No one can help this OP or any other OP choose between schools. That should be obvious by now. ONLY the student and his/her family can make that decision, and they will have to make that decision based on what they personally experience and what they value as a family – no one else’s input or experience matters one iota.
My comments are of no more value that anyone else’s here, and I certainly hope the OP is not making any decisions based on what anyone says on an anonymous Internet forum.