<p>I, too, admire and respect Tigger Mom for appearing to be realistic about what happened, and wanting to be supportive both to her S and to the girl.</p>
<p>I think that Tigger Mom should do what she can to be at the hearing and to meet with her S and the dean as well as his counselor (and one can meet with a counselor without getting all of the details of counseling sessions), who can give Tigger Mom a read on whether her S appears to be seeriously mentally or is simply a young man with bad judgement, poor social skills, or an alcohol problem that impaired his judgment. The mother needs to know this information from the therapist’s mouth in order to continue to help her son. For instance, is her S someone who could benefit from going to Alcoholics Anonymous and being totally abstinent from alcohol or is he someone who could benefit by being in group therapy or taking antipsychotic medication after having a thorough physical to rule out a physical reason for his behavior. (One of my friend’s daughters began acting bizarrely last year and ended up having a brain tumor.)</p>
<p>I do not think that Tigger Mom should get a lawyer involved unless it’s just to get general advice. I have been a college faculty member, and headed a departmental committee on plagiarism. We had the power to suspend students from campus. Most students showed up at the hearing, spoke their case, and then faculty gave them whatever punishment that the faculty thought would get the message accross. Faculty like students, even students who make mistakes, so the idea was never to ruin any student’s life.</p>
<p>However, one student did get a lawyer involved, and that caused the university’s lawyer to get involved since everything was being so scruitinized. Instead of faculty’s being able to focus on doing what one could to teach a student an important lesson while not ruiniing the student’s life, the faculty and administrators had to spend a lot of time basically covering their butts in case of a lawsuit. The student showed up a that hearing with her mother and lawyer, and that definitely changed the tone of everything because it seemed that the student and her mother were far more interested in saving the student’s butt (and this student had blatantly plagiarized) than helping the student learn from her mistake. It’s hard to seem remoursful if one shows up at a school hearing like this with a lawyer at one’s elbow.</p>
<p>I also fear that if you show up with a lawyer or of the school finds out a lawyer is involved, that may cause the girl to get a lawyer herself and to press charges. Particularly after the Virginia Tech situation, people will probably be less inclined to let colleges handle this kind of situation. The college itself probably now is considering ending handling such cases through campus methods. </p>
<p>While I understand that you and your S would like him to finish the semester – even if that means that he’d do it from home – it appears that your S’s behavior put him in this situation, and the college may be very much within their rights to suspend him and to tell him that he has to do the entire semester over. Having him do the semester from home or finish the semester later would put an additional burden on professors, which isn’t fair to them. Many classes depend on class participation, labs and similar things. </p>
<p>When I was a professor, I didn’t mind having to make various exceptions for students who were, for instance, ill or had to miss classes because of dying parents or other emergencies. . I would have balked, however, at being expected to create special rules for someone who got suspended from school due to violating the school’s rules.</p>
<p>Yes, this semester will probably end up being money down the drain . To me, however, part of your S’s taking responsibility for his actions would be his doing what it takes to borrow or otherwise replace the money that you spent to support him in school this semester.</p>