Need help figuring out a list

Yep, the NPC are why William and Mary, and also Pitt, are not being seriously considered.

S19 visited Williams, and even with his much narrower view of “things that sound interesting” I thought their distribution requirements would be very easy to meet. My guess is that at a school like that she would probably hit all the requirements by accident just picking classes she wanted to take. Any school with requirements along those lines would be fine.

I’ve read repeatedly to avoid CA schools for pre-med due to the competition, which is why Claremont Schools haven’t been on my radar. Otherwise they would be. Are they much worse than the other schools we are talking about? Again I’m not trying to avoid hard work, just trying to avoid schools where they intentionally fail half of the kids in Organic, no matter how well they do.

Another point on the “reach heavy” way the list is looking at this point. By and large, those schools are the ones who meet full need. So financially she is probably looking at either a top 100ish school or an in-state school. I ran the NPC for Lewis & Clark and Puget Sound (looking to add some West Coast flavor) and they were substantially more expensive than the other schools we are talking about here. So to go there for example, I’m guessing COA would be double our in-state flagship, as long as she gets a 33+ on the ACT to qualify for an automatic scholarship at the flagship. I think it’s easier to wrap my head around having to pay an extra $20,000 for an elite education than pay an extra $70,000 for one that is probably better but that doesn’t necessarily have the same connotations that something like Amherst or Brown would have, or even Rochester or Case.

She definitely isn’t recruitable for Stanford. My hunch is that she isn’t recruitable for NESCAC level play, but could probably be a bench player on most soccer teams. One of those “no support, but you can be on the team if you can get in” girls. Golf she has never really committed to, and she’s a great natural athlete, so if a school had a bad golf team and was willing to take on a project she could maybe contribute in a couple years, but not as a freshman certainly.

So on the sports, she probably isn’t recruitable. If anyone knows of schools we are discussing or similar schools who have a bad soccer team but still give out support during recruiting, let me know. Specifically she’s a winger, and bounces from offense to defense depending on who else is playing on her team or what formation the coach is running, sometimes switching positions mid game based on substitutions. (That last sentence was for soccer people only I’m guessing, on the off chance you know of a coach looking for that skill set). She isn’t necessarily opposed to playing, but kind of feels like if she isn’t getting an admissions bump she probably also isn’t really wanted/needed on the team, and her time would be better spent elsewhere.

Her brother was a high D1 recruit, so I think that colors her perception a bit of what being recruited requires. Also he is trying to make the US team to compete at the world level outside of college, so he is training a couple of hours a day outside of the season too. That is what she views as college athletics, and she (probably rightly) can see that if you want to compete on his level and be pre-med, there just aren’t enough hours in a day to do both well.

Consider Southern state school honors colleges. Should be able to go tuition & fees free.

I think this primarily relates to the large number of California residents attending California public universities.

The University of Richmond, mentioned above, should probably be researched, particularly as a somewhat less selective alternative to some of the schools discussed so far.

Yes, the CA premed reputation you refer to is based on the UC’s - which you wouldn’t consider anyway because the OOS cost is $65Kish. The Claremont schools are good, collaborative places to take premed classes. People are often cautioned against Harvey Mudd for premed because of their grade deflation, but HMC wouldn’t be a fit core-curriculum-wise anyway. The beauty of the Consortium, though, is that she could take classes in HMC’s amazing math department, from any of the other schools. Likewise, History is strong throughout the consortium and she could take classes at Pomona, CMC, Scripps, and Pitzer regardless of home campus. GE requirements vary but tend toward the “you’d choose those classes anyway” genre (excepting the heavy STEM core at Mudd).

Since the Claremonts are D3, it wouldn’t hurt for her to fill out the recruiting forms on the two athletic websites, CMS (joint teams for Claremont-McKenna, Mudd, and Scripps) and the Sagehens (joint teams for Pomona and Pitzer). They have both soccer and golf; either/or could give her an admissions boost.

Politically, the whole consortium leans pretty liberal, with CMC known as the most conservative and also the most “sporty.” (Note that CMC also has one of the most Early Decision heavy admission processes - ED admit rate is 25% and the majority of the class is filled that way, leaving a 7% admit rate for the remaining spots in the RD round.) There’s definitely a SJW element throughout the consortium - also a vocal conservative minority - and the discourse is more polarized and echo-chamber-y at either extreme than would be ideal. Having had one kid go to Rice and the other to Scripps, I’d choose the Rice flavor of discourse, all other things being equal… but all other things aren’t equal and the Claremonts have some compelling strengths, and anyone can find likeminded people there. Scripps differs from other women’s colleges in that it’s on an almost-surreally-lovely postage-stamp of a campus that is surrounded on all sides by the other five mixed-gender schools. As such it is more blended, both socially and academically, with its partner schools than its east coast counterparts - which can be a plus or a minus depending on what you prefer. (Scripps does offer the most generous merit of the five schools, but in your situation generosity on the need-based side may be more important.) Pomona might be the best fit in theory but it’s devilishly hard to get into - although definitely a notch easier from an underrepresented state than for Californians. At any rate, the resources for math/history/premed are phenomenal at the 5C’s. The political climate might get on your D’s nerves from time to time but perhaps not to a deal-killer degree - would have to see how the vibe felt to her.

