Need help figuring out a list

Sounds ok to me, FWIW, YMMv, etc.

It depends to some extent on what she thinks about attending the state u.
My D1 got a free ride to hers but would not go there; she didn’t want to stay in the state. On the other hand, my son liked the state u (in a different state, we moved) so much he wound up choosing it over a match private.

A couple things to keep in mind:

  • Real" test scores and remaining grades could make a huge diference.
  • If there's a school she otherwise likes, except for distribution requirements, suggest do check if some of the requirements there can be satisfied with suitable AP scores. Like I mentioned before, D1 was able to satisfy her colleger's distribution requirements largely with AP credits. This won't fly at some other schools, and yet others will still make one take a more advanced course there to fill the requirement. It varies.

I don’t think the AP’s will help her with distribution req. all that much. She will still need the math, science and writing classes taken in college as med school prereqs. If she uses AP she is just supposed to take a more advanced class. History would work, but she likes those classes and will want to take more anyway. It would be helpful for some kids, just not really for her situation. AP Spanish will help, but only to the extent it lets her place into a more advanced language course.

However, due to those divergent interests, she is going to hit quite a few distribution requirements most places anyway. Math? Science? English? All required for her as a pre-med. History either as a major or as classes she is taking for fun anyway. I just looked at Northeastern’s requirements, and they are many and confusing in my opinion. However, when I searched for classes that met the criteria, it looks like only 2-3 extra classes from what she would take anyway. It may mean that she needs to take a history class in a particular area, but honestly she is interested in most of them anyway so for her at least that part isn’t a deal breaker, at least at this stage.

Has your daughter ruled out Northwestern? A reach for everyone these days, but great middle size and very pleasant location in a leafy suburb adjoining Chicago. They claim to meet full need, without loans. Nice mix of brainy, arty, music-oriented, etc., not too Greek.

Hey. I know we’ve talked about a lot of this over the past few months. As you know, we were struggling a bit when we started our process. What we did to get started was focus on big picture issues–location, weather, school size, urban/rural, etc. One good analog might be a trip to the eye doctor, and he pops up two slightly different lenses, and you have to choose between them: A or B? C or D? And in time we were able to hone in on an optimal set of qualities for my daughter, even though she would have been unable to articulate them when we started. We also decided that she would only go across the country for a true superior school–for her that was Stanford, which she wasn’t interested in. We figured that for all other schools in the other half of the country, we could find something pretty similar much closer, and probably in the same time zone where we are. So, since we are on the east coast, we knocked out everything west of the Mississippi (other than Washington U–close enough). I think the key is to start stripping down those preferences. For my daughter, we recognized that she really loved learning from her peers through discussion-based classes, and likes building a relationship with her teachers, and that pushed us in the direction of the LACs.

I wish I could give you some color on Rochester. I graduated 30 years ago, and haven’t been back. Back then, though, the work load was heavy, and the early pre-med classes were definitely used to cull down the students. I don’t know what it is like now. Also, don’t minimize the weather–if your daughter is the sort of person whose moods shift based on the amount of sunshine they receive, it would be a red flag.

I have one other thought, and this is something I have come to believe more and more recently. Like most smart people, your daughter will likely eventually take a job in a big city, maybe Philly or Washington or Boston, etc. College may be the only time to experience life in a small town–really experience it. Why not take advantage of that opportunity? To me, that’s reason enough to shy away from the Chicagos and Columbias and Penns in favor of, say, Dartmouth or Amherst, or perhaps a school in a mid-size metro area like Brown or Vandy. But I think the key is to focus on really narrowing down those specific preferences as best you can.

Northwestern is definitely not ruled out. But it may be a bit more of a reach, just because they probably get more applications from around here. Not many kids from her HS or frankly our state apply to schools on the East Coast, at least comparatively. It might be a harder admit for her than Harvard or Yale.

@RayManta the eye doctor analogy is a good one, I may try that with her. Right now she is missing 4 days of school for a national convention, and since we are on the block system that’s like missing 8 days of regular classes. So she isn’t really going to be up to discussing this for a week or 2 until she gets caught up. I think she feels like she gave me bunch to work with last week, now she wants me to do some investigating. She obviously has opinions, but doesn’t really want to sort through hundreds of schools. She wants me to bring her a manageable number, which is why I ask questions here. But I think I will use that tool to help narrow things down the next time we discuss it.

