Need help figuring out a list

Thanks for all the comments. I have some responses and some questions, if you think I an wrong about anything please point it out.

The vast majority of students in her high school stay in state, primarily going to the flagship or the local directional. Every year there’s a handful of kids that apply for Ivy and equivalent schools, seems like usually a couple get in. Strategically for that reason I think her odds might be better at a NESCAC or similar school than an Ivy or similar school. Looking through Naviance, there are only a few applications total over the last several years to NESCAC type schools.

Also I’m thinking more about the political climate on campus and what she would be comfortable with. Like I said she is pretty liberal, but the SJW climate makes her uncomfortable. There will be a mix of students at every college, I get that. But I don’t think she’s going to be happy going to somewhere very conservative, or to somewhere where everyone has a a pet cause that they need to bring into every conversation either.

If anyone has opinions especially if they come with personal experience about how much weeding goes on in pre-med at any of these schools I would love to hear it. I know that can be a hot button, so if you’re more comfortable with a PM that’s fine. She’s okay with working hard, but I really don’t want her to have to deal with artificial barriers. If she is going to be studying with a group of kids who all would be 4.0 students at our state flagship as premeds, I really don’t want a school the plans on weeding seventy percent of them out anyway.

When we talked with our tour guide at Rochester, she said that most of her friends that were premeds had dropped out. She said it wasn’t due to grades that they couldn’t continue, but the workload was a factor, and they found other things they were interested in that were just easier or more interesting. That I’m okay with. and if anyone feels like that’s not accurate about Rochester, please let me know too.

Amherst. Definitely on the list, but probably a high reach.

Brown. Same.

Hamilton. I really wish we would have gone into New Hartford or Utica. I think D and my wife may be ready to cross it off, but this may be a Dad pick that stays on the list at least for now. if she would get accepted I would certainly want her to go again and check it out before she committed. But I really think if she was there at a better time and could see that there is decent town stuff a 15-minute drive from campus then she would want this on the list. and from what I hear the students are kind of what she’s looking for in a peer group too.

Rochester. Size and open curriculum will probably keep this on the list to the end. If I wasn’t worried about financial aid she might ED here.

Case Western. Sure seems like this has a lot in common with Rochester, which she loved. The curriculum isn’t open, but I think it’s something she could work with.

Vassar. A bit concerned about the math, although I don’t even remember where I saw that was a problem so maybe that is just wrong. Plus if you asked her today she would say history not math. But that’s probably because she’s not taking a math class right now. She tends to love whatever she’s studying at the moment. She isn’t hipster or artsty, not sure how big of an issue that is here. Also not sure about the politics on campus. I do know someone with a daughter there I can ask.

Wesleyan. On paper seems great, again not certain about the political climate. Would love to hear more about that. Because otherwise it seems like this should be high on her list.

Smith. I think it sounds like my initial concerns about the politics and climate on campus if anything were understated not overstated. This is probably dropping off.

Muhlenburg, Wooster Need to look more here.

William and Mary. This is one school that the NPC does not work for me at all. Unless I move to Virginia in the next 12 months, which I don’t see happening, it’s out.

St Olaf. I think the requirements are going to be an issue here. That’s kind of the opposite of an open curriculum. I guess it’s not Chicago or Columbia, but I don’t think it’s really what she’s looking for. Which is too bad because location is great comparatively and her odds of getting in are much higher.

Rice, Tulane, Vanderbilt, Emory, Washington and Lee, Davidson

How is the political climate at these schools? We don’t live in the south, but the politics here are the same. She’s sick of being surrounded by people that think if you didn’t vote for Trump it means you hate America. She’s trying to avoid that just as much as the SJW issue. I’m not saying this because I want any political debate going on here. Mostly I’m just trying to explain where she’s coming from. So I think we’re looking for schools where neither of those extremes are going to be dominant. I know none of those schools are gonna be SJW hotbeds, but overall how liberal / conservative are they?

You won’t find that sort of political commentary at any of the schools discussed. Other than some schools known for constitutional conservatism like liberty hillsdale and some of the more religious schools, you perhaps will.

The others on your list you will never hear those words spoken. This age group is very liberal.

For SJW ethos. Skidmore Oberlin Smith Wellesley. NY. And Philly schools especially swat bmc penn NYU Barnard Brown is pretty high of SJW Richter scale as well.

@dadof4kids, I wouldn’t worry too much about a curriculum based on distribution requirements. Distribution requirements in which students take ~3 classes in each of 3 different academic groups are not as restrictive as core curriculums. Bear in mind that even open curriculums have graduation requirements (for example, writing intensive, language, cross-cultural), plus progression requirements within the individual majors. They are not entirely open.

A student like your daughter with a range of interests (e.g., math & history) will have no problem fulling typical distribution requirements as well as meeting medical school prerequisites.

