Son wants to decommit from football [at college 2.5 hours away] and stay at [commute to] local college [no ED, similar cost, both good for major]

Nervous to leave home

It’s mostly the unknown and leaving home. Talking through it we have addressed many questions and unknowns so hopefully that does not get in his way still.

He is a kicker/punter so very minimal impact.

I have been reading this thread without commenting. However, two things come to mind.

Your son needs to decide this. He is the one who will be attending class, doing homework, studying for tests, and optionally playing football. Doing all of the above is a lot.

Personally, if I had a son, I would be nervous about him playing football. Injuries do happen, including brain injuries.

Much like @Mewuser we also have a daughter who was very good at music. At some point our daughter similarly more or less dropped it. I loved her music and was her biggest fan and was sorry when she dropped it. However, this was her decision. Instead she started focusing even more on academics, and if all continues to go well will be called “doctor” in May (veterinary medicine). She found the right path for her.

Again, this was her decision. Similarly, whether to continue with football is your son’s decision.

And it is not easy to be a parent and watch while this happens.

4 Likes

Then injury is unlikely. But you still need to let him decide for himself.

1 Like

No, it means he can’t accept an athletic scholarship to play at another NLI-participating school (most D1 and D2 schools, but not Ivies or service academies) for one academic year. He could attend any other school he wants to, and play at a D3 or an NAIA immediately. No one can force him to go to a school, even if he signs an NLI and it doesn’t change merit or other non-sports scholarships at other schools. Also, because of the transfer portal, it’s unlikely an athlete can’t get around this and play at the new school. Signing the NLI may prevent him from being a walk on at the local school if he still had dreams of that.

I’d suggest he contact the coach (or the position coach) at the out of town school. Have him be honest, that he’s having doubts and needs more time. I think the coach would suggest another visit, maybe with a teammate or maybe just for the academics and other school offerings (probably go to a basketball game, attend a class, go to a party with teammates). The school can hold off on the NLI too, and if he doesn’t sign in Feb he can sign in April or not sign at all. It ISN’T a requirement that an athlete sign, even if there is a scholarship involved. I know D1 athletes who never signed one and they still got scholarships. The opposite isn’t true; if they sign, they must get a grant-in-aid.

If he contacts the coach and the coach says ‘sign or stay home’ then he has the answer. I don’t think the coach will do that as most coaches don’t want a player who doesn’t want to be there so won’t force him to sign when he’s not ready.

1 Like

This topic was automatically closed 180 days after the last reply. If you’d like to reply, please flag the thread for moderator attention.