It’s funny how our personal experiences shape the way we view things. I kind of took your last point from the opposite point of view. We live just outside a town of 30,000, which is where she has spent her whole life, at least the part she is old enough to remember. In some ways I think it would be good for her to do something like Penn or Northeastern or Northwestern, because it might be her only chance to live in a real city! If she stays on the medical/dental route, there are plenty of jobs in the smaller towns and cities, and I can see her either returning here or maybe seeking out somewhere slightly larger but in the 100-300,000 range in the midwest.

I lived in NYC for 3 years and then in the first ring of suburbs for 3 1/2 years, and while I didn’t love it enough to stay and raise my family there I think it was a great experience. It gives me more perspective and empathy I think. I’ve lived in NYC, and I’ve also lived on a rural cattle ranch. Short of moving to Alaska or Hawaii I’ve hit the extremes. I want her to have that experience too.

There could be intellectual value in skipping introductory level courses when allowed to with AP credit and taking more advanced courses in their place to learn something new or more in depth.

Also, pre-meds who repeat AP credit may have to mark “repeat” on their medical school applications for those college courses which repeat AP credit.

@ucbalumnus I’m not that familiar with how that works. Would that only be if she took college credit for the AP and then retook the same intro course? For example, say she gets a 5 on the AP Chem exam. But she didn’t take it as a dual credit course in HS, and she never reported it to her college to try to get credit. Would it still show up as “repeat”? Or is that just if she takes college credit for the 5, and then still takes the intro class anyway?

My guess is that it would depend on the level of school she is at whether she would try to advance or not. If she is at the State U then she might. But if she heads to a more selective school she probably should take their intro course. This is just anecdotal because it is exactly 1 student. But I know a freshman at an Ivy in intro Chem right now. He got a 5 on his AP exam, and is struggling in the Ivy Class. I would assume that if he skipped ahead to the next semester and relied on his HS prep in the AP class he would be totally lost. My thinking was that for her in that case she should just not use the AP credits and take the intro courses (Bio, Chem and Calc will probably be the ones where she would have that option).

I’d spend a lot more time getting her to love the flagship, appreciate the money she’d likely save there, emphasis the opportunities she’d find there (big labs, internships, top professors working on big projects). You can always learn to love the higher ranked schools but it is much harder to take a step back when she has her heart set on a very expensive LAC that you can’t afford.

I think I can afford the “full need” schools, so that part isn’t a huge concern.

The danger though is that she falls in love with Brown or Rochester or Amherst or all of them, and doesn’t get into any of them. That’s a real risk for anyone I think. So you are right about trying to get her to love the flagship. I don’t think she will ever quite get there, to be honest. But I think she already appreciates that it would be an easier path to get the GPA she needs for med school. So that would be a nice consolation prize in the college admissions game I guess. One of her brothers is there right now, and he likes it. I’m planning on taking her there sometime (probably in the summer) to check it out.

Her big issue I think is that she knows a lot of kids who are mediocre students who go there. Also her other brother (the one she is super competitive with) is at an Ivy right now. I think by any objective standard she is smarter than him. So if she doesn’t get in anywhere that will be tough to swallow I think.

I don’t know the exact process, but I would expect that she would be accepted into the honors program at the flagship, which I think would also take some of the sting out of not getting into a selective school I think. I’m hoping when she hears about that and what it involves she will get a bit more enthusiastic about the flagship.

If you are visiting, Smith and Amherst are obviously a 2-for-1, they’re 15 minutes apart. Maybe add Mount Holyoke too, though it’s pretty rural it’s about the same distance.

Absolutely zero weed out culture at Amherst, and from what D said, Smith either (though she only took 2 classes there, as a senior). Pre-med advising at Amherst is very strong and starts as soon as kids arrive on campus (like that first week).

I feel like Emory DOES have a weed-out culture, and a lot of pre-meds. Maybe take a look at that, Emory at Oxford might do better.