I feel like this is getting more complicated, not easier . . .

At least the schools in New England are close to each other. Doing a Claremont, Emory, Rice, Vandy set of visits doesn’t work so well.

Although to be honest I think I just need her to see enough to figure out what she wants. She’s closer than she was, but still not quite there yet. Probably need one more set of 3-4 schools over few days. And I think she probably gets cut a bit more slack for not visiting than if we lived closer. Houston is a 14 hour drive, Cleveland is also about 14 hours, and those are probably the closest schools we are talking about. (I guess MN and IA a bit closer, but we probably will be able to visit those). Ugh, I’ve done the drive to Cleveland from here a few times. Not a fun trip. I really like Cleveland, 14 hours on the interstate not so much.

Thanks for the info on CA schools.

Yeah, there are ways to show interest without physically visiting prior to getting a decision. Visit-if-you-get-in is a reasonable approach to many reach schools. But applying ED without visiting isn’t usually a good option so that’s where it gets sticky if the school is that much of a contender.

I think Emory ticks a lot of your daughter’s boxes. It is definitely not at either extreme on the political spectrum. Even though it is in the south, I wouldn’t consider it a “southern” school in spirit/vibe.

As far as visits pre-decision/pre-application goes, you can check each school’s Common Data Set to see how they weigh “demonstrated interest”. Here is Emory’s. Look at the last row of section C7. In the case of Emory, they don’t factor interest into the admissions decision. A lot of LACs do but not all. Williams is one that doesn’t.

http://opb.emory.edu/documents/data/Emory-Common-Data-Set-2018-2019.pdf

My thought was Tufts, but I see it has been mentioned.

Given the stated preferences and reactions, I’m not sure what there is about Grinnell that is ticking her boxes, enough to make a special trip to visit there.
I thought one of the most liberal student bodies, in a highly isolated location.

I’m not quite sure why Vassar is so prominently mentioned either.

I’m not seeing Macalester or Carleton either.

We didn’t get the same sense as OP did when we visited Bryn Mawr, or Wellesey which someone mentioned above, for that matter. In both cases our primary take-away was more more “everyone is working hard”. I too felt Bryn Mawr was too small, YMMV. But Wellesley made it up to D1s final cut. Yes there are liberal students there, but it wasn’t everybody. From what I observed, at the time. D1 wasn’t thrilled with the social aspects, however, in either case.

Our one relative who attended Rochester in recent times is today a doctor, and my wife has several friends from our generation who are also in the medical field. FWIW.

I agree that Wellesley doesn’t project a super duper liberal vibe. Bryn Mawr neither but more so than Wellesley. I’ve known more than a handful of young women who’ve attended Wellesley in the past 8 years. The vibe I’ve gathered from those women is that Wellesley is rigorous, competitive, with quite a few real Type As, a lot with interest in law school and IB. Some that I know loved it, others did not care for the atmosphere.

More reading from past CC threads:

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/2145604-liberal-arts-colleges-in-near-cities-p1.html (see links to other threads in post #23)

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/2090086-lac-suggestions-that-are-close-to-a-decent-size-city-p1.html

Thanks for all the additional comments and links. Grinnell is about 3 hours from grandparents so not that hard to visit. I thought we were going to visit this weekend because we are driving by on the interstate, but the timing didn’t work out. I’m guessing she will rule it out but Mom loves the location so it isn’t crossed off the list yet. Macalester and Carlton are not quite as convienent, but those 3 are the 3 that are a realistic driving distance from us. And I will be in Minneapolis this spring, possibly with her depending on how a couple things work out independent of college visits. So if we are there, it makes sense to stop by. She does really like the idea of Macalaster being located in St Paul. Although I agree that if I took location out of the equation none of those 3 would probably make the list.

Emory is interesting. Kind of a long list of requirements that seem not that bad but kind of a pain to deal with. I do have a couple friends in Atlanta though, so I like that better than sending her completely on her own. I think in reality it doesn’t matter, but it would make me feel better.

Tufts I need to look at.

Maybe it was just our guide at Bryn, I know that can make a huge difference both good and bad. And honestly I’m sure she is a nice young woman, she was very earnest in trying to sell her school and seemed to genuinely love it. But after an hour my daughter was kind of done, and the thought of spending 4 years surrounded by people like that did not sound like fun. I think if we had a different tour guide it might still be on the table.

If open curriculum is a big priority, Tufts probably won’t work. Lots of distribution requirements and if I recall correctly, 6 semesters of language.
College of the Holy Cross has excellent pre med placement, advising and mentoring and would checks a lot of boxes for your D, but they do have distribution requirements. Not as many as other schools and double majoring is definitely possible though.

