How much do B grades impact applications to top tier schools like Stanford, Yale, Princeton, and Caltech?

His test scores will be important to see if he is in the ballpark (>1500) for his high reaches. I don’t think the B’s mean an auto-reject, especially since he pulled up the grades.

Do you have an idea of how he ranks vs classmates? While there is not a set quota per high school, the AO’s definitely are comparing students who go to the same high school. Are the teachers who write LoR’s going to say he is the best (one of) in his class in a convincing way? Will they be able to point to specific attributes that make him stand out as an asset to the school he will be attending?

Don’t know your kid, but Caltech in our experience has a very specific “fit”. Have you chosen it because of its prestige or does your kid thrive on STEM topics and activities? Yale does not have a business minor.

Getting into any T20 (let alone T10) is a bit of a crapshoot for even the most highly qualified academic students. Don’t create a mindset that not getting in one means failure or something wasted. While for certain industries/employers, the college matters whether it is a “feeder”, this is not true for engineering. Find a school where he will be happy and less stressed will likely yield a better career/life outcome.

4 Likes

Certainly some have pet schools, but they’re often not the ones we repeatedly see on the lists.

Maybe your school is different.

Our school transcript only shows final grade, not each term. So we do not worry a B from any random term/semester/marking period.

1 Like

I assumed by term they meant semester - but its a good thing to question…if they mean quarter, etc.

I still think - and there’s no test score - the student was “assuming” admission to a top tier school - as they perceive it. And even if they had straight As, that answer doesn’t change. So that’s maybe the biggest challenge - is setting realistic expectations, although it’s completely understandable why a student would feel they are worthy (and many likely are that get told no). At the end of the day, the schools, not students, get to decide.

There’s too many accomplished kids vs. available seats - like my daughter’s val with a 4.0, 36 ACT, and 10 or 11 APs and was shut out at the top 20. Ended up at UTK (in state school).

Absolutely. That was my intent behind including both lists, and there are even more I could suggest considering. No one ranking can possibly capture everything of potential interest to a specific applicant, nor could it weight it appropriately for all specific applicants, or so on. But as an individual, you can look at a bunch of this stuff as may be relevant to you, and then fold whatever you found useful into your own personal ranking.

1 Like

I personally think there is so much noise in the popular salary reports they are not really usable at all. But sure, if someone thought they were useful information, that would be an example of another thing they could fold into a personal ranking.

2 Likes

It’s interesting you all say that - because these kids are going into organizations where they are using - you guessed it - data - for most every decision.

And the colleges gather the data for a reason. Some are better than others - i.e. some have high knowledge rates (Bama, WPI) and some don’t (Ga Tech) - but since when is data a bad thing?

Now - there are other variables and you need to look job to job - a Yale grad may be a consultant or in I Banking where as a Bama grad or PSU grad is likely to be an engineer.

And location matters - you don’t get paid as much in Columbus Ohio as you do in Los Anageles.

But in the end, and I’m sure my son’s organization is reflective (they hire many engineers) - yep, both Michigan and W MIchigan and they start at the same salary.

I don’t want to get into the is the career data worthy argument again - but these schools are publishing it, so use or don’t use at your own peril but companies are using data, so why wouldn’t a prospective student?

This is relevant data - unlike rankings, etc. The only question becomes - is the data useful -i.e. if you are only capturing 1/3 of your grads - what about the other 2/3 and you can’t always isolate for location and or actually job being done.

If I were comparing salary info, I would multiply them by a region- or state- (or even city-) specific coefficient to normalize the numbers to take COL into account.

Why?

  1. Most grads’ first jobs are in the same neighborhood as their college, and
  2. Differences in cost-of-living mean that salaries for the same position will vary based on location.
4 Likes

Data-- highly misleading in the context of salaries. Large companies prefer “total comp” as the metric to eliminate some of the Garbage In,Garbage Out problem but even at a macro level (a company with 100 k employees) comparing and benchmarking is still fraught with error…some small, some huge.

Deferred comp…it can be as small as a 5k annual bonus, or $100k in options. Some new grads will include, others not when reporting. A company which pays the entire legal amount into a 401k vs one which matches an employees contribution up to 7k. Some new grads understand this is real money and report, others do not.

If a huge corporation with a team of hundreds of comp and benefits professionals find it challenging to benchmark their comp it is quite naive to think that a college alumni office with three analysts can pull it off.

One company has a cafeteria plan benefit package…what you don’t use for dental or disability gets paid out as cash. The other has a traditional benefit plan. Which is more lucrative? You tell me! 20 different variables go into that “data”.

5 Likes

You’re looking at multiple kids (volume) getting hired by traditional companies. You can destroy the data if you want but the reality is there is substance there. Most are getting hired by traditional companies. Yes, some have sign on bonuses and should be noted if they are in the #. And yes, some, like my son (and me) include an expected (but not assured) performance bonus. My son’s is 10% - but his salary was his salary and that’s what was reported - because they suss that out in the questionnaires.

Let’s not over complicate it - but the point was simply another factor for the OP to look at and to point out to them, they can do well - from anywhere. It’s not top 10 or you’re a failure.

