in learning for the sake of learning.

Brown - Basically the same thing, but Ivy mode. :sweat_smile: D23 wasn’t really interested before we visited and the visit confirmed that. However, the inverse is true D27. For D23, the guide was a computer science major with an interest in game dev and he basically told her that this isn’t the best school for that (which we knew)

Boston University - She was pretty sure she didn’t want a school without a firm campus and this confirmed it. Info session was great, but tour was awful. The tour guide clearly didn’t like the school and put it down in some way in every one of her blurbs.

Down:

Cornell - Everyone looked SO miserable. No one walked together in groups.

MIT - This was the biggest shock. She had MIT on her list since 6th grade. She ended up not applying after the tour. The info presenter and guides were mean and demeaning. We felt very unwelcome being there. The tour itself was interesting but the info session seemed to be concentrated on dissuading students to apply. And it worked.

RIT - We were really excited about both the game dev major and labs and the cybersecurity major and labs. The tour did a great job showing those off. She didn’t get a great vibe from the rest of the campus or the student body. The dorms were really dark and gloomy. However, the food was off the charts good. Like better than a restaurant good. We had three meals there!!

UCs: We visited several UCs, but it was during Covid. That did them a real disservice and prevented her from seeing them as a serious option.

LMU: Again, it was during Covid, but the vibes were really off for her. We had a 1-1 tour guide and D23 said she wasn’t religious and then the next stop, the guide took us to the Church and spent like 5 minutes there. D23 actually wanted to leave during the info session, but we stayed for the tour and probably shouldn’t have.

13 Likes

D27 - Applying for Psych or Neuroscience with an interest in research and a goal to get a PhD. She hasn’t decided on school size and is looking at all ranges, but ~6000 is a nice number.

Up:

Tufts - There are a few schools we visited that hit the magic combo of mid-size, liberal arts feel/curriculum, heavy research opportunities, nice students. This was the first school we visited that we felt like that and she almost EDed here before deciding not to ED anywhere.

Lehigh - This is one of the reasons she decided not to ED. Lots of the same feels as Tufts, so she couldn’t definitely say which school she liked more. In addition to the above, the student body was so impressive, friendly, and helpful. We loved Bethlehem and the campus is gorgeous.

William and Mary - The third school that has those feels. She felt at home on this campus despite the fact that it was pouring rain. All the students we interacted with she could see being friends with. The buildings were incredible being old on the outside and modern on the inside.

Stanford - She did a summer program here where she interacted with professors doing neuroscience research and this both increased her interest in neuroscience research and got her crazy excited to be the company of those doing this research.

Carleton - Absolutely loved every minute on their campus. The students were so happy and loved each other and their professors. The efforts they go through to encourage student bonding and involvement were really exciting to us. The campus would be a wonderful place to spend four years. And again, the students were so intellectually smart and curious that my daughter could see herself fitting right in.

Macalester - Out of every school in this list and D23 list, this was our best info session. He did an amazing job selling the school and it got us all excited. The tour furthered the interest with our tour guide having the same interests as our daughter and sharing all his opportunities. Further, she sat in a class after that engaged her, included her, and really got her excited for being a student at Macalester.

University of Minnesota Twin Cities - We were really impressed by this giant school in the middle of Minneapolis. The buildings were gorgeous, the opportunities were plentiful, and everyone seemed busy and determined. We knew nothing about it before touring and we had a really good impression.

UCLA - UCLA was one of the first schools she toured and she really liked it. The tour guide did a really good job of making the descriptions at each stop applicable to opportunities the students could have at the school.

Same:

Boston College - She goes to a Jesuit high school and BC felt very familiar. It is a beautiful school with all the best of Jesuit education.

Clark - We had a good idea since we toured with her sister. Our tour guide connected to her on her interests and even introduced her to someone else in a club that D27 might join.

Brown - We had a feeling this would be the pot shot Ivy she would want to apply to and we were right. In fact, she thought it was so perfect, she literally did not believe the tour guide was telling the truth about some of the opportunities and classes at Brown.

Lafayette - We had already visited a few SLACs at this point and Lafayette felt as expected. Very beautiful and very involved student body.

Boston University - I didn’t expect her to like BU and she didn’t. :sweat_smile: Just not the right school for her.

Down:

LMU - I was hoping she would like LMU as a safety, but she didn’t like it at all. It felt to her like an off version of her Jesuit high school. Lots of people from her high school go there, but it wasn’t the right fit for her.

Pomona - I like this one, but she did not. She couldn’t put her finger on why but said it felt weird.

Scripps - I was really hoping she would like Scripps, but she thought it was too small and she really doesn’t want an all girls school. I was hoping the consortium would resolve both of those issues, but it did not.

Brandeis - Another disappointment for us. We thought this would be a great fit on paper. The underlying issue was that it was a small school that seemed to have big school problems - hard to get classes, large classes, hard to get good housing.

Northeastern - I was disappointed because I was hoping this was a larger school she would consider after how much her older sister liked it. However, the info session and tour were so much worse than they were 4 years ago. It felt like a different school. It was so impersonal and kind of felt like a machine.

16 Likes

Columbia University Dual Degree International Programs- WAY UP

Sometimes you just get lucky- and boy did we have a great visit.

Columbia University has something called the “Dual Degree International Programs”. If enrolled in the program, you spend your freshman and sophomore years abroad, and then your junior and senior years at Columbia. The campus choices are Trinity College in Dublin, City University in Hong Kong, Tel Aviv University in Israel, and Sciences Po a French university with four campus choices of LeHavre, Menton, Poitiers, or Reims. Classes abroad are in English. At Columbia you are enrolled in the School of General Studies. When you graduate, you will get two diplomas- one from Columbia University and one from the foreign university.

We attended an afternoon midweek information session and my wife, son, and I were the only ones in attendance so it became a customized discussion of the program (we are interested in Tel Aviv University and I believe there are a lot of differences in the details of the programs). When we were finished it was time for our tour of the Columbia campus- it was a beautiful day and the campus is really striking and felt surprisingly large and separate from the surroundings.

The best part was we had the tour guides, plus a tour guide in training, and one of the tour guide’s friends decided to join- so we had five tour guides for just the three of us!!!

Because of the personal attention we had a lot of questions that were answered and a lot of concerns that were assuaged. There is a lot of close advising from both schools that happens through the duration of the program so that you can meet all of the requirements (and yes even have room for electives). When you return to Columbia junior year all the students from all of the international programs are housed together so you have this cohort of people starting out together and you don’t feel lost. The School of General Studies is more of an administrative division than anything else so students are in classes with Columbia College, SEAS, and Barnard students and everyone gets the Columbia University degree just like the Columbia College students. (There are some murmurs out there that if you are in the School of General Studies you are a “lesser than” or red headed stepchild but the tour guides assured us this was a lot of nonsense and had prestigious internships and career outcomes to back it up)

The student guides were super enthusiastic about the program. They felt very supported throughout the four years and didn’t feel disadvantaged when starting late at Columbia and were integrated into Columbia clubs and activities and internships and career opportunities.

It is a separate application from Columbia University and you cannot apply to both. The dual degree international program does not take common app- it has its own application and only has a regular decision option. The Tel Aviv University program has about 40 students a year. I think it takes a certain type of student to succeed in this type of program but if there is any interest at all, it is worth looking more into because I think it is a great opportunity and it is a lot more supportive and cohesive of a program than it might appear at first glance.

14 Likes