Just a story about the application process for S17. I had no idea that merit aid was different from school to school. I did not know that some schools gave a lot while others did not. I just let my son apply where he thought he wanted to go and figured it would work out in the end. We are from Colorado and he wanted to be in the marching band in the Big 10. Since there were no schools in the Big 10 here, we did a road trip through the mid-west. We visited Minnesota, Michigan, Notre Dame (I know, not Big 10), Ohio State and Wisconsin.
S liked most of the schools but absolutely fell in LOVE with Wisconsin. It was the one he wanted, the one he could see himself at.
S decided to apply to Ohio State, Minnesota, Wisconsin and Notre Dame. He also applied to other schools at either my urging or his mothers urging.
THEN I found CC and started reading. I found that not all schools give merit. Not all schools give merit equally.
The acceptance season was upon us and S did quite well. He did not get into his two reaches (Notre Dame and Vanderbilt) but he did get into every other school he applied to, including Wisconsin. He was going to be a Badger after all!. Then the merit scholarships started to come in. He got $10K per year from Minnesota and $15K per year from Ohio State. He got scholarships from most of the other schools he applied to but nothing came from Wisconsin.
Then the financial packages came in. Minnesota was affordable. Ohio State was in budget too. Wisconsin was double Minnesota. No way we could swing it financially as his brother was going to be headed to school the following year.
As we approached the May 1 commit date, my son was struggling with his decision. He really wanted somehow to go to Wisconsin (outside scholarships, Lottery, etc.) so it was making it impossible for him to decide where to do. I suggested that he put Wisconsin aside and choose between the schools left and if we “came into some money” we could confirm at Wisconsin. That seemed to get him past his block.
We visted his final 2 choices (Minnesota and Miami of Ohio) and he decided on Minnesota. We confirmed and as you could expect, we did not come into any “extra money”.
He just finished his first semester and is a Gopher to the core. He even hates Wisconsin now as all good Minnesota Gophers do.
So, moral of the story is to make sure that you can afford a school before you apply. That is why my S18 did not apply to the tippy top schools, even if accepted, we would not be able to send him.