Not looking to have this debate over and over again - but it is useful for OP (if they desire) to look at.

Why does he need to be at a top 10 school?

Does he realize that a number of those schools have extremely limited seating?

Does he realize that those schools are expensive?

Our children performed exceptionally well in their admissions.
When their freshman English classes had the “counselor talks” about college, the kids did tell us about those visits. We gave them their college budgets and told them, that if we couldn’t afford it from their 529 accounts, then they needed to consider other affordable options .

Neither my husband, nor I were involved in their applications and we initially had no idea where they all had applied.

They all had rigorous coursework.
They all maintained unweighted 4.0 gpa’s
They were all Varsity athletes.
They all worked part time and summer jobs: Zoo, Sea World, food service.

Eldest Daughter:
Yale, Johns Hopkins, UC’s and went to SUNY Buffalo (on a full ride) as a double major in EE/CS.
Middle Daughter:
Chose Davis because of strong record of Medical School preparation. Got into UCSF for Med School.
Youngest Son:
Top 5 student at his large HS. (Missed 1 question on SAT’s), Eagle Scout. Attended Caltech. We paid full fees. Every student at Caltech is eligible for merit, so they don’t need to give it out. Learned that Caltech is a research institution and is a FIT school. It is not a small college/university. It is a RESEARCH institution with inexperienced grad students running the courses while the professors lecture and return to their own research projects. Publish or perish.

What my husband and I learned:

The colleges like nice kids. The administrative staff (Principal/Vice Principal, Coaches, teachers) at their large HS all knew our kids by name, and us, as well.

Rigor and respectful attitude counts.

Getting outside of the classroom counts (Volunteering, sports, jobs)

Budget should be heavily weighed when applying to colleges.

Not one of them had a leadership title in a club, in their HS activities. The staff sought them out as leaders.

Given that there are ~45K student Valedictorians annually, we didn’t expect them to get into the top 10s.

All of them did extremely well.
Eldest attended SUNY Buffalo to save US money for her siblings!
She’s had a meteoric rise as an engineering and CS manager for a large international engineering firm. Her program at Buffalo was extremely strong and under-rated.

Stanford legacies. Eldest two didn’t get in but weren’t interested in that school. Applied for Dad. Son, didn’t finish the alumni request for letter.

2 Likes

To take that one step further, and I get push back every time I say it, I had two retired Caltech/JPL professors as patients. Both advised my son who was fully qualified, not to apply. They both praised the graduate program, but one went as far as saying “Caltech is not an undergraduate institution.”

This is but one anecdote with a very important message…do not use rankings as your only metric. Learn what your student wants their experience to be like and make a list of schools that meet those criteria.

3 Likes

If a student is not accepted to the highly selective schools, I seriously doubt the few Bs alone would be the main reason, unless it’s UT and the few Bs drag the GPA or ranking out of the range UT prefers.

2 Likes

So as always with data, one of the first questions you should be asking is if you need to implement controls to extract any information you would want to use.

And in the college choice context, I think the answer is obviously yes.

The next question is can you practically implement sufficient controls?

In this context, I think the answer is typically no.

Of course that doesn’t mean this data is unusable for all purposes. But for this specific purpose, I don’t find it usable.

2 Likes

Yes, one the most obvious things you would need to control for is locational factors.

Another would be the many different types of careers people can choose. Like engineers can work as engineers in for-profit engineering firms, or engineering departments in other for-profit firms. But they can also go into academia. They can go into government or policy or other public interest jobs. They sometimes go into business roles only tangentially related to engineering. And so on.

So we’d need to control for all that too in order to make this data usable.

ETA: By the way, I suspect if you did all this, the basic hypothesis that there is a lot less career-earnings-value-added that depends on exactly which reputable engineering program you as an individual choose than some people seem to assume would be validated. Like it would turn out a lot of apparent differences disappeared with proper controls, within a wide range of engineering programs.

But that is part of why I personally don’t really see a need to use any of this salary stuff in a college choice context. Like, there are some things the OP’s son can actually know, like how much a given engineering program would cost. He can also know what their general curriculum looks like, what classes they offer, and what majors and tracks and such they offer. He can know what research the faculty is doing. He can know what engineering clubs they have. He can know where the college is located. How the dorms and dining work. Non-engineering activities. And so on.

All that stuff is ascertainable without a bunch of very thorny control problems.

And yes, he doesn’t need really need EduRank for any of that either. As I see it, EduRank is more a starting point, a lead generator. Like, Wisconsin is highly ranked for Electrical Engineering in that measure. OK, cool, maybe that means it would be a good idea to check out Wisconsin! But that’s the beginning, not the end, of such a process.

Same deal with Rose-Hulman topping the other list. Maybe worth checking out! But that’s a lead into the process, not the end of it.

4 Likes

A post was split to a new thread: Math Sequence Question/AP Stats

His school transcript lists

UC (Capped) GPA 4.148
UC (W) GPA 4.630

This is useful, I will definitely check this out and discuss with him.

:folded_hands: I will consider what you have said. TYSM

@Mwfan1921 Changed this to reply directly.