I would also suggest that you study the level of advising available for medical school admissions. Your daughter might take a look at Williams (even though its rural location may be a negative). My son was in humanities, but from his classmates’ experiences, I can attest to Williams strong premed counseling and its track record for getting its students into selective medical schools.
https://careers.williams.edu/sciences-health-professions/

Williams offers superb math and sciences as well as excellent social sciences such as History. Double majoring in seemingly diverse disciplines (like history and math) is common. The political climate leans left but is not intensely activist. Your daughter sounds like the type of student that Williams attracts: high achievers in academics and sports (even if she doesn’t intend to play at a varsity level).

Regarding potential premeds changing their intentions because some other area was easier or more interesting, I think you’ll find that at most schools with a large group of high-performing students.

I personally found the Niche surveys to be useful in assessing political climate. For instance:

Washington & Lee: 78% of respondents perceive the campus as conservative or very conservative, 0% progressive / very liberal
Emory: 1% conservative, 15% progressive / very liberal
Smith: 0% conservative, 79% progressive / very liberal

I am not sure why you are getting advice steering you towards schools like Rice and WAsh U and Amherst, which are really really high reaches.
Rochester is a great place and a good match.
I would think about Brandeis too.
Pitt would be a nice safety I think and great for pre-meds.

Pitt would be a reach as well, financially, as it sounds like she would attend only if she got Big Merit and that is getting just as competitive as admission to the high-reach privates.

Whether all of these high-reach suggestions are relevant will depend in part on how the standardized tests actually go.

Re: political climate at Rice - my D13 was a progressive-but-not-SJW West Coaster who grew up in an area where liberal ideologies predominate. She definitely felt that while progressives were still in the majority on campus, it was not an echo chamber - there was enough diversity of viewpoints that everyone had to do the work of defending their positions intelligently. This made her think through her own views, which she liked. That said, it’s also a relatively apolitical campus - political conversations happen but are certainly not constant. Agreed that it’s a really high reach - more so than in 2013 when my D applied - and it’s skewing more and more toward filling the entering class with ED applicants. You’ll have to assess whether it’s a realistic target once you have definitive stats in hand.

Oddly enough, I’ve heard the rep Smith has for SJWs, but when my D20 visited (three times, including sitting in on a class), we didn’t feel the vibe at all. It didn’t feel any different from any other LAC we have visited.

That’s what I was hoping to hear about the climate at those schools. I think her biggest concern is avoiding the echo chamber for either side. She lives in one now, and wants to be somewhere where you can have intelligent conversation about issues without it pretty quickly devolving into accusations that anyone who doesn’t believe the same thing I do is either stupid or evil.

Pitt is another school I like but is out unless she gets large merit.

@momrath you may be right about distribution requirements, at least at some schools. I’ve been trying to look at them individually and figure out how they will work for her interests.

Her brothers are both at schools without a core, but with enough requirements that she can’t really do things the way she would prefer. Although that could be partly due to majors, I’m not sure. I just know I’ve helped both of them (one freshman, one soph who just transferred schools and changed majors) put together a 4 year plan, and neither had much flexibility… For them it doesn’t matter really, they’re just trying to get done what they need to get done so they can move on. She has a lot more intellectual curiosity. I think she’d be happy taking classes that sound interesting for the next ten years. And even then she would be a bit sad about the ones she was missing out on.

Also I’ll think about Williams. The rural location is an issue. But I think if she find her people she wouldn’t care as much. I think part of her hesitancy about rural is she doesn’t want to be trapped if she can’t find her crowd.

As far as being reach heavy, I’m aware. But even though it doesn’t excite her I think she would be okay with attending the state flagship. And with her stats that will be an auto admit. I’ll probably worry more about filling in matches and maybe a couple other safeties she would like more as we get further down the process. I think that while it is difficult sometimes to find those schools, there may actually be more of them. It’s a pretty small list at the top, so if she finds what she likes there then we can find something else less selective along the same lines.

Also agree we’ll know more once we have test scores. but I have a bit of an ulterior motive on looking at this now before we have those. She really wants to go to a selective school. I’m hoping to find a few she gets excited about, and then remind her that she’s going to have to actually study for higher test scores if she wants to be able to make that happen. I’ve tried using the stick to get her to study for standardized tests and it doesn’t really work. I’m hoping to have better luck with the carrot.

I’ll look at those political climate surveys on Niche. I know everything on there you have to take with the grain of salt but I do think that’s a pretty good data point.

Even though I haven’t addressed all of them, I do read and really appreciate all the comments. Thanks to everyone who has contributed. I need to do a little more research on my end, but I’ll be back after I’ve done that.

