Thanks for all the comments. I have some responses and some questions, if you think I an wrong about anything please point it out.
The vast majority of students in her high school stay in state, primarily going to the flagship or the local directional. Every year there’s a handful of kids that apply for Ivy and equivalent schools, seems like usually a couple get in. Strategically for that reason I think her odds might be better at a NESCAC or similar school than an Ivy or similar school. Looking through Naviance, there are only a few applications total over the last several years to NESCAC type schools.
Also I’m thinking more about the political climate on campus and what she would be comfortable with. Like I said she is pretty liberal, but the SJW climate makes her uncomfortable. There will be a mix of students at every college, I get that. But I don’t think she’s going to be happy going to somewhere very conservative, or to somewhere where everyone has a a pet cause that they need to bring into every conversation either.
If anyone has opinions especially if they come with personal experience about how much weeding goes on in pre-med at any of these schools I would love to hear it. I know that can be a hot button, so if you’re more comfortable with a PM that’s fine. She’s okay with working hard, but I really don’t want her to have to deal with artificial barriers. If she is going to be studying with a group of kids who all would be 4.0 students at our state flagship as premeds, I really don’t want a school the plans on weeding seventy percent of them out anyway.
When we talked with our tour guide at Rochester, she said that most of her friends that were premeds had dropped out. She said it wasn’t due to grades that they couldn’t continue, but the workload was a factor, and they found other things they were interested in that were just easier or more interesting. That I’m okay with. and if anyone feels like that’s not accurate about Rochester, please let me know too.
Amherst. Definitely on the list, but probably a high reach.
Brown. Same.
Hamilton. I really wish we would have gone into New Hartford or Utica. I think D and my wife may be ready to cross it off, but this may be a Dad pick that stays on the list at least for now. if she would get accepted I would certainly want her to go again and check it out before she committed. But I really think if she was there at a better time and could see that there is decent town stuff a 15-minute drive from campus then she would want this on the list. and from what I hear the students are kind of what she’s looking for in a peer group too.
Rochester. Size and open curriculum will probably keep this on the list to the end. If I wasn’t worried about financial aid she might ED here.
Case Western. Sure seems like this has a lot in common with Rochester, which she loved. The curriculum isn’t open, but I think it’s something she could work with.
Vassar. A bit concerned about the math, although I don’t even remember where I saw that was a problem so maybe that is just wrong. Plus if you asked her today she would say history not math. But that’s probably because she’s not taking a math class right now. She tends to love whatever she’s studying at the moment. She isn’t hipster or artsty, not sure how big of an issue that is here. Also not sure about the politics on campus. I do know someone with a daughter there I can ask.
Wesleyan. On paper seems great, again not certain about the political climate. Would love to hear more about that. Because otherwise it seems like this should be high on her list.
Smith. I think it sounds like my initial concerns about the politics and climate on campus if anything were understated not overstated. This is probably dropping off.