Yep, the NPC are why William and Mary, and also Pitt, are not being seriously considered.
S19 visited Williams, and even with his much narrower view of “things that sound interesting” I thought their distribution requirements would be very easy to meet. My guess is that at a school like that she would probably hit all the requirements by accident just picking classes she wanted to take. Any school with requirements along those lines would be fine.
I’ve read repeatedly to avoid CA schools for pre-med due to the competition, which is why Claremont Schools haven’t been on my radar. Otherwise they would be. Are they much worse than the other schools we are talking about? Again I’m not trying to avoid hard work, just trying to avoid schools where they intentionally fail half of the kids in Organic, no matter how well they do.
Another point on the “reach heavy” way the list is looking at this point. By and large, those schools are the ones who meet full need. So financially she is probably looking at either a top 100ish school or an in-state school. I ran the NPC for Lewis & Clark and Puget Sound (looking to add some West Coast flavor) and they were substantially more expensive than the other schools we are talking about here. So to go there for example, I’m guessing COA would be double our in-state flagship, as long as she gets a 33+ on the ACT to qualify for an automatic scholarship at the flagship. I think it’s easier to wrap my head around having to pay an extra $20,000 for an elite education than pay an extra $70,000 for one that is probably better but that doesn’t necessarily have the same connotations that something like Amherst or Brown would have, or even Rochester or Case.
She definitely isn’t recruitable for Stanford. My hunch is that she isn’t recruitable for NESCAC level play, but could probably be a bench player on most soccer teams. One of those “no support, but you can be on the team if you can get in” girls. Golf she has never really committed to, and she’s a great natural athlete, so if a school had a bad golf team and was willing to take on a project she could maybe contribute in a couple years, but not as a freshman certainly.
So on the sports, she probably isn’t recruitable. If anyone knows of schools we are discussing or similar schools who have a bad soccer team but still give out support during recruiting, let me know. Specifically she’s a winger, and bounces from offense to defense depending on who else is playing on her team or what formation the coach is running, sometimes switching positions mid game based on substitutions. (That last sentence was for soccer people only I’m guessing, on the off chance you know of a coach looking for that skill set). She isn’t necessarily opposed to playing, but kind of feels like if she isn’t getting an admissions bump she probably also isn’t really wanted/needed on the team, and her time would be better spent elsewhere.
Her brother was a high D1 recruit, so I think that colors her perception a bit of what being recruited requires. Also he is trying to make the US team to compete at the world level outside of college, so he is training a couple of hours a day outside of the season too. That is what she views as college athletics, and she (probably rightly) can see that if you want to compete on his level and be pre-med, there just aren’t enough hours in a day to do both well.