@dadof4kids I’m most familiar with Williams distro requirements, but I believe that many LACs follow the same general guidelines. There are 3 divisions: Languages & the Arts, Science & Math, Social Studies. A student interested in (or double majoring in) Math and History would automatically cover the Science/Math and Social Studies categories.

Languages & the Arts includes foreign languages, literature, theater, music, art, art history plus a whole host of cross-listed and interdisciplinary courses. Some of my son’s most memorable courses were those that fell outside of his preferred arts and humanities basket, in areas such as oceanography, geology, anthropology, even physics. This is, to me, the beauty of a liberal arts education for an intellectually curious person.

@creekland can offer some input on pre med classes at Rochester - her s did undergrad there and is now in their medical school. Your d may find Wes to be over the top, in your face SJW – out of too-many-to-mention college tours, it was the only one I felt that way about. Visit if you can.

Pomona College & the 5 Claremont College consortium

Vanderbilt University

Brown University (have a niece who was a math major, now a university prof in a state like yours, her brother, my nephew, was a math major at the Univ. of Chicago–their dad is a chaired prof. at another university).

Northwestern University if interested in “Econometrics and Quantitative Economics”–doesn’t have to pursue medicine to have a lucrative, demanding & fulfilling career. (8% admit rate, much higher for ED. )

Williams College

Stanford University if recruitable & willing to play.

Curious as to what aspect of Wm. & Mary was a turnoff.

My D is liberal but didn’t want a liberal echo chamber at an LAC. She’s very happy at Davidson where most students are liberal/moderate but there are def. conservative voices. This, along with other kinds of diversity, leads to more robust intellectual climate.

Politics isn’t her thing so in reality she’s mostly happy b/c she loves the strong sense of community and amazing profs and other resources the college offers. And the weather! Lots of happy students at Davidson and it always ranks near the top of “Grateful Grads” lists.

I’ve heard Rice is also known for happy students, and tried to get my D to apply but she didn’t.

Duke University is another school to consider. But, again, would be helpful to know what was unattractive about the College of William & Mary.

Note that pre-med course requirements/recommendations themselves span a range of fields (typical number of semester-length courses in parentheses): chemistry (4), biology (3), physics (2), math/statistics (2), English/literature (2), psychology (1), sociology (1). The general requirements of the college she chooses, along with the degree of overlap between pre-med courses and your daughter’s major and other academic interests, will affect her planning for these requirements. In a best-case scenario, study abroad would be possible.

Before reading your list of possible schools in the original post, I thought U of R. Given the non-rural request, open-ish curriculum, non-cut throat desire, it fits the bill. Strong is the second biggest hospital in NY, and is right on campus. That is simply a great place to be a pre-med, especially one who may turn towards one of the other medical careers. I know a lot of docs who went to U of R undergrad, and they all had non-science majors. It is a place which highly encourages exploration. Not a politically charged student body. Serious kids, but not March-in-the-steets types.

My son sounds a lot like your D. Tough to find an elite school without a lot of SJWs, because those schools often select for those types (‘leaders’). He sought a place where heterogeneity, of thought, race, SES, etc. was not just sought, but achieved. Very tough to find, and maybe we visited too few schools. He thus ended up choosing our state flagship as his #1. Rochester’s engineering program was not what he wanted. Just sharing the journey of a kid who was repelled by homogeneity, big time, but didn’t realize that until he visited schools.

With her work ethic, your D will be fine (even at a ‘weed-out’ school). Most premeds drop it; usually because they find there are other great options which don’t require organic chemistry (my personal hell).

Its Net Price Calculator indicated W&M would not be affordable for the OP (reply #21).

Hamilton’s Jitney schedules should give you an idea as to the time and distance to suburban and small-urban areas:

https://www.hamilton.edu/campuslife/transportation/the-jitney

https://www.hamilton.edu/campuslife/transportation/the-jitney/utica-jitney-service

Relative to most colleges, Vassar might appear both hipster and arts-oriented.

@dadof4kids Our D17’s search a few years back focused on LACs and mid-sized universities so there was a lot of overlap with your list.

LACs that seemed more middle of the road politically: Denison, Wooster, Dickinson, Muhlenberg, St. Olaf, Carleton. All but Carleton offer merit scholarships. Muhlenberg is strong in pre-med.

You mentioned possibly visiting Mac and Grinnell in the future. Mac skews quite liberal (similar to Oberlin/Wesleyan/Smith). Not sure about the SJW quotient at Grinnell. It may be too small and rural for your child.

Like many others above, I also thought of Rochester and Case Western as good picks, and less reachy than Wash U/Vandy/Rice. In the mid-sized, non SJW category, check out U of Richmond (offers merit).

Finally, as mentioned earlier, distribution requirements can be so flexible that they are not all that different than the complete freedom of an open curriculum. Given that she likes history and Math, it shouldn’t be too hard to complete those at many schools.

Good luck!