My D felt the same way. Though she went to Amherst (great college town but not a city), she did internships in a huge city for 2 of her 3 college summers, and studied/did research abroad in a large foreign capital city for 6 months - and returned for research there a second time for a month. Lots of living-in-city time, by the end.

RE #62: "If she uses AP she is just supposed to take a more advanced class. "

What I’ve been trying to tell you is that is not necessarily, universally the case, and it should be checked at each school where it may be the one apparent stumbling block.

And the reason I say this is, again, my D1 was able to fill some distribution requirements with APs and was not required to take more advanced courses in those areas instead. At that time, at her college.

And re last paragraph of #62:
If it’s the case that she would have to, or want to, take courses in most or all areas that would constitute the distribution requirements at a partivcular college , then why the emphasis on having an “open curriculum” ? To me, it might not be worth it to turn down an otherwise perfect school just to avoid taking zero to two courses of somewhat less interest, if those turn out to be the numbers. YMMV.

@monydad I think we are talking past each other a bit, because I don’t really disagree with what you are saying. So I’m not trying to argue here, just explain:

Regarding the AP issue, She should have tests in history, math, english, spanish, and science.

I agree that at many schools, she could use some of these to satisfy the school’s requirements. However, in the case of history, that is a subject she is very interested in, and will probably either be a history major or be using up some of her free electives in the history department anyway. So no real help there. Spanish it could get her around a language requirement depending on the school and how much foreign language they require.

For English, Chem, Bio, Calc and Stats, or in-state medical school, which is by far the one she would be most likely to attend, does not accept AP credits in place of their pre-med requirements. They explicity state “for example, if you take AP credits for inorganic chemistry, then you are expected to take 2 more semesters of inorganic chemistry with lab beyond the introductory courses”. It is like that for everything. If you take your Calc 1 credit, they expect you to take Calc 2. So while her college might not require it, for her it is a requirement, no matter where she goes.

RE: the open curicculum:

That’s really why I’m hoping for something without a bunch of requirements. Because I think she has 14 pre-med required classes, plus a few like genetics that aren’t required but are “highly recommended”. So between say 18 or so classes she has to or should take for pre-med, and say 10 or so for a major, that allows her about 4 free electives, if she is at a school that requires 32 classes. That isn’t many, and while we can debate the merits of particular requirements, she doesn’t want to waste one on a fine arts class or something else she isn’t interested in when she could instead take another semester of calculus. What can I say, she’s a different cat. I guess that’s the point of the open curicculum, you take the 3rd semester of ceramics (which I use as an example because she just finished struggling through that class), and I’ll take the 3rd semester of calculus. And we both think that there is something wrong with you that you are doing it your way and not my way.

This is the kind of information that is super helpful. Thank you.

Our tour guide said there wasn’t a weed out culture at Rochester. I have since been told by a couple sources that is not really accurate. Which I sort of expected, but it is still dissapointing.

I think at most schools, gone are the days of “look right, look left, those people won’t be sitting next to you at graduation.” Schools want to maintain their 4 year graduation rates.

That said, some schools have a more collaborative vibe than others and some are known for being more competitive.

@momofsenior1 I think you are right in terms of graduation.

But I think it hasn’t gone away, just changed slightly. The modern version is “Look right, look left, those people won’t be sitting next to you in second semester organic. They will be sociology majors.”

LOL!

You can ask for the data from the schools to see how many students stay in the major. That was a big question for us with engineering programs.

My sense now is that the selection process happens during the application process. They aren’t taking kids they don’t think can succeed.

Re #77, I’d be surprised if colleges would make attrition data by major available.
Leave aside data for students who had not yet declared a major, but had been thinking about it, before they took orgo, etc. Which is perhaps more relevant.

And though colleges may be taking kids who they think can succeed (eg graduate), that doesn’t mean they think all of them are likely to make dean’s list (or equivalent), which is where their grades need to be to be competitive for med school I’m guessing.

FWIW, Georgetown came to mind, seems right-size and in a city. For that matter Notre Dame, if 318,000 SMSA is big enough for her.
I don’t know anything about course requirements though.