If your daughter has the chance to visit Vassar, she could explore the political climate a little more and see how comfortable she feels. The curriculum is quite open except for a couple of requirements and I don’t think it is weak with regard to math. Also, it is worth noting that of several selective LACs to which my D17 was admitted, they offered the best financial aid package (there was quite a range).
I also agree with looking into U. Richmond.

From a quick glance at some old threads, some other schools OP might screen:

Lehigh U
Brandeis U
Carnegie Mellon U
Johns Hopkins U

All have their imperfections vs criteria, but so do most places. Application process can be what is best compromise, to an extent.

There’s something to be said for state U + saving money, for a pre-med with med school tuition maybe looming ahead. A lot, actually.

I think it has been mentioned already, but it may be the case that, at least at some schools, a lot of the distribution requirements can be met via prior AP courses, or courses your D will be taking anyway. I know D1 found that a lot of her distrbution requirements were already met, and basically took what she wanted. But I imagine it is very case-by-case.

I would vote for Case Western. An Eagle Scout I worked with is a current freshman and is getting 20,000 a year in merit aid. His mother is a doctor and his father is a manager at a high tech company. Under most circumstances, the kid would be full pay. Plus Case has EA.

Tufts has a lot of requirements that don’t really fit with what she wants I think. Which is too bad, I liked it until I saw that.

I did see EA for Case, which is a definite plus.

I already have a spreadsheet for NPC #'s and admissions info, I should probably add a column for curriculum openness. The problem is that it isn’t easy to see at first glance how well they work for her personally, it takes a bit of digging into.

Obviously I’ll have better info after the ACT.

I appreciate all of the comments, and will probably return with a similar but more focused thread in a few months. Right now you all have given some great guidance, thank you.

Right now your daughter’s list looks to be “Top something-or-other” and State U. Am I correct about that? Is she looking at anything a step down from Grinnell/Case/etc.? A sporty, but not recruitable, FFA, 4.0, 30 ACT, co-valedictorian student I know was very happy at Guilford. Kept up her GPA there, and landed in the right grad program for her goals. Guilford may be smaller than your daughter wants, but there also could be some place at that “not-top” range that she would like and would have merit money.

This list is full of reaches. I think this student needs more matches and safeties. We all know that it’s difficult for the average excellent student to get into reaches, and simply applying to a bunch of them isn’t a good strategy.

U Rochester sounds like a great fit to me and she’d probably be offered money, depending on her test scores. Expressing interest is important to them, but she’s visited which is good.

A useful thread from a couple of years ago: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/college-search-selection/2014605-list-of-schools-with-little-to-no-core-curriculum-or-have-great-flexibility-with-double-majors.html

Your daughter needs some more matches and a safety or two. There are also colleges that are so flexible that they might as well have an open curriculum. Look in the first page of that thread for good suggestions.

She may not necessarily need more matches, or any additional safeties.
The question is what shools might she like enough to pay more than she would have to pay for the state U. (if it works out that she would have to pay more, after realistic FA). Particularly given that med school $$ may follow.

Two of my kids used their state U as their safety. They had no other safeties.

(The other might have had a private U for a safety but she was accepted to her ED school before it mattered).

@Lindagaf first thanks for that thread. Second, that’s a fair assessment. We will probably want to round out the list a bit. She is just a junior though, not a senior. So we have a bit of time. What I’m trying to do is find the ideal, and then work backwards from there. I’m not really trying to put together a final application list yet. More of a wish list.

I do think finding a few good matches is important. Hopefully she can test well enough and put together a good enough overall package that schools like Rochester and Case Western are on that match list, which as of right now seem like schools that are going to be pretty high on her wish list.

I’ve seen a few people post that it’s really hard to find a safety they can fall in love with. If that’s where we end up, I’d rather keep some money in my pocket and just go with a school she is ok with and is in state. She should be able to get full tuition at the flagship, assuming her PreACT score translates to the ACT. She definitely will be auto-admit, and that scholarship is strictly based on ACT score so we should know this summer if she will qualify. Since she is pretty focused on medical or dental school that’s probably the smarter choice anyway, both for GPA protection and to save money for grad school. Most of the doctors I know around here went to the flagship and then to the in-state medical school.

We could easily end up where @monydad is suggesting. If after looking the only places that she likes more than the state U are all reaches, then that is probably what we will shoot for. My guess is that her list ends up being mostly reaches, a few high matches, and maybe a school or 2 that are admission safeties, but in reality only work if she gets good merit money. Off the top of my head, Lewis & Clark is one that she should easily be admitted to, but that wouldn’t make sense unless she received substantial merit.

The flagship would be the only real safety.

Does that sound like a reasonable plan? I genuinely want an honest response to that. I’ve certainly been wrong before, and have learned a lot from the advice i have received here. Thanks.